Economy/Trade War/EU & PRC/Debts/Hukou Change

China: The Shift to a More Autarkic Governance Regime Will Hurt the Economy and Investors

Trade War/Huawei/Stocks/Tiananmen/Electric Vehicles

Global Asset Allocation, Politics & Governance, Ecstrat

John-Paul Smith

Global Asset Allocation, Politics & Governance

Ecstrat

Ecstrat is a consultancy advising on asset allocation between global equity markets, with a focus on the intersection of governments, geopolitics, governance and markets.
 
Over the past few years and more especially since the Great Financial Crisis (GFC), investors have become more focused on short-term market movements and real-time returns and have consequently neglected the analysis of the underlying structural themes that underpin longer term performance.
​
More specifically we believe that the evolution of governance-based relationships between investors, controlling shareholders, labour and the state is one of the primary determinants of both relative and absolute performance between individual equity markets.
 
We will endeavour to provide investors with some of the context surrounding governance-related issues which encompass many different disciplines including history, economics and political science, as well as the financial metrics which are the most obvious manifestation of the structural characteristics of each market.
 
We will pay particular attention to the shifts and potential inflection points for governance in individual markets as these are often the best lead indicators for both economic and market performance.

Cross Asset Strategy

The Chinese onshore and offshore equity markets have been outstanding performers over Q1, due to; i) rising hopes of a trade settlement with the US; ii) expectations of easier monetary policy from the Fed in response to the weakness in the global economy partly emanating from China and iii) the increased representation of Chinese onshore debt and equity securities in the most widely followed global indices.
However, the Chinese authorities are both unwilling and unable to tackle the underlying causes of financial fragility in the local government and industrial sectors, by imposing a hard budget constraint that would trigger a series of potentially systemic crises. The inflows of cash from overseas are therefore merely helping Beijing to kick the proverbial can further down the road in the absence of significant structural reforms.
Chinese equities listed offshore ranked 11th cheapest out of 48 global markets at the end of March down from 5th at the start of January, according to the Ecstrat sector-adjusted valuation table, based on a median stock rather than a market cap weighted methodology. I remain underweight for structural reasons despite the very strong buying momentum from both domestic and foreign investors.

The Chinese onshore and offshore equity markets have been outstanding performers over Q1, due to; i) rising hopes of a trade settlement with the US; ii) expectations of easier monetary policy from the Fed in response to the weakness in the global economy partly emanating from China and iii) the increased representation of Chinese onshore debt and equity securities in the most widely followed global indices.
However, the Chinese authorities are both unwilling and unable to tackle the underlying causes of financial fragility in the local government and industrial sectors, by imposing a hard budget constraint that would trigger a series of potentially systemic crises. The inflows of cash from overseas are therefore merely helping Beijing to kick the proverbial can further down the road in the absence of significant structural reforms.
Chinese equities listed offshore ranked 11th cheapest out of 48 global markets at the end of March down from 5th at the start of January, according to the Ecstrat sector-adjusted valuation table, based on a median stock rather than a market cap weighted methodology. I remain underweight for structural reasons despite the very strong buying momentum from both domestic and foreign investors.

China - Not Out of the Woods by Any Means