External broker reports(aggregated public sources), Topline Securities

Topline Securities

Topline Securities is one of the fastest growing brokerage houses in Pakistan. It has strong equity brokerage, economic / equity research, mutual fund distribution, commodity trading and corporate finance & advisory functions. Content available is external broker reports authored by a third party outside the Smartkarma network and has been aggregated by an online aggregator through publicly available sources and is displayed by Smartkarma in this format for user's convenience and general informational purposes only. Content does not constitute investment or financial advice and Smartkarma makes no representation or warranty regarding its accuracy or contents. Original third party author retains all copyright and other proprietary rights in the content. Access or use of third party links not controlled by Smartkarma are at the user's own risk.

External broker reports(aggregated public sources)

Equity Bottom-Up

<ul>
<li>
Investment Thesis: Post announcement of HBL’s 2Q2018 financial results, we revise down our earnings estimate for HBL by ~20% for 2018-20 as bank is incurring additional cost on improving its local &amp; international compliance. We also downgrade the stock to ‘Hold’ given lack of clear visibility on the continuity of this cost, which is estimated to continue at least till 2019. Furthermore, additional cost on account of deposit protection mechanism, FX losses and implementation of IFRS 9 could further restrict earnings growth going ahead. The stock currently trades at a 2018 PE of 8.7x and PBV of 1.1x with ROE of 14%.</li>
<li>
Earnings revised down post 2Q2018 financial results: HBL posted earnings of Rs2.3/share in 1Q2018, down 48% YoY taking 1H2018 EPS to Rs5.4/share, down 49%. Sharp deterioration in earnings during 1H2018 was due to 1) Rs1.9bn (Rs0.85/share) of pension charge, 2) bank business &amp; compliance transformation project costing Rs2.5bn (Rs1.1/share) &amp; 3) higher consultancy cost pertaining to NY operations. Along with higher costs, non-markup income of the bank was also down 35% YoY to Rs10.7bn primarily due to FX losses on borrowings and lower capital gains, which will likely prevail given expectations of currency devaluation &amp; lower expected gains on bonds/equities. Accounting for the same, we revise down our earnings estimate by ~20% to Rs14/19/21 for 2018/2019/2020.</li>
<li>
Cost related to NY operation to remain inflated: HBL registered strong increase in admin costs during 1H2018, +27% YoY amid higher cost related to consultancy &amp; other legal fees in connection to its U.S operations. This fees is related to legal consultation carried out by the bank for compliance of Anti-Money Laundering (AML) rules &amp; regulation &amp; other costs relating to closure of its NY branch. The bank incurred loss of Rs4.9bn during 1H2018 on its international business versus loss of Rs0.5bn in same period last year. To recall, New York Department of Financial Services (DFS) imposed a penalty in Sep 2018 of US$225mn (revised down from US$630mn) on non-compliance of its AML laws. Due to this, the bank has not only paid the penalty amount (paid in 2017) but has also been paying the increased legal cost. The increased legal cost is expected to continue till 2019 at least.</li>
<li>
FX losses on foreign currency borrowings to continue: The bank borrowed an amount of ~US$200mn in order to pay the fine on its oversees operations, which was subject to FX losses during 1H2018 of Rs2.5bn as Pak rupee lost 10% against the USD in 1H2018. Given Pakistan’s weak external account situation, we expect further currency devaluation in 2019 &amp; 2020, which will likely result in further FX losses. </li>
<li>
Bank to bear additional cost on deposit protection: SBP has recently setup a Deposit Protection Corporation (DPC) to ensure deposit protection of small depositors by providing guarantee of Rs250k to the depositor in case of a default. Banking companies being member of the DPC will have to comply to the above regulation and will have to pay insurance premium of 0.16% of their respective eligible deposits. Eligible deposits would include all deposits excluding i) deposits that have been reported as unclaimed deposits, &amp; ii) such deposits that are maintained at branches and subsidiaries of Pakistani bank operating outside Pakistan &amp; branches located in export processing zone. The first premium was payable in July 2018 and is expected to have an annualized impact of Rs1-1.5bn (Rs0.5-Rs0.7/share) for the bank.</li>
<li>
Rising interest rates to offer some support: In a tough operating environment, the bank is likely to get some relief from rising interest rates. SBP has already raised policy rates by 175bps to 7.5% in 8M2018, which we expect to go further up to 9.75% by 2020. This is likely to support NII growth of the bank going forward on its domestic operations. We expect NII to grow by 8% on average during 2018-20. Higher NII will support earnings and ROE (excluding surplus) of the bank, which is expected to improve from 2019, however, it will still be lower than the average of 21% seen pre 2017 level when fine was imposed.</li>
<li>
Pension charge: Supreme Court (SC) of Pakistan had ordered banks to increase minimum pension to Rs8,000/month to bank’s pensioners with an annual increase of 5%. The bank booked Rs1.9bn (Rs0.85/share) of pension charge in 1H2018 which was revised down from Rs2.1bn charged during 1Q2018. The bank so far has provided for the pension charge as per the requirement of SC. However, any future adjustment to pension charge can not be ruled out.</li>
<li>
Implementation of IFRS9: IAS39 is expected to be replaced by IFRS9 in 2019, which alters the mechanism of booking and measurement of financial instrument. It is likely to change the recognition of Non performing loans will change. Currently, banks follow objective classification criteria for recognition of NPLs as highlighted in SBP’s Prudential regulations, which require provisioning of 25%, 50% &amp; 100% for substandard, doubtful &amp; loss categories. The new IFRS9 rule will require banks to classify NPLs based on subjective criteria, which will require banks to subjectively classify loans as NPLs that may not be recovered eventually from borrowers which could result in higher provisioning.</li>
<li>
Key Risks: Key risks for the bank include 1) further increase in cost relating to NY operations, 2) increase in NPLs, 3) further increase in pension charge, &amp; 4) imposition of further penalty. </li>
</ul>



Investment Thesis: Post announcement of HBL’s 2Q2018 financial results, we revise down our earnings estimate for HBL by ~20% for 2018-20 as bank is incurring additional cost on improving its local &amp; international compliance. We also downgrade the stock to ‘Hold’ given lack of clear visibility on the continuity of this cost, which is estimated to continue at least till 2019. Furthermore, additional cost on account of deposit protection mechanism, FX losses and implementation of IFRS 9 could further restrict earnings growth going ahead. The stock currently trades at a 2018 PE of 8.7x and PBV of 1.1x with ROE of 14%.

Earnings revised down post 2Q2018 financial results: HBL posted earnings of Rs2.3/share in 1Q2018, down 48% YoY taking 1H2018 EPS to Rs5.4/share, down 49%. Sharp deterioration in earnings during 1H2018 was due to 1) Rs1.9bn (Rs0.85/share) of pension charge, 2) bank business &amp; compliance transformation project costing Rs2.5bn (Rs1.1/share) &amp; 3) higher consultancy cost pertaining to NY operations. Along with higher costs, non-markup income of the bank was also down 35% YoY to Rs10.7bn primarily due to FX losses on borrowings and lower capital gains, which will likely prevail given expectations of currency devaluation &amp; lower expected gains on bonds/equities. Accounting for the same, we revise down our earnings estimate by ~20% to Rs14/19/21 for 2018/2019/2020.

Cost related to NY operation to remain inflated: HBL registered strong increase in admin costs during 1H2018, +27% YoY amid higher cost related to consultancy &amp; other legal fees in connection to its U.S operations. This fees is related to legal consultation carried out by the bank for compliance of Anti-Money Laundering (AML) rules &amp; regulation &amp; other costs relating to closure of its NY branch. The bank incurred loss of Rs4.9bn during 1H2018 on its international business versus loss of Rs0.5bn in same period last year. To recall, New York Department of Financial Services (DFS) imposed a penalty in Sep 2018 of US$225mn (revised down from US$630mn) on non-compliance of its AML laws. Due to this, the bank has not only paid the penalty amount (paid in 2017) but has also been paying the increased legal cost. The increased legal cost is expected to continue till 2019 at least.

FX losses on foreign currency borrowings to continue: The bank borrowed an amount of ~US$200mn in order to pay the fine on its oversees operations, which was subject to FX losses during 1H2018 of Rs2.5bn as Pak rupee lost 10% against the USD in 1H2018. Given Pakistan’s weak external account situation, we expect further currency devaluation in 2019 &amp; 2020, which will likely result in further FX losses. 

Bank to bear additional cost on deposit protection: SBP has recently setup a Deposit Protection Corporation (DPC) to ensure deposit protection of small depositors by providing guarantee of Rs250k to the depositor in case of a default. Banking companies being member of the DPC will have to comply to the above regulation and will have to pay insurance premium of 0.16% of their respective eligible deposits. Eligible deposits would include all deposits excluding i) deposits that have been reported as unclaimed deposits, &amp; ii) such deposits that are maintained at branches and subsidiaries of Pakistani bank operating outside Pakistan &amp; branches located in export processing zone. The first premium was payable in July 2018 and is expected to have an annualized impact of Rs1-1.5bn (Rs0.5-Rs0.7/share) for the bank.

Rising interest rates to offer some support: In a tough operating environment, the bank is likely to get some relief from rising interest rates. SBP has already raised policy rates by 175bps to 7.5% in 8M2018, which we expect to go further up to 9.75% by 2020. This is likely to support NII growth of the bank going forward on its domestic operations. We expect NII to grow by 8% on average during 2018-20. Higher NII will support earnings and ROE (excluding surplus) of the bank, which is expected to improve from 2019, however, it will still be lower than the average of 21% seen pre 2017 level when fine was imposed.

Pension charge: Supreme Court (SC) of Pakistan had ordered banks to increase minimum pension to Rs8,000/month to bank’s pensioners with an annual increase of 5%. The bank booked Rs1.9bn (Rs0.85/share) of pension charge in 1H2018 which was revised down from Rs2.1bn charged during 1Q2018. The bank so far has provided for the pension charge as per the requirement of SC. However, any future adjustment to pension charge can not be ruled out.

Implementation of IFRS9: IAS39 is expected to be replaced by IFRS9 in 2019, which alters the mechanism of booking and measurement of financial instrument. It is likely to change the recognition of Non performing loans will change. Currently, banks follow objective classification criteria for recognition of NPLs as highlighted in SBP’s Prudential regulations, which require provisioning of 25%, 50% &amp; 100% for substandard, doubtful &amp; loss categories. The new IFRS9 rule will require banks to classify NPLs based on subjective criteria, which will require banks to subjectively classify loans as NPLs that may not be recovered eventually from borrowers which could result in higher provisioning.

Key Risks: Key risks for the bank include 1) further increase in cost relating to NY operations, 2) increase in NPLs, 3) further increase in pension charge, &amp; 4) imposition of further penalty. 


Habib Bank (HBL): Earnings Revised Down, Downgraded To "Hold"

Habib Bank Ltd

Habib Bank (HBL): Earnings Revised Down, Downgraded To "Hold"