Daily Event-Driven: Softbank: Reduced Yield Competitiveness, End of Passive Buying and Softbank Group’s Hunger for Cash and more

In this briefing:

1. Softbank: Reduced Yield Competitiveness, End of Passive Buying and Softbank Group’s Hunger for Cash
2. Hankook Tire Worldwide Stub Reverse Trade: Massive Price Divergence Is Created Today
3. (Mostly Asia) M&A in 2018: What Was Hot, And What Was Not
4. Healius (HLS AU): Bid Rejection Provides Option Value
5. Poongsan Holdings Stub Trade: Current Status & Trade Approach

1. Softbank: Reduced Yield Competitiveness, End of Passive Buying and Softbank Group’s Hunger for Cash

We are once again turning negative on Softbank Corp (9434 JP) as the stock price is now 18% above the ¥1,200 level which we mentioned looked cheap, outperforming Topix by 20% and the Nikkei by 21%. 

Softbank Corp: When Does It Become a Buy?

In our view this IPO was oversold and probably to numerous weak hands who may now be looking at the large price drops that Softbank Group has occasionally suffered. We would hazard a guess that many of the individuals looking to flip the shares may still not have sold, however, if the stock dips below ¥1,200 we believe risk-reward would tilt positive until the passive buying is complete. Our view on this large drop is mostly that Softbank over-reached in terms of the size of the sale and the valuation.

The business, while subject to various headwinds should still be highly cash generative and at the current price is on just under 13x EV/OP. That’s not particularly cheap but nor is it ridiculously expensive if you believe OP will not drop (we believe it will). With a bit more of a discount and once the initial selling pressure from flippers dies down we believe the yield and passive buying should help the stock find a temporary floor. We do not view this as an attractive long-term holding in any way shape or form, but as a short-term trade the potential to make a 5-10% return on the back of a bounce following panic selling by retail supported by the yield and passive buying seems reasonably good.

Prior to that, we had flagged that retail demand for the IPO could be fragile in Softbank IPO: Signs Point to Risk of Early IPO Price Break and while there was a stronger sell-off than we expected immediately post listing, we would hazard a guess that there could still be an overhang close to the IPO price as there could be significant latent sell volume from retailers hoping to break-even and if that opportunity opens up in a weak market we believe many could choose to sell despite the rebound.

We would point to the news today regarding Softbank Group lowering its planned investment in WeWork from $16bn to just $2bn due to investors in the Vision Fund balking. As perhaps the most aggressive tech investor of the last few years, Softbank stepping back is not a good sign overall and raises questions about the viability of the valuations that other companies in its investment portfolio, namely Uber, are targeting for their upcoming IPOs. With news sources suggesting that Softbank Group is also looking to offload its Nvidia Corp (NVDA US) stake, the tide appears to have truly turned for tech in general and the chronically unprofitable platform companies such as Uber and WeWork in particular.

This raises the governance risks we initially highlighted regarding the use of Softbank Corp for funding the overall Softbank Group. As such, despite a final round of passive buying for Topix buying at the end of the month, the stock price looks vulnerable here.

2. Hankook Tire Worldwide Stub Reverse Trade: Massive Price Divergence Is Created Today

• Hankook Tire Worldwide (000240 KS) is another local single sub dependent holdco in Korea. Hankook Tire (161390 KS) accounts for nearly 90% of the sub holdings. Holdco is now at a 35% discount to NAV. This is substantially better than the local peer average.
• Sub is taking a harsh hit now mainly on concerns over 4Q results. It is currently down 7% today. In contrast, Holdco is holding steady. It is rather up 1%. This is creating a massive price divergence. As of now, they are close to +3 σ on a 20D MA.
• Holdco’s real world float is much less than 10% of total shares. This often serves to help Holdco stave off market volatility like today’s. But this much divergence is a rare one. Sub’s current PER on FY19e is at 7x. This is 20% less than its usual level. It should be that Sub is being oversold.
• I’d make a very short-term trade at this point. I’d go short Holdco and long Sub for a quick mean reversion.

3. (Mostly Asia) M&A in 2018: What Was Hot, And What Was Not

This insight briefly summarises the 93 M&A transactions, with a collective deal size of ~US$215bn, published on Smartkarma in  2018.

Transactions discussed were typically Asia-Pacific-centric or concerned an outbound transaction initiated from an Asia-Pacific-listed company. The majority of these deals involved a market cap/deal size in excess of US$100mn.

The mega deals of Takeda Pharmaceutical (4502 JP)/Shire PLC (SHP LN), Sprint Corp (S US)/T Mobile Us Inc (TMUS US) and Intl Business Machines (IBM US)/Red Hat Inc (RHT US) were first discussed in May, June and November respectively.

• The most generous country? The average premium for Australian and Hong Kong deals was almost identical at 38%.
• The stingiest? Singapore with 16%.
• The graveyard award? 49 deals were completed with 35 ongoing. Australia had four deals (out of a total of 29, the most for any country) that were abandoned for various reasons – such as CKI getting dinged by FIRB in its tilt for APA Group (APA AU). But in terms of outright fails, Hong Kong takes home that award following the failures in Pou Sheng Intl Holdings (3813 HK), Guoco Group Ltd (53 HK) and Spring Real Estate Investment Trust (1426 HK).

During the year a number of large, high profile transactions were completed that were also extensively analysed and discussed on Smartkarma. However, if the initial discussions between the two parties (acquirer & target) took place pre-2018, they are not included in the charts above. A selection of these include (in no particular order): 

Broadcom Corp Cl A (BRCM US)/Qualcomm Inc (QCOM US)
Alps Electric (6770 JP)/Alpine Electronics (6816 JP)
Westfield Corp (WFD AU)/Unibail-Rodamco SE (UL FP)
Idemitsu Kosan (5019 JP)/Showa Shell Sekiyu Kk (5002 JP)
Orient Overseas International (316 HK)

4. Healius (HLS AU): Bid Rejection Provides Option Value

Healius (HLS AU), formerly known as Primary Health Care (PRY AU), is a leading Australian owner of GP clinics and pathology centres. Healius just took four days to reject Jangho Group Co Ltd A (601886 CH)’s 3 January 2018 proposal of A$3.25 cash per share as it “is opportunistic and fundamentally undervalues Healius.”

5. Poongsan Holdings Stub Trade: Current Status & Trade Approach

• Poongsan Holdings (005810 KS) is another clear-cut target of stub trade in Korea. Poongsan Corp (103140 KS) is responsible for nearly 80% of the sub holdings. Holdco is currently at a 53% discount to NAV. Holdco discount has narrowed. But it is still substantially higher than the local average of 40%.
• Sub is having a run today. It went as high as 6% today. Currently, it is up 4%. Holdco is up 2%. They are now close to -1 σ on a 20D MA. Poongsan business is highly exposed to copper price and US ammunition demand. It still appears that Poongsan is suffering from a weaker copper price and falling demand of ammunition in US.
• I’d make a trade on a short-term horizon. I’d capitalize on a divergence on a 20D MA. I’d wait a bit until later today when there is a little greater price divergence on the duo. I’d make a stub trade when the price ratio on a 20D MA once again enters < -1 σ territory.