Silver Point

Thomas J. Monaco

Independent Insight Provider

Silver Point is a boutique research firm that focuses on the broader financial services sector, with a particular focus on troubled institutions globally. 

Asia Ex Japan

Equity Bottom-Up

*Results Highly Reliant On Gains: Canara Bank (CBK.IN) [Canara] reported bottom-line results of INR 10.1 bn for FY 4Q21, improving INR 6.0 bn (85.5%) linked quarter. Results were driven one factor alone: am INR 9.3 bn (21.8%) increase in various sundry gains - securities, F/X, et al. As awe calculate, these various low quality items and gains amounted to INR 48.9 bn during FY 4Q21 or nearly 5x Canara’s stated bottom-line result; and  * Credit Leads To Solvency Concerns: Given the INR 27.3 bn in NCO, we calculate that annualized net new NPLs amount to 21.7%. We remain highly concerned about Canara’s credit outlook, given the concentrations of SMA loans, ‘BBB’ and below corporate, and MSME loans; and poor collection efficiency.  By our calculation, Canara’s loan loss reserve falls short by INR 674.0 bn or by 180.2% - representing 115% of Canara’s equity base and implying a lack of solvency.

*Results Highly Reliant On Gains: Canara Bank (CBK.IN) [Canara] reported bottom-line results of INR 10.1 bn for FY 4Q21, improving INR 6.0 bn (85.5%) linked quarter. Results were driven one factor alone: am INR 9.3 bn (21.8%) increase in various sundry gains - securities, F/X, et al. As awe calculate, these various low quality items and gains amounted to INR 48.9 bn during FY 4Q21 or nearly 5x Canara’s stated bottom-line result; and  * Credit Leads To Solvency Concerns: Given the INR 27.3 bn in NCO, we calculate that annualized net new NPLs amount to 21.7%. We remain highly concerned about Canara’s credit outlook, given the concentrations of SMA loans, ‘BBB’ and below corporate, and MSME loans; and poor collection efficiency.  By our calculation, Canara’s loan loss reserve falls short by INR 674.0 bn or by 180.2% - representing 115% of Canara’s equity base and implying a lack of solvency.

Canara Bank – India’s Trash Compactor

*Another Unwarranted Provision Reduction: Federal Bank’s (FB.IN) results were likely managed, as it posted FY 4Q21 bottom-line result of INR 4.8 bn – improving INR 737 mn (18.2%) linked quarter. One factor, which was simply ridiculous, given the state of Federal Bank’s balance sheet, drove the improvement – aggressively cutting loss provisions again; and*Reserve Cover Is Shallow: Net new problem loans increased INR 8.4 bn or 78.4% on an annualized basis – dangerously accelerating over FY 3Q21. We remain discouraged that management hasn’t taken the opportunity to more aggressively address the risk sitting pon balance sheet. In fact, we find that reserve cover is increasingly light by close to INR 84.5 bn (versus being short INR 50.0 bn just a quarter ago) – nearly 20 years of core operating performance.

*Another Unwarranted Provision Reduction: Federal Bank’s (FB.IN) results were likely managed, as it posted FY 4Q21 bottom-line result of INR 4.8 bn – improving INR 737 mn (18.2%) linked quarter. One factor, which was simply ridiculous, given the state of Federal Bank’s balance sheet, drove the improvement – aggressively cutting loss provisions again; and*Reserve Cover Is Shallow: Net new problem loans increased INR 8.4 bn or 78.4% on an annualized basis – dangerously accelerating over FY 3Q21. We remain discouraged that management hasn’t taken the opportunity to more aggressively address the risk sitting pon balance sheet. In fact, we find that reserve cover is increasingly light by close to INR 84.5 bn (versus being short INR 50.0 bn just a quarter ago) – nearly 20 years of core operating performance.    

Federal Bank – A Five Year Hole Has Developed

Chief Economist & Political Strategist, CrossASEAN Research

Prasenjit K. Basu

Chief Economist & Political Strategist

CrossASEAN Research

At CrossASEAN Research we strive to produce unbiased and differentiated on the ground insights on companies across South East Asia. Our Research is produced for the most part after face to face meetings and conversations with company management to dig deep into the long term vision and strategy of the companies we cover. We seek to deliver investable and actionable themes on sectors and markets across SE Asia, often in collaboration with other Insight Providers across the region, pooling the vast experience of the analysts within the Smartkarma Ecosystem. We also offer bespoke work and tailor made trips for our clients. 

Insights across South East Asia

Macroeconomics

We recommend staying underweight India until the 7-day moving average of Covid cases turns down (likely no sooner than mid-May). There would then be an excellent buying opportunity: we have lowered our forecast of real GDP growth in FY2020/21 to 12% (from 13.5%), but the vaccine roll-out (with 60% of all those above 45 likely to have been vaccinated by the end of this month) should wrestle the new Covid case numbers down from peaks by end-May. A current account surplus, liquid banks, and a reformed, privatization-driven policy framework should ensure that the rebound is delayed but not halted by this virulent Second Covid wave.  When the IMF was forecasting 8.8% real GDP growth for FY2021/22 and the consensus was 8-9%, we raised our forecast to 12.5% in December 2020 -- and to 13.5% at the beginning of February 2021 (post the reform-oriented Budget). Now that the IMF has caught up with our end-2020 forecast, we are lowering ours to 12%, acknowledging the huge uncertainties induced by this 2nd Covid wave. Given the low base in April-May 2020, YoY growth rates for production will barely budge, but private consumption will likely weaken during these months as retailers in key hotspots (including Delhi, Mumbai, Bengaluru) will stay shut during 2-week curfews/lockdowns. The current account surplus of 1.5% of GDP in 2021, and loan-deposit ratio of 72%, imply there is ample external and domestic liquidity to spur a strong economic recovery once lockdowns are lifted. At 145 million vaccinations, 17.7% of the adult population (18 &amp; over) or 57% of all those eligible (45 &amp; over) have had at least one vaccine dose. This is far from achieving herd immunity, but faster vaccinations from June should allow over a billion people to be vaccinated by end-2021. Lockdowns and curfews are proving effective in Maharashtra and Delhi (the worst hotspots), but will now roll through several other states. But the base effects will help the YoY growth rates in April-May. In March 2020 there was only a week's disruption, but exports were up 60% YoY (imports 53% YoY) in March 2021, steel output up a world-leading 23.9% YoY and car production up 79% YoY in March 2021. April and May 2020 were almost wiped out economically, so the YoY growth rates will still be spectacular in Apr-May 2021, given the strong underlying momentum.The disruptions to consumption (especially) and production should be made up in the next few months. The low corporate tax rate, reformed labour market and production-linked incentives should induce a powerful surge in investment, with privatization and asset-monetization providing an extra fillip as they are implemented during the course of the year. We do not expect the liquid banking system (L-D ratio 72%) to contribute to the rebound until early-2022, with early-recapitalization of state-owned banks helping a bit, but privatizations providing a bigger spur.

We recommend staying underweight India until the 7-day moving average of Covid cases turns down (likely no sooner than mid-May). There would then be an excellent buying opportunity: we have lowered our forecast of real GDP growth in FY2020/21 to 12% (from 13.5%), but the vaccine roll-out (with 60% of all those above 45 likely to have been vaccinated by the end of this month) should wrestle the new Covid case numbers down from peaks by end-May. A current account surplus, liquid banks, and a reformed, privatization-driven policy framework should ensure that the rebound is delayed but not halted by this virulent Second Covid wave.  When the IMF was forecasting 8.8% real GDP growth for FY2021/22 and the consensus was 8-9%, we raised our forecast to 12.5% in December 2020 -- and to 13.5% at the beginning of February 2021 (post the reform-oriented Budget). Now that the IMF has caught up with our end-2020 forecast, we are lowering ours to 12%, acknowledging the huge uncertainties induced by this 2nd Covid wave. Given the low base in April-May 2020, YoY growth rates for production will barely budge, but private consumption will likely weaken during these months as retailers in key hotspots (including Delhi, Mumbai, Bengaluru) will stay shut during 2-week curfews/lockdowns. The current account surplus of 1.5% of GDP in 2021, and loan-deposit ratio of 72%, imply there is ample external and domestic liquidity to spur a strong economic recovery once lockdowns are lifted. At 145 million vaccinations, 17.7% of the adult population (18 &amp; over) or 57% of all those eligible (45 &amp; over) have had at least one vaccine dose. This is far from achieving herd immunity, but faster vaccinations from June should allow over a billion people to be vaccinated by end-2021. Lockdowns and curfews are proving effective in Maharashtra and Delhi (the worst hotspots), but will now roll through several other states. But the base effects will help the YoY growth rates in April-May. In March 2020 there was only a week's disruption, but exports were up 60% YoY (imports 53% YoY) in March 2021, steel output up a world-leading 23.9% YoY and car production up 79% YoY in March 2021. April and May 2020 were almost wiped out economically, so the YoY growth rates will still be spectacular in Apr-May 2021, given the strong underlying momentum.The disruptions to consumption (especially) and production should be made up in the next few months. The low corporate tax rate, reformed labour market and production-linked incentives should induce a powerful surge in investment, with privatization and asset-monetization providing an extra fillip as they are implemented during the course of the year. We do not expect the liquid banking system (L-D ratio 72%) to contribute to the rebound until early-2022, with early-recapitalization of state-owned banks helping a bit, but privatizations providing a bigger spur.   

India: 2nd Covid Wave Will Delay (Not Halt) The Strength of the Economic Rebound

*Improved Operating Performance: ICICI Bank (ICICIBC.IN/IBN.US) [ICICI] reported FY 4Q21 earnings of INR 44.0 bn, decreasing INR 5.4 bn (10.9%) linked quarter. Excluding gains, FY 4Q21 core operating results increased INR 2.5 bn (6.5%) over the same period. In our view, ICICI’s results were of higher quality than last quarter; and*Credit Improvement Coming: With NCOs of INR 42.2 bn, we find that net new NPLs actually continued to increase - up INR 34.9 bn or at a decelerated pace of 33.1% on an annualized basis. With credit quality continuing to breakdown at ICICI and virtually every financial institution in India, we find that ICICI – like its competitors, is still short on reserves to the tune of INR 229 bn or four quarters of PBT.

*Improved Operating Performance: ICICI Bank (ICICIBC.IN/IBN.US) [ICICI] reported FY 4Q21 earnings of INR 44.0 bn, decreasing INR 5.4 bn (10.9%) linked quarter. Excluding gains, FY 4Q21 core operating results increased INR 2.5 bn (6.5%) over the same period. In our view, ICICI’s results were of higher quality than last quarter; and*Credit Improvement Coming: With NCOs of INR 42.2 bn, we find that net new NPLs actually continued to increase - up INR 34.9 bn or at a decelerated pace of 33.1% on an annualized basis. With credit quality continuing to breakdown at ICICI and virtually every financial institution in India, we find that ICICI – like its competitors, is still short on reserves to the tune of INR 229 bn or four quarters of PBT.

*Earnings Miss: HDFC Bank (HDFCB.IN) [HDFCB] released a weak FY 4Q21 balance sheet update several weeks back, following it up with an even more disappointing FY 4Q21 bottom-line result of INR 81.9  bn - declining INR 5.7 bn (6.5%) on a linked quarter basis. The earnings disappointment came from both an increase in loss provisions and costs; and*Credit Challenged Still: Restructured loans did increase INR 10 bn (19.8%) linked quarter to INR 65 bn or 0.6% of loans. Inclusive of NCOs of INR 49.0 bn during the quarter, we calculate that net new NPLs actually increased INR 49.2 bn or 130.4% on an annualized basis which  is quite worrisome – especially considering the challenges at HDFCB’s NBFC subsidiary, HDB Financial Services.  We would be more comfortable if HDFCB was a bit more aggressive with its provisions. By our calculation, reserves are currently short by nearly INR 242 bn or nearly a half year of core operating results.

*Earnings Miss: HDFC Bank (HDFCB.IN) [HDFCB] released a weak FY 4Q21 balance sheet update several weeks back, following it up with an even more disappointing FY 4Q21 bottom-line result of INR 81.9  bn - declining INR 5.7 bn (6.5%) on a linked quarter basis. The earnings disappointment came from both an increase in loss provisions and costs; and*Credit Challenged Still: Restructured loans did increase INR 10 bn (19.8%) linked quarter to INR 65 bn or 0.6% of loans. Inclusive of NCOs of INR 49.0 bn during the quarter, we calculate that net new NPLs actually increased INR 49.2 bn or 130.4% on an annualized basis which  is quite worrisome – especially considering the challenges at HDFCB’s NBFC subsidiary, HDB Financial Services.  We would be more comfortable if HDFCB was a bit more aggressive with its provisions. By our calculation, reserves are currently short by nearly INR 242 bn or nearly a half year of core operating results.   

India

iShares MSCI India ETF is an exchange-traded fund incorporated in the USA. The ETF seeks investment results that correspond generally to the price and yield performance, before fees and expenses, of the MSCI India Index.

iShares MSCI India ETF (INDA US)

Canara Bank – India’s Trash Compactor

CANARA BANK: Canara reported QOQ bottom-line improvement of 85.5%, reliant on gains. Net new NPLs amount to 21.7%, but its reserve shortfall...

Thomas J. Monaco

Federal Bank – A Five Year Hole Has Developed

FEDERAL BANK: FB's FY 4Q21 bottom-line QOQ result improved 18.2% due to an unwarranted provision cut. Net new NPLs accelerated 78.4% QOQ, while ...

Thomas J. Monaco

India: 2nd Covid Wave Will Delay (Not Halt) The Strength of the Economic Rebound

Underweight India near-term amid Covid uncertainty. But real GDP still to grow 12% in FY2021/22, with output growth aided by ultralow base in Apr...

Prasenjit K. Basu

ICICI Bank – Much Better

ICICI BANK: ICICI reported a 6.5% linked quarter improvement in FY 4Q21 operating results. Credit weakness is still there, but the breakdown in net...

Thomas J. Monaco

HDFC Bank – Big Credit Disappointment

HDFC BANK: HDFCB released a disappointing FY 4Q21 bottom-line, declining 6.5% QOQ, due higher provisions and costs. Net new NPLs increased 130.4%...

Thomas J. Monaco