Financials Credit Analyst

Hank Calenti, CFA

CreditContinuum

Credit

Executive Summary: <a href="https://www.smartkarma.com/entities/hsbc-holdings-plc-a723bd63-0890-486f-aaa0-3bb9ad2b95ce" target="_blank" data-smartkarma-citation="entities:21976:1" rel="noopener">HSBC Holdings' (HSBA LN)</a> Q1 earnings release was one part theater, one part reality and in a large part more of the same. This may be a long and slow recovery and transformation for this institution. Time is not on its side from a debt rating perspective.With respect to reality, there is a glimmer of hope for revenues as HSBC reported an increase in the pipeline of loan applications.  As regards theater, HSBC’s loan loss reserve release appears to be largely signaling, rather than driven by an actual improvement in asset quality. Additional theater is provided in the way HSBC’s underlying profits are calculated.More of the same was seen in that HSBC cannot immediately escape its predicament of being a large conventional lender as opposed to a significant fee generating wealth and asset manager. This may be a long and slow recovery and transformation for this institution.Time is not on its side from a debt rating perspective. Moody’s review for a possible downgrade should be concluded before the end of Q2.  Notably, HSBC’s Additional Tier 1 (AT1) bonds are not at risk of a downgrade. They currently represent a safe harbor from downgrade risk and remain supported by a large buffer of capital. Most of these securities also trade at a meaningful discount, in spread and multiple terms, to the higher seniority Tier 2 securities.Concurrently, HSBC’s Tier 2 bonds trade extremely tight relative to the higher seniority Senior Unsecured bonds issued by HSBC Holdings.  For investors that cannot hold AT1 bonds, given the downgrade risk and the fact that there is little upside to be gained from owning HSBC’s Tier 2 bonds, our general preference would be to own HSBC’s holding company issued Senior Unsecured notes.

Executive Summary: HSBC Holdings' (HSBA LN) Q1 earnings release was one part theater, one part reality and in a large part more of the same. This may be a long and slow recovery and transformation for this institution. Time is not on its side from a debt rating perspective.With respect to reality, there is a glimmer of hope for revenues as HSBC reported an increase in the pipeline of loan applications.  As regards theater, HSBC’s loan loss reserve release appears to be largely signaling, rather than driven by an actual improvement in asset quality. Additional theater is provided in the way HSBC’s underlying profits are calculated.More of the same was seen in that HSBC cannot immediately escape its predicament of being a large conventional lender as opposed to a significant fee generating wealth and asset manager. This may be a long and slow recovery and transformation for this institution.Time is not on its side from a debt rating perspective. Moody’s review for a possible downgrade should be concluded before the end of Q2.  Notably, HSBC’s Additional Tier 1 (AT1) bonds are not at risk of a downgrade. They currently represent a safe harbor from downgrade risk and remain supported by a large buffer of capital. Most of these securities also trade at a meaningful discount, in spread and multiple terms, to the higher seniority Tier 2 securities.Concurrently, HSBC’s Tier 2 bonds trade extremely tight relative to the higher seniority Senior Unsecured bonds issued by HSBC Holdings.  For investors that cannot hold AT1 bonds, given the downgrade risk and the fact that there is little upside to be gained from owning HSBC’s Tier 2 bonds, our general preference would be to own HSBC’s holding company issued Senior Unsecured notes.

HSBC’s Q1 Results: One Part Theater and One Part Reality as We Move To a Downgrade

Executive Summary: US investment banking Q1 results set us up for an interesting European bank earnings season. After reserve releases, investment banking revenues were the second largest driver of net revenues as compared to the prior year.The upcoming set of European bank results may be as good as it gets for this year. As each bank may release reserves, investment banking specialization may be the differentiating factor in terms of revenue results.With US banks noting that their more macro-related trading activities were lower than in the prior year, we consider which European banks may report similar activity. We suspect that the French institutions, Société Générale in particular, could benefit most from their investment banking results provided their real economy activity continues to strengthen.

Executive Summary: US investment banking Q1 results set us up for an interesting European bank earnings season. After reserve releases, investment banking revenues were the second largest driver of net revenues as compared to the prior year.The upcoming set of European bank results may be as good as it gets for this year. As each bank may release reserves, investment banking specialization may be the differentiating factor in terms of revenue results.With US banks noting that their more macro-related trading activities were lower than in the prior year, we consider which European banks may report similar activity. We suspect that the French institutions, Société Générale in particular, could benefit most from their investment banking results provided their real economy activity continues to strengthen.

US Investment Bank Results and Upcoming European Bank Earnings

Silver Point

Thomas J. Monaco

Independent Insight Provider

Silver Point is a boutique research firm that focuses on the broader financial services sector, with a particular focus on troubled institutions globally. 

Asia Ex Japan

Equity Bottom-Up

*Results Materially Supported By Provision Reversals and Principal Transactions: Citigroup (C.US) [Citi] reported 1Q21 bottom-line results of USD 7.6 bn, increasing USD 3.7 bn (89.0%) linked quarter. Citi reversed provisions of USD 2.1 bn - increasing 43.7x versus 4Q20. In addition to the negative provision, Citi’s results were also supported by a USD 2.0 bn (99.7%) increase in principal transaction gains;*Credit Weaker But Coverage Strong: Net new NPLs came in about 1/3 of the previous quarter’s result came in at USD 635 mn or increasing 48.0% on an annualized basis – still far worse than JPM for the last three consecutive quarters. Citi’s loan loss reserve declined to 422% of NPLs and 325 bp of total loans – but still pretty darn good for the known and potential risk in the loan portfolio; and *Puzzling EM Exit: Citi also announced strategic changes in the Global Consumer Bank (GCB), where they are exiting 13 markets, of which ten are in Asia-Pacific. As rationale for the move, new CEO Jane Fraser believe that Citi "does not have the scale" to compete in those markets which account for USD 7 bn in allocated equity and USD 70 bn in loans. We await clarity on the potential restructuring costs and the capital release from these divestitures.

*Results Materially Supported By Provision Reversals and Principal Transactions: Citigroup (C.US) [Citi] reported 1Q21 bottom-line results of USD 7.6 bn, increasing USD 3.7 bn (89.0%) linked quarter. Citi reversed provisions of USD 2.1 bn - increasing 43.7x versus 4Q20. In addition to the negative provision, Citi’s results were also supported by a USD 2.0 bn (99.7%) increase in principal transaction gains;*Credit Weaker But Coverage Strong: Net new NPLs came in about 1/3 of the previous quarter’s result came in at USD 635 mn or increasing 48.0% on an annualized basis – still far worse than JPM for the last three consecutive quarters. Citi’s loan loss reserve declined to 422% of NPLs and 325 bp of total loans – but still pretty darn good for the known and potential risk in the loan portfolio; and *Puzzling EM Exit: Citi also announced strategic changes in the Global Consumer Bank (GCB), where they are exiting 13 markets, of which ten are in Asia-Pacific. As rationale for the move, new CEO Jane Fraser believe that Citi "does not have the scale" to compete in those markets which account for USD 7 bn in allocated equity and USD 70 bn in loans. We await clarity on the potential restructuring costs and the capital release from these divestitures.

*Results Better, But Likely Unsustainable: Bank of America (BAC.US) [BAC] reported 1Q21 bottom-line results of USD 7.6 bn, increasing USD 2.4 bn (45.2%) linked quarter. Results were driven by two factors: a) a negative USD 1.9 bn, in contravention to overall credit performance; and b) a USD 2.1 bn (147.3%) increase trading activities, the sustainability of which we call into question; and*BAC Still Needs To Focus On Credit Quality: Given the USD 774 mn in NCOs (33 bp annualized of total loans), we note that net new NPLs reversed course – increasing a a high 74.8% on an annualized basis. JPM and Citigroup each reported declines. Relative to NPLs, however, reserves – while still significant – declined 67.4% to 3.00x while declining 24 bp to 1.79% against total loans.

*Results Better, But Likely Unsustainable: Bank of America (BAC.US) [BAC] reported 1Q21 bottom-line results of USD 7.6 bn, increasing USD 2.4 bn (45.2%) linked quarter. Results were driven by two factors: a) a negative USD 1.9 bn, in contravention to overall credit performance; and b) a USD 2.1 bn (147.3%) increase trading activities, the sustainability of which we call into question; and*BAC Still Needs To Focus On Credit Quality: Given the USD 774 mn in NCOs (33 bp annualized of total loans), we note that net new NPLs reversed course – increasing a a high 74.8% on an annualized basis. JPM and Citigroup each reported declines. Relative to NPLs, however, reserves – while still significant – declined 67.4% to 3.00x while declining 24 bp to 1.79% against total loans.

Bank of America – Not Exactly A Shining Result

*Results Should Only Get Better: JP Morgan Chase &amp; Co (JPM.US) [JPM] reported 1Q21 bottom-line results of USD 13.9 bn, increasing USD 2.2 bn (18.4%) linked quarter. Results were essentially driven by two factors: a) revenue growth at the Corporate &amp; Investment Bank (CIB) of USD 3.3 bn (28.7%) due primarily to principal transactions which increased USD 3.0 bn (103%); and b) a reserve reversal of USD 4.2 bn – increasing USD 2.3 bn (120%) over 4Q20’s provision reversal. The strength of the bottom-line, should allow larger capital returns in 2Q21 predicated on the Federal Reserve Board’s (FRB) dividend payout ratio test; and*Credit Improvement: JPM’s net new NPLs linked quarter amounted to just USD 638 mn or a 22.2% increase on an annualized basis – which is incredibly good. Given the current risk profile of JPM’s loan portfolio that the company remains over-provided for and that we will continue to see loss provision reversals until loan growth returns in some meaningful way.

*Results Should Only Get Better: JP Morgan Chase &amp; Co (JPM.US) [JPM] reported 1Q21 bottom-line results of USD 13.9 bn, increasing USD 2.2 bn (18.4%) linked quarter. Results were essentially driven by two factors: a) revenue growth at the Corporate &amp; Investment Bank (CIB) of USD 3.3 bn (28.7%) due primarily to principal transactions which increased USD 3.0 bn (103%); and b) a reserve reversal of USD 4.2 bn – increasing USD 2.3 bn (120%) over 4Q20’s provision reversal. The strength of the bottom-line, should allow larger capital returns in 2Q21 predicated on the Federal Reserve Board’s (FRB) dividend payout ratio test; and*Credit Improvement: JPM’s net new NPLs linked quarter amounted to just USD 638 mn or a 22.2% increase on an annualized basis – which is incredibly good. Given the current risk profile of JPM’s loan portfolio that the company remains over-provided for and that we will continue to see loss provision reversals until loan growth returns in some meaningful way.

United Kingdom

HSBC Holdings plc is the holding company for the HSBC Group. The Company provides a variety of international banking and financial services, including retail and corporate banking, trade, trusteeship, securities, custody, capital markets, treasury, private and investment banking, and insurance. HSBC Holdings operates worldwide.

Price Gauge
52-week Range	0.00 - 0.00
Market Cap (USDm)	0.00
P/E	0.00
Dividend (Yield)	0.00

HSBC Holdings (HSBC US)

HSBC’s Q1 Results: One Part Theater and One Part Reality as We Move To a Downgrade

HSBC’s earnings release was one part theater, one part reality and in a large part more of the same. This may be a long and slow recovery and...

Hank Calenti, CFA

US Investment Bank Results and Upcoming European Bank Earnings

Upcoming European bank results may be as good as it gets for this year. As each bank should release reserves, investment bank specialization may be...

Hank Calenti, CFA

Citigroup – Shifting Winds

CITIGROUP: Citi reported a QOQ 1Q21 bottom-line result increase of 89.0% due to provision reversals and principal transactions. Net new NPLs...

Thomas J. Monaco

Bank of America – Not Exactly A Shining Result

BANK OF AMERICA: BAC's QOQ 1Q21 bottom-line increased 45.2% driven by reserve releases and trading (not sustainable). Net new NPLs reversed course...

Thomas J. Monaco

J.P Morgan Chase & Co. – Well On Track

JP MORGAN CHASE: JPM 1Q21 bottom-line results increased 18.4% linked quarter due to principal transactions and provision reversals. This should...

Thomas J. Monaco

Price Gauge

52-week Range

Market Cap (USDm)

P/E

Dividend (Yield)