In this briefing:
- Youngone Holdco/Sub Trade: Price Divergence Got Too Wide
- Delta Electronics (DELTA TB): Little Option but to Accept the Tender Offer
- StubWorld: Matheson’s Strategic Buying of Strategic
- Orion Holdco/Sub Trade: Holdco’s Price Catching up Was Overworked, Time for Sub to Catch Up
- GrainCorp (GNC AU): Better Late than Never Move to Get an LTAP Binding Proposal
1. Youngone Holdco/Sub Trade: Price Divergence Got Too Wide
- Youngone Holdings (009970 KS) is another single-sub holdco. Youngone Corp (111770 KS) is the largest sub that accounts for 70% of Holdco NAV. Youngone is one of Korea’s two largest OEM apparel manufacturers. On a 20D MA, they are now at 312% of σ. Current price ratio is at a 120D high. Holdco discount is 27.5% to NAV.
- I am not seeing any substantial factor that can explain this much price divergence in the last two days. There is a growing concern over Sub’s labor cost. This may explain Sub’s price plunge. But this isn’t enough to explain the current huge price divergence.
- In the last 120 days, we’ve had a couple of radical divergences. All of these got quickly reverted to mean. I expect the same to happen this time. At this much divergence, there is a little chance of further widening. I’d go short Holdco and long Sub. Just, Holdco liquidity can be an issue here.
2. Delta Electronics (DELTA TB): Little Option but to Accept the Tender Offer
Delta Electronics (2308 TT) (DEI) launched the conditional voluntary tender offer for Delta Electronics Thai (DELTA TB) (Delta), an electronics contract manufacturer, on 26 February 2019. The tender offer of THB71.00 cash per share values Delta at an EV of THB72 billion ($2.2 billion).
Delta and DEI have close links as they were both founded by billionaire Bruce Cheng. Consequently, the tender offer could be viewed as a mechanism for the Chen family to sell their stake to a “friendly” DEI. For minority shareholders, we believe that DEI’s tender offer is reasonable and it makes little sense for minority shareholders to hold on to their shares.
3. StubWorld: Matheson’s Strategic Buying of Strategic
This week in StubWorld …
- Jardine Matheson Hldgs (JM SP)‘s recent buying of Jardine Strategic Hldgs (JS SP) is nothing new and follows a long-term plan to fortify the cross-holding structure.
Preceding my comments on Jardine and other stubs are the weekly setup/unwind tables for Asia-Pacific Holdcos.
These relationships trade with a minimum liquidity threshold of US$1mn on a 90-day moving average, and a % market capitalisation threshold – the $ value of the holding/opco held, over the parent’s market capitalisation, expressed in percent – of at least 20%.
4. Orion Holdco/Sub Trade: Holdco’s Price Catching up Was Overworked, Time for Sub to Catch Up
- Orion Holdco/Sub duo is now above +2σ on a 20D MA. They made nearly 2σ jump in just two trading days. Price ratio is currently at a 120D high. Holdco discount to NAV dropped 4%p from 50% to 46% since last time we checked on Jan 24.
- China easing wind began to blow into Korea since late last year. This China expectation had pushed up both Holdco and Sub. Sub had reacted more sensitively to it. Sub has undergone a price correction lately. Holdco has done a lot of catching up during this period. Now, Holdco surpassed Sub in terms of price return. Holdco climbed 32% from its 52W low. Sub went up 30% from its 52W low.
- Holdco is preparing its own business operation, water purifier, in China. This may act as a divergence factor. But at this point, Holdco’s own business in China has no meaningful substance that can shake its NAV radically. They must be reverted back to mean. Their price return got reversed in favor of Holdco. Holdco’s price catching up should be done now. It is time to go long Sub and short Holdco.
5. GrainCorp (GNC AU): Better Late than Never Move to Get an LTAP Binding Proposal
Graincorp Ltd A (GNC AU)‘s ability to generate shareholder value remains in doubt as LTAP enters its fourth month of due diligence. Yesterday, GrainCorp announced the first result (but overdue) of its portfolio review – the deal to sell its Australian bulk liquid terminals business to ANZ Terminals for A$350 million.
The option with the highest potential to unlock shareholder value remains the LTAP bid. The sale of the Australian bulk liquid terminals business would represent 13% of the current EV which in the absence of an LTAP bid, is unlikely to sustain GrainCorp’s current rating. However, we believe that the proposed sale is a necessary step to push LTAP towards a binding proposal.
Get Straight to the Source on Smartkarma
Smartkarma supports the world’s leading investors with high-quality, timely, and actionable Insights. Subscribe now for unlimited access, or request a demo below.