In this briefing:
- Bank Danamon Goes Ex-Rights
- Nutrien’s Move On Ruralco Makes Agronomic Sense
- Nexon M&A: Amazon & Comcast Enter the Race – It Ain’t Over Till Its Over!
- Korean Stubs Spotlight: Focus on Diverging Share Prices and Changes to Foreign Ownership
- Diageo Proposes Another Partial Tender for Sichuan Swellfun
1. Bank Danamon Goes Ex-Rights
The process of the merger between Bank Danamon Indonesia (BDMN IJ) and Mitsubishi Ufj Financial (8306 JP)‘s local unit Bank Nusantara Parahyangan (BBNP IJ) is proceeding apace.
Today, the shares go ex-rights for shareholders looking to both vote on March 26th and, assuming the vote goes through, to elect to receive cash of IDR 9,590 instead of continuing to hold shares. BDMN shares are trading down, as expected.
2. Nutrien’s Move On Ruralco Makes Agronomic Sense
Ruralco Holdings (RHL AU) has announced it has entered into a Scheme Implementation Deed in which Nutrien Ltd (NTR CN) has agreed to take Ruralco private at $4.40/share – a 44% premium to last close and the one-month VWAP. The Offer values Ruralco at A$469mn and an enterprise value of $615mn.
A fully franked special dividend of A$0.90 will reduce the Scheme consideration. An interim dividend of A$0.10 will be added.
The Scheme is subject to shareholder approval, and approval from the ACCC and FIRB. Previous commentary bv ACCC’s Rod Sims would indicate this regulatory approval will not be an issue.
Ruralco’s directors unanimously recommend the Offer in the absence of a superior proposal and a favourable independent expert opinion.
Concerning shareholder reception to the Scheme, Ruralco’s CEO Travis Dillon said “The feedback we’ve had … with all stakeholders, but including our shareholders (has been) overwhelmingly positive.“
This is a pretty clean deal and the gross/annualised spread of 1.4%/4.1%, assuming late June completion, reflects this.
A counter offer from Elders Ltd (ELD AU) cannot be ruled out. But given its comparative size, Nutrien would be the likely winner in such a scrap, potentially reducing the likelihood of Elders making an offer.
3. Nexon M&A: Amazon & Comcast Enter the Race – It Ain’t Over Till Its Over!
In a surprising move, it was reported after the market close today that Amazon.com Inc (AMZN US) (market cap of US$804 billion) and Comcast (US$176 billion) will enter the race and have submitted initial bids to acquire Nexon Co Ltd (3659 JP)/NXC Corp.
The entrance of Amazon and Comcast is a major positive surprise and it should have a strong positive impact on Nexon’s share price. Prior to the entrance of Amazon and Comcast in this M&A battle, the market was firmly leaning towards the consortium including Tencent, Netmarble Games, and MBK Partners to acquire NXC Corp/Nexon.
Now, Amazon and Comcast’s entrance into this M&A battle has made it a lot more exciting and uncertain. Nexon Co Ltd (3659 JP)‘s share price is up 19% YTD but its share price trend has been flattening out in February. In the next few weeks, we expect further boost to Nexon’s share price (15%+), mainly because a lot more investors will think that the Tencent consortium, Amazon, and Comcast will try to pay higher price to acquire NXC Corp/Nexon. Kudos to Nexon shareholders!
4. Korean Stubs Spotlight: Focus on Diverging Share Prices and Changes to Foreign Ownership
In this report, we provide the one year share price comparisons of the holdcos and the opcos in both table and chart formats as well as changes to the foreign ownership stakes of these companies YTD. Significant, rapid changes to the foreign shareholdings of these companies sometimes lead to opportunities in the holdco/opco pair trades.
Among these 30 pair of companies, five pairs in particular are interesting where the difference in their share prices have diverged significantly in the past year (by 30% or more). These five pairs of companies include the following:
- Hyosung Corp vs. Hyosung Advanced Materials
- BGF Retail vs. BGF Co.
- Doosan Corp vs. Doosan Heavy Industries Corp.
- Cuckoo Holdings vs. Cuckoo Homesys
- Orion Holdings vs. Orion Corp
5. Diageo Proposes Another Partial Tender for Sichuan Swellfun
UK alcoholic drinks conglomerate Diageo Plc (DGE LN) bought a stake in Sichuan Swellfun Co Ltd A (600779 CH) in 2007, then through a 49% stake in Sichuan Chengdu Quanxing Group which owned ~40% of the Chinese baiju maker. In 2011 Diageo raised its stake in Sichuan Chengdu Quanxing Group from 49% to 53% by paying US$21mm to Chengdu Yingsheng Investment Holding Co. which lowered its stake to 47%.
In 2013, Diageo spent £233m to buy out Chengdu Yingsheng Investment Holding Co.’s 47% to go from a consolidated 21.05% to 39.71% in Swellfun (which is also named Sichuan Shui Jing Fang, after one of its brands).
Last summer, Diageo offered to buy 20.29% of the shares outstanding in a Partial Tender Offer (PTO) which was announced June 25th leading to a brief pop to RMB 60.0, and then launched a few weeks later at RMB 62.00 a share, which was a 22.6% premium to the then-current share price. The shares paid a RMB 0.62 dividend on August 1st and the PTO price was lowered to RMB 61.38 accordingly.
Last year’s Partial Tender was for 99,127,820 shares to be acquired out of a total free-float of 294,546,100 shares, which gave a minimum pro-ration of 36.65%. Surprisingly, pro-ration ended up being quite low at ~40.1%. The shares fell sharply and buy-and-tender trades done at the low were OK but in the mid 50s were not.
The shares languished as the economy softened, real estate transactions slowed, and conspicuous consumption continued to be frowned upon, and buy-and-tender-and-own-back-end trades did not do well (though owning A-shares in general did not do well either) as the shares troughed at less than half the tender offer price.
The New News
On 26 February 2019, Diageo announced it had approached the board of directors of Sichuan Swellfun with a proposal to increase its stake from 60% to 70% at RMB 45.00. This was a 19.33% premium to the last close and a 40.05% premium to the 30-day average.
The proposal was announced on the Shanghai Stock Exchange as well in Chinese.
This deal obviously has a lower minimum pro-ration, and the shares have jumped limit up this morning to RMB 41.48 leaving only 8.49% upside if you can buy at limit up today. At 25% pro-ration, breakeven is RMB 40.31, 6.9% higher than yesterday’s close. Assuming yesterday’s close is The Right Price, today’s limit up would give an implied expected pro-ration of 55%, implying only 18.2% of the remaining 40% of shares outstanding would tender.
What To Do?
That is the question. A-shares are on a tear, with the SSE-SZSE 300 up 23% ytd. Historically, bull markets are good to buy. Consensus forecasts have come down so there is a reason why the shares fell to where they did, but even though consensus EPS for 2019 as of six months ago is now the consensus EPS estimate for Dec 2020, on 2019 the shares at the Proposed Tender Offer Price are at less than 30x PER and less than 24x Dec 2020.
If you are buying these to get the minimum pro-ration on a target price equivalent to the offered Tender Offer Price, don’t bother. If you are looking at this as a cheap put because you may decide to downsize your position if the A-share rally sees the brakes applied, this is more interesting.
This is a trader’s trade rather than an arbitrageur’s trade and should be dealt with accordingly.
Breakeven Arb Grids for Price, PER, PBR, EV/EBITDA below.
Get Straight to the Source on Smartkarma
Smartkarma supports the world’s leading investors with high-quality, timely, and actionable Insights. Subscribe now for unlimited access, or request a demo below.
