In this briefing:
- Takeda: Move Over Newton! Now It’s Spooky Action At a Distance
- Hitachi (6501 JP): A Bold but Risky Acquisition of ABB’s Power Grids
- Smartkarma’s Week that Was in JP/KR: Softbank, JDI, Pioneer Corp and Doosan Bobcat
- SoftBank Corp IPO Valuation: Bull/Bear Case DCF Scenarios
- Start Your Engines: SoftBank Corp (9434 JP) Is Off to the Races
1. Takeda: Move Over Newton! Now It’s Spooky Action At a Distance
Over the weekend I published Softbank Corp, Takeda, and Newton’s Three Laws of Motion. Newton’s Three Laws helpfully guide one to understanding the nature of interaction of forces and bodies and the motion which results. Later, Euler’s laws of motion applied a framework for rigid and continuum bodies, and since then “action at a distance” has been replaced be Einstein’s Theory of General Relativity.
After I wrote the bit about one part of the index impact, FTSE unhelpfully changed their mind on timing based on an unhelpful change by the LSE. On Monday, the TSE exercised its discretion – clearly stated in the TOPIX Index Guidebook on p4 (2nd sentence of the opening paragraph) as something it may do – to go its own course in how it will adapt index changes to the first couple of increases in share count due to mergers with foreign corporations.
If an event not specified in this document occurs, or if TSE determines that it is difficult to use the methods described in this document, TSE may use an alternative method of index calculation as it deems appropriate.
So with the changes at FTSE and now TOPIX and JPX Nikkei 400, we no longer have quite the same clarity of forces on the bodies, and therefore less clarity on the resulting motion. The LSE’s announced market change appears to have led the MSCI to change its deletion date for Shire as well, now also (along with FTSE) deleting Shire at the close of the 21st (announcement early this AM Asia time).
Investors have prepared based on the idea that there was a reasonably tight relationship – helped because it was a lot of force applied in a short period (selling and buying all done in a short period in January) between the particles. Now that relationship is being stretched. A lot.
The problem resembles that which Einstein famously pooh-poohed as “Spooky Action At a Distance”. Schrödinger called this entanglement – and it turns out to be one of the weirder branches of quantum mechanics – a field broken wide open by Bell’s Theorem a decade after Einstein shuffled off this mortal coil* – and about which John Wheeler famously said, “If you are not completely confused by quantum mechanics, you do not understand it.”
I cheerfully say quantum mechanics completely baffles me.
I less cheerfully say this whole episode with Takeda and index providers has baffled me too.
But it is important to note that the timing and implications are vastly different than expected just two trading days ago. And the difference is worth thinking about. When the FTSE/MSCI net sell of risk was just 3 days apart, there was a clear connection across that three day distance. Now, the 6-10 week spread of time between the FTSE/MSCI events, the weird two weeks of SETSqx illiquid purgatory just as everyone is full up of risk, then the walk through the Valley of the Shadow of Flowback before we get the first really good net index inclusion to cover the Shire risk people have been dumping for months means that the certainty of understanding the movement of the particle on the other side is substantially lower.
If it all works out well, it might just be Spooky Action At a Distance.
2. Hitachi (6501 JP): A Bold but Risky Acquisition of ABB’s Power Grids
Hitachi Ltd (6501 JP) announced the acquisition of an 80.1% stake in ABB Ltd (ABBN VX)’s power grids business for $6.4 billion. ABB will retain the remaining stake in the divested unit, which is valued at an EV of $11 billion. ABB’s power grids is a global #1 player and makes transformers, long distance electricity-transmission systems and energy storage units.
Setting aside the huge cultural and integration challenges, we believe that Hitachi’s acquisition of ABB’s power grids is a bold but a risky move.
3. Smartkarma’s Week that Was in JP/KR: Softbank, JDI, Pioneer Corp and Doosan Bobcat
Below is the list of the Japan/Korea-related posts put on the Smartkarma platform during the week.
Insight | Insight Provider | Published |
Japan | ||
14/12/2018 | ||
14/12/2018 | ||
13/12/2018 | ||
13/12/2018 | ||
12/12/2018 | ||
12/12/2018 | ||
12/12/2018 | ||
12/12/2018 | ||
12/12/2018 | ||
10/12/2018 | ||
10/12/2018 | ||
10/12/2018 | ||
9/12/2018 | ||
9/12/2018 | ||
9/12/2018 | ||
9/12/2018 | ||
9/12/2018 | ||
9/12/2018 | ||
Korea | ||
10/12/2018 | ||
10/12/2018 | ||
11/12/2018 | ||
12/12/2018 | ||
12/12/2018 | ||
12/12/2018 | ||
12/12/2018 | ||
12/12/2018 | ||
13/12/2018 | ||
13/12/2018 | ||
13/12/2018 | ||
14/12/2018 | ||
14/12/2018 |
4. SoftBank Corp IPO Valuation: Bull/Bear Case DCF Scenarios
Softbank Group (9984 JP) is set to raise JPY2.65 trillion ($23.5 billion) through the Softbank Corp (9434 JP) IPO, Japan’s biggest-ever IPO. However, SoftBank Corp’s IPO which is set for 19 December is oversubscribed by less than double, according to press reports. This level of oversubscription is well below blockbuster Japanese stock debuts such as Mercari Inc (4385 JP) and Recruit Holdings (6098 JP).
Based on client discussion on SoftBank Corp’s intrinsic value, we have put together a DCF-based valuation along with scenario analysis. Our conclusion remains the same that SoftBank Corp is overvalued at the proposed IPO price of JPY1,500 per share.
5. Start Your Engines: SoftBank Corp (9434 JP) Is Off to the Races
The price has been set. The book building is done. Like watching a sleek race car aligned on the starting grid, the world eagerly awaits the start of trading for Softbank Corp (9434 JP) on Wednesday, 19 December.
We are also eager to see the stock go live. It’s not only nostalgia for the stock code “9434” to be brought back into the race, but it will be helpful to be able to compare the stock and to gain better insights into the domestic Japanese telecom industry.
That said, the past few weeks have been full of drama, and some of the drama has longer-term implications. In this insight, we take a more detailed look at some of the challenges facing SoftBank Corp. and some of the concerns that may give investors pause, or at least some things to keep in mind, over the months ahead.
Specifically, we look at issues related to:
- Network outages
- Huawei network equipment
- Corporate governance
- Regulatory headwinds
- Competitive threats
