Brief Industrials: SNC: Downgrade to “HOLD” to Factor in Gloomy Outlook and more

In this briefing:

1. SNC: Downgrade to “HOLD” to Factor in Gloomy Outlook
2. CJ Corp Holdco/Synthetic Sub Trade: Current Status & Trade Approach

1. SNC: Downgrade to “HOLD” to Factor in Gloomy Outlook

SNC’s 4Q18 net profit dropped 39%YoY to Bt72m, lowest in past five quarters.  

• The drop in sales to Bt1.288m (-19%YoY) and the rise in SG&A to sales from 6.6% in 4Q17 to 9.6% are major contributors to the drop in earnings.
• Overall, FY18 net profit was Bt431m (+6%YoY) despite 14% decrease in sales. The strong improvement in its 2018 earnings was due mainly to high restructuring costs in 2017.
• We maintain neutral view toward its 2019-20 outlook due to slow recovery in overall industry.

We cut our target price by 17% to Bt14 (9.6xPE’19E) and downgrade from “BUY” to “HOLD” for gloomy outlook. Despite limit upside, current share price is still cheap compared to historical trading and offer an attractive dividend yield (6.5% in 2019-20E).

2. CJ Corp Holdco/Synthetic Sub Trade: Current Status & Trade Approach

• CJ Corp is a three-sub holdco. CJ Cheiljedang and CJ ENM, account for three fourth of the holdings. CJ Olive Networks accounts for 10%. Olive Young’s growth has slowed down substantially. There is nearly nothing in Holdco’s stub. Holdco price should now be virtually pegged to the two listed subs.
• It’d be safe to do a stub trade with a synthetic sub. I synthesize the four listed subs on a ratio of 50:40:7:3 (CJ Cheiljedang, CJ ENM, CJ CGV and CJ FW). It’d be also fine to do a simpler one with 55:45 on CJ Cheiljedang and CJ ENM only.
• Holdco/Synthetic Sub are now at -0.25σ on a 20D MA. Normally, I wouldn’t make any move at this point. But things still look a bit tempting in favor of Holdco. We are now seeing a much higher price volatility on Korea’s media content stocks including CJ ENM.
• Generally, a higher sub price volatility leads to a higher holdco valuation relative to sub. In addition, this Olive Networks IPO story is being re-ignited by local investors lately. I expect Holdco to hit a +2σ level which we saw late December. I’d go long Holdco and short the synthetic sub even at this point.