Daily Brief China: Techtronic Industries, Alibaba Group, Sino Oil And Gas Holdings, iShares MSCI ACWI ETF, Tencent, Shui On Land and more

• Jehoshaphat’s short report has alleged that Techtronic Industries (669 HK)/TTI has been inflating its profits dramatically for over a decade with manipulative accounting.
• Our forensic analysis of the allegations suggests that some are credible red flags while others are essentially an exaggeration.
• TTI’s response to Jehoshaphat is pitiful. Valuation is meaningless until management adopts more conservative accounting or compelling disprove the allegations.

• Alibaba’s 3QFY23 results marginally topped consensus. With the share price dropping 0.65% cf. +0.35% for the index, both results and the price reaction were in line with our expectations.
• Yesterday’s results confirm that Alibaba (ADR) (BABA US)’s core businesses, Taobao and Tmall are in trouble and cost-cutting elsewhere is insufficient to offset the short-term weakness.
• Therefore, we do think that this is a good opportunity to profit on the short side with Alibaba shares having the potential to fall another 40-45% in the short term.

• Techtronic Industries (669 HK) was targeted by Jehoshaphat Research (JR) accusing that the company’s profits are inflated dramatically over a decade with manipulative accounting.
• As per the report, routine expenses incurred have been booked under various asset accounts such as deferred development costs thereby showing ever increasing margins for a cyclical business.
• We have assessed the merits of some of these claims using our forensic accounting framework and it appears that most of the claims are very difficult to refute.

• Troubled coalbed methane play Sino Oil And Gas Holdings (702 HK) is currently suspended pursuant to the Hong Kong Code on Takeovers and Mergers. 
• Sino Oil is burdened with a large convertible note and a winding-up petition.  Its auditor has disclaimed accounts since 2017 over its ability to continue as a going concern.
• Jiangxi Jovo Energy (605090 CH) is interested in taking more than 50% of Sino Oil (via new shares), but less than 75%. Sino Oil is up >100% in the past month. 

• In our latest int’l reports we have preached caution, and since January we have discussed our expectations for $93 to cap upside on the ACWI-US
• Thus far, $93 has proven to be rock-solid resistance, and ACWI-US now displays a 4.5-month uptrend violation signaling the pullback has officially begun.
• We would expect this pullback to continue down to $86-87 at minimum, and potentially $84 (December 2022 low). Even $75-77 (the 2022 lows) is not out of the question.

• Tencent faced formidable resistance at 385 where old lows and old highs coincided and was our short level outlined on January 17.
• 300 is our base line downside target. March will be a bearish month. Buy zone at sub-300.
• Macro is constructive if 270 holds. Current decline is labeled a deep correction of the October to late January rally.

We view Shui On as “Medium Risk” on the LARA scale. Our opinion is underpinned by the company’s portfolio of high-quality assets situated in prime locations in major Chinese cities. Shui On has a large investment property portfolio, which generates sufficient recurring revenue to cover more than 1x of adjusted interest expense. The investment properties were worth CNY 51.2 bn as at end-June 2022, covering net debt by 1.7x. Moreover, the company can dispose assets to boost cash flow if needed. These positive factors are balanced against Shui On’s small scale and lumpy earnings profile.

Our fundamental Credit Bias on Shui On is “Stable”, supported by the improved operating and financing environment for stronger Chinese developers. The company has a high-quality asset base and sizeable investment property portfolio, which would support access to bank financing. We also believe Shui On’s differentiated business model (compared to peers with heavy reliance on property development) will thrive in the post-property crisis environment.

Controversies are “Immaterial” and the ESG Impact on Credit is “Neutral”. Shui On’s management appears to place a strong emphasis on ESG issues, and we note positively the company’s high level of disclosure and transparency.