Brief China: China Three Gorges’ Rebuttable Presumption and more

In this briefing:

1. China Three Gorges’ Rebuttable Presumption
2. Haitian: Trade War Fears Fade, Full Stream Ahead
3. Huishang Bank: Subpar Earnings and Asset Quality Indicate Caution
4. The Two Flavours of Kool-Aid
5. Bilibili Offering: Unnecessary and Opportunistic

1. China Three Gorges’ Rebuttable Presumption

In my initial insight on China Power New Energy Development Co (735 HK, “CPNED”)‘s privatisation by China Power New Energy Limited (the Offeror) by way of a Scheme, I concluded China Three Gorges, CPNED’s largest shareholder with 27.10%, will likely be required to abstain at the Court Meeting as it is presumed to be a connected party to the Offeror as per the Takeovers Code.

But the announcement states that CTG has given an irrevocable undertaking to vote for the Scheme and to elect the share alternative.

It seems illogical to mention in the irrevocable CTG will vote for the Scheme when in actuality it cannot vote. So, which one is it?

The short answer is: CTG cannot currently vote. 

But understanding this requires diving into the minutiae of Hong Kong’s Takeovers Code. So I do.

2. Haitian: Trade War Fears Fade, Full Stream Ahead

We expect Haitian’s margins go up in 2019, because 1) steel price in China is expected to decrease by 10% yoy with the re-balance of sector demand-supply, 2) Haitian’s newly launched third generation PIMM, and increasing sales propotion of high margin products, would improve the company’s overall margin.

Market demand is warming up in March, according to the management. The third generation PIMM is expected to trigger clients’ demand on upgrading their existing machines. High margin products, all-electric PIMM and large two-plate PIMM, would further increasing their sales and profit contribution. Overseas revenue growth would continue going faster than domestic revenue growth, with its new plants in Germany and Turkey coming on stream. We estimate Haitian’s net profit growth to reach 15% yoy in 2019E, vs. a 4% yoy decline in 2018.

Market concern on potential risk from Trade War, which had triggered Haitian’s valuation de-rating, should fade. As we expected, Haitian’s business wasn’t hurt by the Trade War in 2018, as the company has only 3% of overall revenue from US market. And the negotiations between US and China are on the right way to terminate the Trade War. Valuation re-rating might come with earnings improvement.

3. Huishang Bank: Subpar Earnings and Asset Quality Indicate Caution

Huishang Bank Corp Ltd H (3698 HK) looks interesting at first. Some trends are moving in the right direction and the valuation is hardly stretched.

So it seems. Closer inspection reveals subpar earnings quality and pressure on the top line from an elevated growth in funding costs and a double-digit reduction in income from non-credit earning assets. Impairments weighed heavily on the bottom line. Underlying “jaws” were extremely negative, putting the decrease in the Cost-Income ratio into perspective.

An improving NPL ratio of 0.95% (or 1.04% depending on which one you use) does not tell the whole story at all. Asset quality issues, of course, come through in the income statement with writedowns and loan loss provisions consuming a huge (and increasing) chunk of pre-impairment profit. The Balance Sheet exhibits strains and stresses from an explosion of doubtful loans, rising substandard loans, and arguably an unhealthy expansion of special mention loans. At least “unimpaired past-due” loans have moderated though they stand at 45% of headline NPLs. Some key capitalisation metrics are deteriorating while liquidity erodes given the 23% growth in credit which flatters the problem loan picture.

4. The Two Flavours of Kool-Aid

Suning, Alibaba, & Tencent Holdings join forces with three state-owned auto co’s to challenge Didi on ridesharing in China. LYFT Kool-Aid becomes more toxic with five new strategic developments in the past week. lululemon’s DTC reaches nearly 30% of sales in Q4.

• lululemon: lululemon is looking to further leverage its cult-like following by investing in its digital ecosystem and launching a nationwide membership program as DTC reaches nearly 30% of sales in Q4.
• Dollarama & Sleep Country Canada: We continue to caution against these value traps as Dollarama is still focusing on the base of the value pyramid and Sleep Country’s structural risk continues to rise with Casper looking to IPO.
• Lyft: In the past week, there have been five new major strategic developments that add to the toxicity of the LYFT Kool-Aid.

My heart pounded as I sat in the WeWork conference room on Thursday, staring at the Skype screen, waiting to be interviewed live on Yahoo! Finance’s morning show by its host, Alexis Christofouros, on why I wasn’t drinking the LYFT Kool-Aid. I wish I could go back on the show as since I published my report just a week ago, there have been five major strategic developments, adding to the toxicity of the LYFT Kool-Aid. But I’m excited about the upcoming stampede of unicorns as my mindset is what Heidi Grant Halvorson and E. Tory Higgins call “promotion focus”, as they describe in their book Focus: Use Different Ways of Seeing the World for Success and Influence: “Promotion focus is about maximizing gains and avoiding missed opportunities. Prevention focus, on the other hand, is about minimizing losses” Just like we saw with the dotcoms nearly two decades ago, promotion-focused investors are now in danger of getting caught up in the “cult-like following” of these unicorns and drinking what I call the “pink Kool-Aid”.

Prevention-focused investors are also at risk of drinking the Kool-Aid. But the Kool-Aid in this case is blue, not pink, and the danger is the toxicity of “blue Kool-Aid” increases as the rate of structural disruption increases. For example, back in January 2008, I warned investors to stop drinking Yellow Pages’ “blue Kool-Aid” as I was worried the accelerating shift to online and emergence of the then new online disruptors like Facebook and Craigslist would increase its business risk profile. And I continue to caution investors against drinking the “blue Kool-Aid” of Canadian retailers like Dollarama and Sleep Country Canada as they still operate mainly at the base of the value pyramid.

5. Bilibili Offering: Unnecessary and Opportunistic

On Monday, Bilibili Inc (BILI US) unveiled plans to raise around $192 million (based on the closing price of $18.95 per ADS) through a public offering of 10.6 million ADS and a concurrent offering of $300 million convertible senior notes. Also, certain selling shareholders will offer 6.5 ADS in the offering.