In this briefing:
- Futu Holdings Pre-IPO – Great Metrics but in a Commoditised Industry
- Tencent Music: Short Idea on Consumption Slowdown Angle
- PCI Ltd – All Over Before It Starts
- Softbank: Reduced Yield Competitiveness, End of Passive Buying and Softbank Group’s Hunger for Cash
- Samsung Bear Targets Coming into Focus
1. Futu Holdings Pre-IPO – Great Metrics but in a Commoditised Industry
Futu Holdings Ltd (FHL US) plans to raise around US$300m in its US IPO. The company is backed by Tencent Holdings (700 HK) , Matrix Partners and Sequoia, who together own over 45% of the company.
The founding team comes mostly from Tencent, which might explain Tencent’s large stake in the company. Growth for the company has been stupendous despite the jittery markets, with margin financing adding to the top-line growth.
While its low costs will help it to steal clients from the more traditional brokers, other new low-cost brokers seem to be offering similar services at comparable rates. In addition, the company is not licensed or regulated by any entities in China, despite the majority of its client base being Chinese nationals. Furthermore, the company plans to expand into newer overseas market where it doesn’t seem to have much of a cost advantage.
2. Tencent Music: Short Idea on Consumption Slowdown Angle
- Tencent Music Entertainment (TME US)‘s social entertainment services (discretionary consumption in nature) face more headwinds due to ongoing China (macro) consumption slowdown.
- Moreover, high consensus earnings expectation would make material earnings downgrade a major narrative for TME throughout 2019, in our opinion.
- We initiative coverage on TME with Short/Sell recommendation, with 12-mo PT of US$9.80/ADR (representing a 25% downside potential).
3. PCI Ltd – All Over Before It Starts
After gaining 22.5% over seven trading days back in mid-September, Pci Ltd (PCI SP) responded to an SGX query over this price action that “it has been approached by a third party in connection with a potential transaction in relation to the securities of the Company. The discussions are on-going …“.
All was revealed on 4th January 2019, when PCI announced that Pagani Holding (a SPV indirectly owned by Platinum Equity Advisors) had made a S$1.33/share cash offer for the company by way of a scheme.
Chuan Hup Holdings (CH SP), which holds 76.7% in PCI, has given an irrevocable undertaking to vote its stake in favour of the scheme resolution, and to reject or vote against any competing offers. PCI’s executive chairman, Peh Kwee Chim, is Chuan Hup’s majority owner.
The price presents a ~18% premium to the last close, but a 49% premium to the “undisturbed” price back in early September and a 60% premium over the 12-month VWAP. The Offer values PCI at US$195mn.
With the 75%-for scheme condition satisfied and a lifetime-high takeover price, this is a done deal, and is duly reflected in the gross/annualised spread of 2.3%/6.8%, assuming mid-May completion.
4. Softbank: Reduced Yield Competitiveness, End of Passive Buying and Softbank Group’s Hunger for Cash
We are once again turning negative on Softbank Corp (9434 JP) as the stock price is now 18% above the ¥1,200 level which we mentioned looked cheap, outperforming Topix by 20% and the Nikkei by 21%.
Softbank Corp: When Does It Become a Buy?
In our view this IPO was oversold and probably to numerous weak hands who may now be looking at the large price drops that Softbank Group has occasionally suffered. We would hazard a guess that many of the individuals looking to flip the shares may still not have sold, however, if the stock dips below ¥1,200 we believe risk-reward would tilt positive until the passive buying is complete. Our view on this large drop is mostly that Softbank over-reached in terms of the size of the sale and the valuation.
The business, while subject to various headwinds should still be highly cash generative and at the current price is on just under 13x EV/OP. That’s not particularly cheap but nor is it ridiculously expensive if you believe OP will not drop (we believe it will). With a bit more of a discount and once the initial selling pressure from flippers dies down we believe the yield and passive buying should help the stock find a temporary floor. We do not view this as an attractive long-term holding in any way shape or form, but as a short-term trade the potential to make a 5-10% return on the back of a bounce following panic selling by retail supported by the yield and passive buying seems reasonably good.
Prior to that, we had flagged that retail demand for the IPO could be fragile in Softbank IPO: Signs Point to Risk of Early IPO Price Break and while there was a stronger sell-off than we expected immediately post listing, we would hazard a guess that there could still be an overhang close to the IPO price as there could be significant latent sell volume from retailers hoping to break-even and if that opportunity opens up in a weak market we believe many could choose to sell despite the rebound.
We would point to the news today regarding Softbank Group lowering its planned investment in WeWork from $16bn to just $2bn due to investors in the Vision Fund balking. As perhaps the most aggressive tech investor of the last few years, Softbank stepping back is not a good sign overall and raises questions about the viability of the valuations that other companies in its investment portfolio, namely Uber, are targeting for their upcoming IPOs. With news sources suggesting that Softbank Group is also looking to offload its Nvidia Corp (NVDA US) stake, the tide appears to have truly turned for tech in general and the chronically unprofitable platform companies such as Uber and WeWork in particular.
This raises the governance risks we initially highlighted regarding the use of Softbank Corp for funding the overall Softbank Group. As such, despite a final round of passive buying for Topix buying at the end of the month, the stock price looks vulnerable here.
5. Samsung Bear Targets Coming into Focus
Samsung Electronics (005930 KS) bear call from 50k has rewarded with a series of short trades with the most recent short from 46k and has sliced through support at 39,500. Impulsive nature of the decline tell us a key low will take more time to take shape.
SEC is pressing on critical relative support versus the Kospi. A break would send ripples through the broader market in terms of the direction bias. Kospi has already spent far too much time below the macro pivot barrier at 272k for signs of any immediate recovery. Risk lies with a downside overshoot below 250 support for the Kospi.
SEC is completing a minute full wave count down that sets up a counter trend bounce which is tradable but the major low remains elusive. We outline probable downside targets in late Q1/Q2, upside cap into Q3 and the more strategic buy support.
Get Straight to the Source on Smartkarma
Smartkarma supports the world’s leading investors with high-quality, timely, and actionable Insights. Subscribe now for unlimited access, or request a demo below.