In this briefing:
- AIG Sells PICC: A Clean-Up Trade Cum Liquidity Event
- Autohome (ATHM): Promising Auto Loan, Waiting for Buying Opportunity
- Futu Holdings IPO – Given the Team, Execution, and Backers, Might Be Worth a Look at the Low-End
- Diageo Proposes Another Partial Tender for Sichuan Swellfun
1. AIG Sells PICC: A Clean-Up Trade Cum Liquidity Event
AIG is selling its USD 450 million stakes in PICC today after market close. The deal scores negatively in our ECM Framework.
We like the fact that it will increase the free-float significantly and hence there will be a liquidity event, meanwhile, we are also concerned that the deal size is large compared to its liquidity.
2. Autohome (ATHM): Promising Auto Loan, Waiting for Buying Opportunity
- The 4Q2018 results suggest that it is a right decision to close out direct automobile sales and start auto loan.
- The 4Q2018 results also suggest that ATHM has successfully completed the post-acquisition integration after three years.
- Peer companies’P/E ratios suggest ATHM is fairly valued, but we believe it will be a good opportunity to accumulate if the stock price falls.
3. Futu Holdings IPO – Given the Team, Execution, and Backers, Might Be Worth a Look at the Low-End
Futu Holdings Ltd (FHL US) plans to raise upto US$130m in its US listing. The deal has been downsized from its earlier indicative size of US$300m and the valuation too has been downsized by almost the same extent to around US$1.2-1.5bn.
In my earlier insights, Futu Holdings Pre-IPO – Great Metrics but in a Commoditised Industry and Futu Holdings Pre-IPO – FY18 Updates And Quick Thoughts on Valuation, I looked at the company’s background and past financial performance.
In this insight, I’ll run the deal through our IPO framework and comment on valuations. At the low-end the deal might be worth looking into, although free-float might end up being very small owing to US$30m being taken up Tencent which would leave just about US$100m as free-float.
4. Diageo Proposes Another Partial Tender for Sichuan Swellfun
UK alcoholic drinks conglomerate Diageo Plc (DGE LN) bought a stake in Sichuan Swellfun Co Ltd A (600779 CH) in 2007, then through a 49% stake in Sichuan Chengdu Quanxing Group which owned ~40% of the Chinese baiju maker. In 2011 Diageo raised its stake in Sichuan Chengdu Quanxing Group from 49% to 53% by paying US$21mm to Chengdu Yingsheng Investment Holding Co. which lowered its stake to 47%.
In 2013, Diageo spent £233m to buy out Chengdu Yingsheng Investment Holding Co.’s 47% to go from a consolidated 21.05% to 39.71% in Swellfun (which is also named Sichuan Shui Jing Fang, after one of its brands).
Last summer, Diageo offered to buy 20.29% of the shares outstanding in a Partial Tender Offer (PTO) which was announced June 25th leading to a brief pop to RMB 60.0, and then launched a few weeks later at RMB 62.00 a share, which was a 22.6% premium to the then-current share price. The shares paid a RMB 0.62 dividend on August 1st and the PTO price was lowered to RMB 61.38 accordingly.
Last year’s Partial Tender was for 99,127,820 shares to be acquired out of a total free-float of 294,546,100 shares, which gave a minimum pro-ration of 36.65%. Surprisingly, pro-ration ended up being quite low at ~40.1%. The shares fell sharply and buy-and-tender trades done at the low were OK but in the mid 50s were not.
The shares languished as the economy softened, real estate transactions slowed, and conspicuous consumption continued to be frowned upon, and buy-and-tender-and-own-back-end trades did not do well (though owning A-shares in general did not do well either) as the shares troughed at less than half the tender offer price.
The New News
On 26 February 2019, Diageo announced it had approached the board of directors of Sichuan Swellfun with a proposal to increase its stake from 60% to 70% at RMB 45.00. This was a 19.33% premium to the last close and a 40.05% premium to the 30-day average.
The proposal was announced on the Shanghai Stock Exchange as well in Chinese.
This deal obviously has a lower minimum pro-ration, and the shares have jumped limit up this morning to RMB 41.48 leaving only 8.49% upside if you can buy at limit up today. At 25% pro-ration, breakeven is RMB 40.31, 6.9% higher than yesterday’s close. Assuming yesterday’s close is The Right Price, today’s limit up would give an implied expected pro-ration of 55%, implying only 18.2% of the remaining 40% of shares outstanding would tender.
What To Do?
That is the question. A-shares are on a tear, with the SSE-SZSE 300 up 23% ytd. Historically, bull markets are good to buy. Consensus forecasts have come down so there is a reason why the shares fell to where they did, but even though consensus EPS for 2019 as of six months ago is now the consensus EPS estimate for Dec 2020, on 2019 the shares at the Proposed Tender Offer Price are at less than 30x PER and less than 24x Dec 2020.
If you are buying these to get the minimum pro-ration on a target price equivalent to the offered Tender Offer Price, don’t bother. If you are looking at this as a cheap put because you may decide to downsize your position if the A-share rally sees the brakes applied, this is more interesting.
This is a trader’s trade rather than an arbitrageur’s trade and should be dealt with accordingly.
Breakeven Arb Grids for Price, PER, PBR, EV/EBITDA below.
Get Straight to the Source on Smartkarma
Smartkarma supports the world’s leading investors with high-quality, timely, and actionable Insights. Subscribe now for unlimited access, or request a demo below.
