Brief Consumer: BGF Holdco/Sub Trade: Sub Overbuying Wouldn’t Last Another Day and more

In this briefing:

1. BGF Holdco/Sub Trade: Sub Overbuying Wouldn’t Last Another Day
2. Parco: 4 New Shopping Centres This Year, 28% Rise in Revenue in 5 Years to 2021
3. Valuetronics (VALUE SP): Trade War Uncertainty Continues, Downside Supported by Large Cash Position
4. FRETAIL IN
5. Puregold Price Club: Steady Grower with Provincial Expansion Story

1. BGF Holdco/Sub Trade: Sub Overbuying Wouldn’t Last Another Day

• BGF Sub had a 5.39% gain on better-than-expected 4Q18 results. Holdco stayed flat. As a result, we had a 2+σ jump from 95% of σ to -133% of σ. This is the widest jump in 120D. Holdco discount is currently at 47% to NAV.
• On a 120D horizon, price ratio is still well below 120D mean. Despite recent gains, Holdco price relative to Sub is nearly 20+%p down since 120D ago. 4Q results seem to be encouraging. But local sentiments are still heavily divided on Sub’s fundamentals. 4Q results aren’t strong enough to turn the tide drastically.
• Sub has been one of the most heavily shorted stocks in Korea lately. Yesterday’s huge gain might have been a short covering. This shouldn’t be a structural price pushing up for Sub. Sub staying below -1σ wouldn’t last another day. I expect a quick mean reversion at this point.

2. Parco: 4 New Shopping Centres This Year, 28% Rise in Revenue in 5 Years to 2021

Parco (8251 JP) is enjoying a new lease of life under J Front Retailing (3086 JP) ownership, investing assiduously in updating existing buildings and showing a decisiveness to rebuild entirely where location merits it and even closing down stores that don’t work.

It will celebrate its 50th anniversary this year by opening four new buildings, including the flagship Parco Shibuya and is forecasting a 28% rise in revenue for 2016-2021.

3. Valuetronics (VALUE SP): Trade War Uncertainty Continues, Downside Supported by Large Cash Position

Valuetronics reported its 3Q19 figures this week which showed a 7.5% decline in revenues but a small (+2.6%) increase in bottom line profits. Stronger margins in its ICE segment offset weakness in its CE segment.

Valuetronics Holdings (VALUE SP) remains a solid company run by a good management team with interesting clients in consumer electronics and automotive. The valuation of the company is cheap (5x ex-cash 2019 P/E) and the balance sheet is rock solid.

All these positives are currently being overshadowed by the US-China trade war as the company has 100% of its production in China and does 45.7% of its sales in North-America. While many companies try to downplay the impact of the trade-war Valuetronics cannot hide and the alternatives it is working on to offset the tariff impact will surely cause short-term disruption and increased costs.

YTD the share price is +12% as the market is hoping for a positive resolution to the US-China trade war. Management is cautious on macro political improvements as trade war friction is unlikely to dissipate soon. Given the weak outlook for its CE segment and no significant new customer wins in its ICE segment risk/reward does not seem very attractive despite good dividend yield and cheap valuation.

4. FRETAIL IN

We visit the large format stores of Future Retail (FRETAIL IN) fbb, Big Bazaar and Big Bazaar Gen Next, along with visiting stores run by Future Lifestyle Fashions (FLFL IN) Brand Factory and Central in Ahmedabad, Gujarat to understand some of the drivers behind SSSG of over 10% over the last 15 consecutive quarters. Our regional checks indicate the large format growth might be maintained in the future driven by loyalty programs like Future Pay. Interestingly the group has resorted to using its stores to mobilise funds for its fixed deposits, which could be a final indication that the planned of deal with Amazon.com Inc (AMZN US) is finally being called off.

5. Puregold Price Club: Steady Grower with Provincial Expansion Story

• Conference call with the IR of Puregold Price Club (PGOLD PM) reveals that SSSG grew healthily at 6.5% YoY in 9M18, thanks to personal income tax cut.
• The bigger growth driver is provincial expansion (outside Metro Manila), which would allow PGOLD to achieve mid-teen sales growth.
• There has been little to no sales impact from e-commerce as e-commerce penetration in Philippines is lagging even in the ASEAN context. 
• PGOLD trades at 18.3x 2019E PE, a 15% discount to peers average of 21.6x