In this briefing:
- Hitachi High Tech’s Ace in the Hole
- India Generic Drugs: “Antitrust Unredacted”
- Versum Materials – Merck KGaA Not Going Away (Part II)
- Bristol Myers Squib & Celgene–Starboard Objections Addressed Today- Successful Deal Closure Probable
- Sea Ltd (SE US): The Bear Case – A One-Hit Wonder?
1. Hitachi High Tech’s Ace in the Hole
Last Friday, Hitachi (6501) was reported to be considering selling Hitachi Chemical (4217), according to media sources over the weekend. This has sent Hitachi Chemical and its parent into a frenzy with Hitachi Chemical ADR up 13% last Friday. We believe this news is relevant for Hitachi High Tech because both subsidiaries are 51-52% consolidated by the parent Hitachi, and both have arguably businesses with little synergy with the parent. We believe that Hitachi High Tech is also rumored to be on the block for sale or spin-off. Media sources say that Hitachi is considering a sale of Hitachi Chemical and would reap Y300bn. The current value of their 51% ownership in Hitachi Chemical is Y211bn, and thus there is 42% implied upside if the Y300bn figure is achieved.
To recap Q3 results for Hitachi High Tech from January 31, 2019, the numbers were decent with earnings above consensus forecasts by 33% for Q3 (Y15.8bn OP versus Y13.8bn forecast). The profit rise was due to improved margins in medical and continued strength in process semiconductor equipment. The shares are up 20% year-to-date, outperforming the Nikkei by 15%. Some of the fears of a sharp slowdown in semiconductor have been nullified by the continued strength in logic chip investments as well as the improved profitability in medical clinical analyzers. Medical profits soared 46% YoY in Q3 to Y7.6bn on a 13% YoY increase in revenues. OP margin improved from 12.3% to 15.8% YoY.
2. India Generic Drugs: “Antitrust Unredacted”
New information in the government’s investigation into antitrust violations by generic drug companies continues to surface. An unredacted version of the Attorneys General complaint was published recently by a health care trade publication. The unredacted portions of the document paint an incriminating picture of the industry, increasing the pressure to settle. The timetable for the process remains open-ended, and manufacturers will be reluctant to raise prices absent documentable product shortages. Among the Indian companies, Sun Pharmaceutical Indus (SUNP IN), Dr. Reddy’S Laboratories (DRRD IN), and Aurobindo Pharma (ARBP IN) feature prominently in the court filings.
3. Versum Materials – Merck KGaA Not Going Away (Part II)
Since my initial report on Versum Materials (VSM US) last week, Versum Materials – Entegris Beaten to the Punch by Merck KGaA , I’ve dug deeper and feel even more confident that Merck KGaA (MRK GR) is intent on seeing its proposal to acquire Versum to a successful conclusion, with or without a recommendation from the Versum board.
In this follow-up note I provide an update of events since last week, look at VSM’s corporate governance documents, review relevant landmark Delaware takeover case law, and elaborate on a possible path to control of Versum for Merck KGaA.
4. Bristol Myers Squib & Celgene–Starboard Objections Addressed Today- Successful Deal Closure Probable
The proposed Bristol Myers Squibb Co (BMY US) & Celgene Corp (CELG US) transaction announced in the first week of 2019, garnered many sceptical comments. Starboard Value jumped in the fray by writing a letter denouncing the transaction while one of the largest holders of BMY, Wellington Management Group, holding about 7.7% of the stock expressed a desire to vote against the transaction. BMY’s response to Starboard’s half-baked objections is credible, and in our view, increases the likelihood of a successful closure manifold. We are bullish on the transaction.
5. Sea Ltd (SE US): The Bear Case – A One-Hit Wonder?
Despite burning through $700mn in cash in 2018, investors decided to give another $1.3bn to Sea Ltd (SE US) . We believe investors should treat Sea Ltd with caution for the following reasons:
A significant slowdown in e-commerce
Is the gaming division a one-hit wonder?
Expecting another 800mn cash burn into 2019
Consensus has priced in further upgrades while cash flow metrics worst in the sector
NB. Our team has taken both sides of the Sea Ltd investment case as we think this makes for better decision making and encourages unique thinking within our team. We strongly recommend that investors read my colleague Arun’s positive notes on the company listed below, if you have not already done so.
Sea Ltd (SE US): Placing Price Leaves Money on the Table
Sea Ltd (SE US): Placement a Good Opportunity to Enter an Attractive Story
Get Straight to the Source on Smartkarma
Smartkarma supports the world’s leading investors with high-quality, timely, and actionable Insights. Subscribe now for unlimited access, or request a demo below.