Financials Credit Analyst

Hank Calenti, CFA

CreditContinuum

Credit

Executive Summary:<a href="https://www.smartkarma.com/entities/societe-generale-sa" target="_blank" data-smartkarma-citation="entities:21478:1" rel="noopener">Société Générale (SocGen)</a> recently presented plans to target sustained profitability with a lower standard deviation of performance in its Corporate and Investment Banking (CIB) unit. The firm produced its first annual loss in 30 years from equity derivative positioning as firms cut their prior year dividends due to Covid-19 concerns. As such, SocGen intends to make its results less sensitive to market dislocations.Late last year, SocGen announced a retail banking restructuring plan which effectively increases the resolution potential of the firm should it reach the point of non-viability (PoNV). Taken on its own, this move was not bondholder friendly. Please see: <a href="https://www.smartkarma.com/compose/insight/52061/Soci%C3%A9t%C3%A9%20G%C3%A9n%C3%A9rale%20AT1:%20Resolution%20or%20Resilience%20in%20the%20Retail%20Restructuring?%20Take%20Shorter%20Duration.%20Read%20more:%20https://skr.ma/U3otL" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Société Générale AT1: Resolution or Resilience in the Retail Restructuring?</a> for more details.However, the bank’s plans and actions already undertaken to reduce the volatility in the global markets’ operations may reduce the likelihood of approaching the PoNV. Combined with a meaningful buffer of capital above the level at which Additional Tier 1 bond suspension could be required, SocGen’s AT1 bonds may be ripe for picking.

Executive Summary:Société Générale (SocGen) recently presented plans to target sustained profitability with a lower standard deviation of performance in its Corporate and Investment Banking (CIB) unit. The firm produced its first annual loss in 30 years from equity derivative positioning as firms cut their prior year dividends due to Covid-19 concerns. As such, SocGen intends to make its results less sensitive to market dislocations.Late last year, SocGen announced a retail banking restructuring plan which effectively increases the resolution potential of the firm should it reach the point of non-viability (PoNV). Taken on its own, this move was not bondholder friendly. Please see: Société Générale AT1: Resolution or Resilience in the Retail Restructuring? for more details.However, the bank’s plans and actions already undertaken to reduce the volatility in the global markets’ operations may reduce the likelihood of approaching the PoNV. Combined with a meaningful buffer of capital above the level at which Additional Tier 1 bond suspension could be required, SocGen’s AT1 bonds may be ripe for picking.

SocGen: AT1 Is Ripe for Picking as CIB Is Restructured

Executive Summary: <a href="https://www.smartkarma.com/entities/unicredit-spa" target="_blank" data-smartkarma-citation="entities:21234:1" rel="noopener">UniCredit (UCGIM)</a> shocked bond markets recently by announcing that it would not be paying the coupon on its CASHES legacy Tier 1 notes. Subsequently, adding confusion to this saga, Bloomberg reports that some investors received notification of a coupon payment. Operational risk anyone?Nonetheless, we believe value can be had in the firm’s Senior Non-Preferred (NPS) securities. Rated Baa2, BBB- and BB+ by Moody’s, S&amp;P and Fitch respectively, these securities are Bank of America Merrill Lynch index eligible, which aids in their liquidity.The real risk for UCGIM bondholders going forward is two-fold. One, the firm may engage in consolidation beyond absorbing a cleaner <a href="https://www.smartkarma.com/entities/banca-monte-dei-paschi-di-siena" target="_blank" data-smartkarma-citation="entities:21162:1" rel="noopener">Banca Monte dei Paschi di Siena (BMPS IM)</a>. The risk here is over-extending into another asset quality quagmire. Two, investor risk perceptions regarding Italy could deteriorate. We think the former, that is excessive M&amp;A activity, is more likely than the latter over the near term.Cancelling the CASHES coupon payment shortly after Mr. Orcel’s arrival is not a good omen. Possibly paying a coupon that was set to be cancelled is even worse. Nonetheless, we see UCGIM’s Senior Non-Preferred debt as offering an attractive risk/ reward opportunity.

Executive Summary: UniCredit (UCGIM) shocked bond markets recently by announcing that it would not be paying the coupon on its CASHES legacy Tier 1 notes. Subsequently, adding confusion to this saga, Bloomberg reports that some investors received notification of a coupon payment. Operational risk anyone?Nonetheless, we believe value can be had in the firm’s Senior Non-Preferred (NPS) securities. Rated Baa2, BBB- and BB+ by Moody’s, S&amp;P and Fitch respectively, these securities are Bank of America Merrill Lynch index eligible, which aids in their liquidity.The real risk for UCGIM bondholders going forward is two-fold. One, the firm may engage in consolidation beyond absorbing a cleaner Banca Monte dei Paschi di Siena (BMPS IM). The risk here is over-extending into another asset quality quagmire. Two, investor risk perceptions regarding Italy could deteriorate. We think the former, that is excessive M&amp;A activity, is more likely than the latter over the near term.Cancelling the CASHES coupon payment shortly after Mr. Orcel’s arrival is not a good omen. Possibly paying a coupon that was set to be cancelled is even worse. Nonetheless, we see UCGIM’s Senior Non-Preferred debt as offering an attractive risk/ reward opportunity.

UniCredit: CASHES Paid or Not, Senior Non-Preferred Offers Value

Executive Summary: Friday’s jobs report shocker capped off a week which included US Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen needing to be Mirandized. This was followed by the Fed stating the obvious in its financial stability report. Unmentioned in this report is that the role of this Fed is no longer to take away the punchbowl, but instead it is the bartender. The week ended with a jobs report that was the biggest miss in nominal terms, ever.The report was at odds with recent PMI surveys in which respondents stated that it was difficult to hire. This may be the result of frictions in hiring as unemployment benefits as well as child-care needs and postponed school re-openings delay employee re-entry. The truth serum for the US economy may occur around September when extended unemployment payments expire.The market impact was an immediate 10 basis point (bp) drop in the 10-year Treasury while the 2-year note even fell 1bp. Prices on the 10-year gave up these gains as the day progressed, but the smart money, that is the bond market, may be correct with the recent dampening of interest rates suggesting a longer time period to a less accommodative Fed.  The US Treasury bond curve ended the week flatter with short-end yields falling by much less than the longer part of the curve.With rates continuing to push credit spreads, Asia- and European-headquartered banks generated negative total returns in all but the lowest duration notes. There was a clear preference for Additional Tier 1 (AT1) bond issuance over the past week while over US$11 billion equivalent was raised by financial institutions globally in USD and Euros. In what may have been the busiest AT1 bond issuance weeks of the year, five institutions brought over US$6.5 billion in six securities.Nonetheless, this is a great credit environment and spreads which could go even tighter into year-end. A single piece of data, such as April’s non-farm payroll figure, is unlikely to change investor positioning. It may be a little too early to fade the market as fundamentals catch-up.Next week we will get a record-matching $126 billion slate of Treasury auctions. We may also see a robust serving of corporate and financials debt issuance. US consumer-price data is set to be published on Tuesday, 12 May. A sharp annual acceleration is forecast, although the market is likely to dismiss the figure as resulting from a comparison to depressed levels of a year earlier.With peak Q1 earnings season now behind us, Japanese banks will deliver their year-end results over the next week while several other stragglers pepper the remainder of the month. US banks signaled that they anticipate significantly higher interest rates by raising record breaking amounts in the debt capital markets following their Q1 earnings announcements. Other banks may follow with material debt issuance over the next few weeks after reporting earnings.Market Outlook: The question is whether the over-heating narrative will make a comeback and bring rate and tapering expectations closer. Financial stability risks appear binary from here. Either the Fed is over-accommodative, and it sits on its hands too long while asset bubbles over-inflate so that it gets nasty when it moves, or the Fed gets impatient, and it lowers accommodation unexpectedly which creates a risk off reaction. In both cases, curves flatten in a risk-off environment. We suspect the former is more likely, and for now, the Fed remains the bartender.

Executive Summary: Friday’s jobs report shocker capped off a week which included US Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen needing to be Mirandized. This was followed by the Fed stating the obvious in its financial stability report. Unmentioned in this report is that the role of this Fed is no longer to take away the punchbowl, but instead it is the bartender. The week ended with a jobs report that was the biggest miss in nominal terms, ever.The report was at odds with recent PMI surveys in which respondents stated that it was difficult to hire. This may be the result of frictions in hiring as unemployment benefits as well as child-care needs and postponed school re-openings delay employee re-entry. The truth serum for the US economy may occur around September when extended unemployment payments expire.The market impact was an immediate 10 basis point (bp) drop in the 10-year Treasury while the 2-year note even fell 1bp. Prices on the 10-year gave up these gains as the day progressed, but the smart money, that is the bond market, may be correct with the recent dampening of interest rates suggesting a longer time period to a less accommodative Fed.  The US Treasury bond curve ended the week flatter with short-end yields falling by much less than the longer part of the curve.With rates continuing to push credit spreads, Asia- and European-headquartered banks generated negative total returns in all but the lowest duration notes. There was a clear preference for Additional Tier 1 (AT1) bond issuance over the past week while over US$11 billion equivalent was raised by financial institutions globally in USD and Euros. In what may have been the busiest AT1 bond issuance weeks of the year, five institutions brought over US$6.5 billion in six securities.Nonetheless, this is a great credit environment and spreads which could go even tighter into year-end. A single piece of data, such as April’s non-farm payroll figure, is unlikely to change investor positioning. It may be a little too early to fade the market as fundamentals catch-up.Next week we will get a record-matching $126 billion slate of Treasury auctions. We may also see a robust serving of corporate and financials debt issuance. US consumer-price data is set to be published on Tuesday, 12 May. A sharp annual acceleration is forecast, although the market is likely to dismiss the figure as resulting from a comparison to depressed levels of a year earlier.With peak Q1 earnings season now behind us, Japanese banks will deliver their year-end results over the next week while several other stragglers pepper the remainder of the month. US banks signaled that they anticipate significantly higher interest rates by raising record breaking amounts in the debt capital markets following their Q1 earnings announcements. Other banks may follow with material debt issuance over the next few weeks after reporting earnings.Market Outlook: The question is whether the over-heating narrative will make a comeback and bring rate and tapering expectations closer. Financial stability risks appear binary from here. Either the Fed is over-accommodative, and it sits on its hands too long while asset bubbles over-inflate so that it gets nasty when it moves, or the Fed gets impatient, and it lowers accommodation unexpectedly which creates a risk off reaction. In both cases, curves flatten in a risk-off environment. We suspect the former is more likely, and for now, the Fed remains the bartender.

Bank Credit Weekly: Jobs Report Shocker Flattens Curves

Silver Point

Thomas J. Monaco

Independent Insight Provider

Silver Point is a boutique research firm that focuses on the broader financial services sector, with a particular focus on troubled institutions globally. 

Asia Ex Japan

Equity Bottom-Up

*Results Materially Supported By Provision Reversals and Principal Transactions: Citigroup (C.US) [Citi] reported 1Q21 bottom-line results of USD 7.6 bn, increasing USD 3.7 bn (89.0%) linked quarter. Citi reversed provisions of USD 2.1 bn - increasing 43.7x versus 4Q20. In addition to the negative provision, Citi’s results were also supported by a USD 2.0 bn (99.7%) increase in principal transaction gains;*Credit Weaker But Coverage Strong: Net new NPLs came in about 1/3 of the previous quarter’s result came in at USD 635 mn or increasing 48.0% on an annualized basis – still far worse than JPM for the last three consecutive quarters. Citi’s loan loss reserve declined to 422% of NPLs and 325 bp of total loans – but still pretty darn good for the known and potential risk in the loan portfolio; and *Puzzling EM Exit: Citi also announced strategic changes in the Global Consumer Bank (GCB), where they are exiting 13 markets, of which ten are in Asia-Pacific. As rationale for the move, new CEO Jane Fraser believe that Citi "does not have the scale" to compete in those markets which account for USD 7 bn in allocated equity and USD 70 bn in loans. We await clarity on the potential restructuring costs and the capital release from these divestitures.

*Results Materially Supported By Provision Reversals and Principal Transactions: Citigroup (C.US) [Citi] reported 1Q21 bottom-line results of USD 7.6 bn, increasing USD 3.7 bn (89.0%) linked quarter. Citi reversed provisions of USD 2.1 bn - increasing 43.7x versus 4Q20. In addition to the negative provision, Citi’s results were also supported by a USD 2.0 bn (99.7%) increase in principal transaction gains;*Credit Weaker But Coverage Strong: Net new NPLs came in about 1/3 of the previous quarter’s result came in at USD 635 mn or increasing 48.0% on an annualized basis – still far worse than JPM for the last three consecutive quarters. Citi’s loan loss reserve declined to 422% of NPLs and 325 bp of total loans – but still pretty darn good for the known and potential risk in the loan portfolio; and *Puzzling EM Exit: Citi also announced strategic changes in the Global Consumer Bank (GCB), where they are exiting 13 markets, of which ten are in Asia-Pacific. As rationale for the move, new CEO Jane Fraser believe that Citi "does not have the scale" to compete in those markets which account for USD 7 bn in allocated equity and USD 70 bn in loans. We await clarity on the potential restructuring costs and the capital release from these divestitures.

Sberbank of Russia PJSC / Equity Bottom-Up

*New US Sanctions: The US Biden administration announced a series of sanctions today against Russia, which leaves the country on the verge of being tossed out of Western banking/finance markets related to SolarWinds and US elections meddling; and  *Nuclear Option Still Available: As bad as this is for Russia and her largest financial institutions, such as Sberbank of Russia (SBER.RU), the Biden administration did not move to the nuclear option of barring investors from holding Russian sovereign debt in the secondary market nor did it actually add tycoons to the sanctions list. The painful worst case scenario of barring ownership of Russian debt has been avoided, as foreign investors own some 20% or USD 37 bn in Russian paper - US investors account for half of foreign holdings. This situation could have triggered substantial indices-related selling.

*New US Sanctions: The US Biden administration announced a series of sanctions today against Russia, which leaves the country on the verge of being tossed out of Western banking/finance markets related to SolarWinds and US elections meddling; and  *Nuclear Option Still Available: As bad as this is for Russia and her largest financial institutions, such as Sberbank of Russia (SBER.RU), the Biden administration did not move to the nuclear option of barring investors from holding Russian sovereign debt in the secondary market nor did it actually add tycoons to the sanctions list. The painful worst case scenario of barring ownership of Russian debt has been avoided, as foreign investors own some 20% or USD 37 bn in Russian paper - US investors account for half of foreign holdings. This situation could have triggered substantial indices-related selling. 

Sberbank of Russia – Dealing With New Sanctions

United Kingdom

Deutsche Bank AG is a global financial service provider delivering commercial, investment, private, and retail banking. The Bank offers debt, foreign exchange, derivatives, commodities, money markets, repo and securitization, cash equities, research, equity prime services, loans, convertibles, advice on M&A and IPO's, trade finance, retail banking, asset management, and corporate investments.

Price Gauge
52-week Range	0.00 - 0.00
Market Cap (USDm)	0.00
P/E	0.00
Dividend (Yield)	0.00

Deutsche Bank AG (DBK1 LI)

SocGen: AT1 Is Ripe for Picking as CIB Is Restructured

SocGen’s AT1 bonds may be ripe for picking as the firm doubles down on reducing revenue volatility. The recently issued 4.75% 2026 note trades at a...

Hank Calenti, CFA

UniCredit: CASHES Paid or Not, Senior Non-Preferred Offers Value

Cancelling the CASHES coupon payment was not a good omen. Possibly paying the coupon is even worse. Nonetheless, UCGIM’s Non-Preferred Senior...

Hank Calenti, CFA

Bank Credit Weekly: Jobs Report Shocker Flattens Curves

Job data raises uncertainty as the Fed continues to act as bartender. Financial stability risks appear binary while rates push credit spreads. Can...

Hank Calenti, CFA

Citigroup – Shifting Winds

CITIGROUP: Citi reported a QOQ 1Q21 bottom-line result increase of 89.0% due to provision reversals and principal transactions. Net new NPLs...

Thomas J. Monaco

Sberbank of Russia – Dealing With New Sanctions

SBERBANK: The Biden administration announced a series of sanctions against Russia, which leaves the country on the verge of being tossed out of...

Thomas J. Monaco

Price Gauge

52-week Range

Market Cap (USDm)

P/E

Dividend (Yield)