Daily TMT & Internet: Chunbo Co. IPO Preview: Valuation Analysis and more

In this briefing:

1. Chunbo Co. IPO Preview: Valuation Analysis
2. Early Investors Say “Xiaomi The Money” Post LockUp Expiry
3. Brazil Banks: Banco Do Brasil Focus – Prospects for Improved Returns, Narrowing PBV Discount
4. Yaskawa Electric: We Are Probably Now Close to the Bottom for This LT Structural Growth Story
5. Starbucks (SBUX): Could Starbucks’ Beans Start to Lose Their Magic?

1. Chunbo Co. IPO Preview: Valuation Analysis

We are bullish on the Chunbo Co. IPO. Our base case valuation of the company suggests a market cap of 448.4 billion won or 44,845 won, which would be 19.5% higher than the mid-point of the bankers’ IPO price band of 37,500 won. We used an estimated P/E of 21.1x (30% premium to the comps’ average P/E of 16.2x) and an estimated net profit of 21.2 billion won in 2019 to derive our base case valuation. 

Chunbo Co Ltd (278280 KS) is a provider of fine chemical materials in Korea, is planning to start its institutional bookbuilding of its IPO starting January 21st. Its chemical materials are used in numerous industries including the display, semiconductors, rechargeable batteries, and medical. The IPO base deal size is between $78 million to $89 million.  

Chunbo is more profitable and generates higher returns on equity than its peers. For example, Chunbo’s operating margin and ROE averaged 20.7% and 22.0%, respectively in 2016 and 2017. In comparison, the peers’ operating margin and ROE averaged 12.3% and 15.2%, respectively in 2016 and 2017. 

2. Early Investors Say “Xiaomi The Money” Post LockUp Expiry

Xiaomi Corp (1810 HK) is likely to break HK$10 this morning again after a placement equal to about 1% of shares outstanding was proposed to buyers last night at a sharp discount to the close. This insight attempts to nail down the shape and size of the ongoing overhang.

After the HK Stock Exchange announced in late April 2018 that it would permit companies with Weighted Voting Rights (WVRs) to list on the HKEx, after sticking to the one-share one-vote principle for years (losing the Alibaba Group Holding (BABA US) listing to NASDAQ in the process), Xiaomi Corp (1810 HK) quickly raised its hand with the prospect of a US$10bn IPO and a US$100bn market cap – heady numbers even for a fast-growing company. This was quickly followed by the launch of the China Depositary Receipt program which saw a quick establishment and even quicker acceptance of a Xiaomi application, potentially setting up a situation where demand was pulled from HK to China. 

Then investors got cold feet, and what was a $100bn valuation dropped to $90bn then $70bn.  The CSRC also pushed back on the possible CDR issuance to such an extent that Xiaomi withdrew its application, and then pricing delivered a valuation of approximately US$50bn at a sharply reduced IPO price of HK$17/share. 

Day1 saw a 6% fall on the open and the shares closed down 1%. After the Day 1 close, fast-track inclusion into the Hang Seng indices was a pleasant and somewhat unexpected surprise for IPO buyers and responded by rising almost 12% on Day 2 on sharply higher volume. MSCI did not follow suit (it had not been expected) but several days later on inclusion day, the stock was 25% higher than the IPO price. 10 days later the over-allotment option had been fully-exercised.

Xiaomi last year grew its ecosystem and its hardware base, but saw lower market share in China (13%) than in 2017 (14%) according to several sources, including Counterpoint Research quoted in the media. The company, which has targeted 50% of revenue from overseas is now just shy of that mark at 44% after ramping up sales in India, Europe, and MENA. 

Global weakness in handsets on mobile tech led by Apple did not spare Xiaomi, but MOST notable was the sharp drop in the share price in December from HK$14.30-50 area to just below HK$13 at year end. The first day of the new year saw the shares fall 5.5%, and the next day the price fell another 3.6%. The shares fell a little more in the next few days but somewhat stabilised until the morning of the 8th. 

Then the volume picked up. The lockup had expired.  

In five days, the shares have traded 880mm shares, and that is before a large placement proposed after the close on 15th January. 

“Xiaomi The Money” was the title of David Blennerhassett‘s initial pre-IPO insight ( Xiaomi The Money!), followed when details came out by Xiaomi the Ecosystem!

3. Brazil Banks: Banco Do Brasil Focus – Prospects for Improved Returns, Narrowing PBV Discount

• A rising pro-market tide has lifted the big-cap banks, but now it is time to be more selective. We see further potential for stock re-rating among the Brazilian banks, as the new Bolosonaro administration executes its pro-market policies.
• Our top pick is Banco Do Brasil Sa (BdoBAS3 BZ) , with a target price of BRL57, which implies 19% re-rating potential. We believe that Banco do Brasil (BdoB) shareholders are set to benefit from less of a “social programme” agenda which in turn should help improve ROE going forward.
• Yet the PBV discount between BdoB and its private sector peers – especially against Itaú Unibanco at 52% – has barely narrowed, and we believe that the discount has potential to narrow further as BdoB’s ROE expands and narrows the gap with its private sector peers.

4. Yaskawa Electric: We Are Probably Now Close to the Bottom for This LT Structural Growth Story

Following Yaskawa’s second downward revision at 3Q earnings, we are shifting towards a more positive stance on the stock, even from a long-term perspective. We had been negative on the stock from late 2017 and as the stock tumbled we maintained that it was still too early buy for the long-term, though by mid-late 2018 we did (incorrectly) feel that there was the potential for a short term rally due to the severity of underperformance.

With the stock selling off harshly in the recent market fall but rebounding following its weak earnings we feel that much of the bad news is now priced in and expectations have corrected to the point where this is once again interesting on the long side.

5. Starbucks (SBUX): Could Starbucks’ Beans Start to Lose Their Magic?

Three key emerging risks to the Starbucks’ growth story: 1) New entrant poses a threat to China growth story; 2) New CEO is missing the magic of the beans; and 3) New Uber partnership could erode Starbucks’ brand equity.

In our January 8 research note, we cautioned that Starbucks had outperformed the NASDAQ by 37% since we turned positive on August 8 but we were concerned about two new developments that we viewed as red flags: shelving of Reserve coffee bar expansion and aggressive China expansion plans of Luckin Coffee. While we do not believe this represents a short opportunity, we do believe it foreshadows emerging risks to Starbucks’ long-term growth story.