Daily Equities Bottom-Up: US Speciality Lenders – Worse Credit Metrics, Especially Personal Loans and more

In this briefing:

1. US Speciality Lenders – Worse Credit Metrics, Especially Personal Loans
2. Credit Bank of Moscow: A Highly Ranked EM Opportunity
3. Rides War Has Shifted To Share of Wallet
4. Indonesian Telcos: Mobile Pricing Should Continue to Recover. Telkom Remains Our Top Pick
5. Z IN

1. US Speciality Lenders – Worse Credit Metrics, Especially Personal Loans

We look at credit metrics of three specialty lenders in the US, for newly announced results. Discover Financial Services (DFS US) mostly provides credit card loans, but additionally it provides student loans and personal loans. The last category is where there is the most deterioration in the just-reported 4Q18 results, and it goes to our concerns about the reported ‘robustness’ of the US economy.  The company’s charge off rate in personal loans rose to 4.49% in 4Q18. The figure was 3.62% in 4Q17 and 2.70% in 4Q16. This is considerable deterioration. Even where some of the credit metrics in credit card loans is not as dire, the direction is of concern. All said, perhaps this is one reason that DFS falls into our growing bucket of financial companies with declining QoQ profit in 4Q18? Credit metrics at Sallie Mae and Synchrony Financial, do not leave us sanguine about the US consumer either. 

2. Credit Bank of Moscow: A Highly Ranked EM Opportunity

Founded in 1992 and acquired by Mr. Roman Avdeev in 1994,Credit Bank Of Moscow Pjsc (CBOM RM) benefits from an entrenched market position and strong brand recognition in its strategic market of Moscow which represents 25% of Russian GDP. CBM is an established operation in Moscow and the Moscow region with over 7,000 devices in high traffic locations.

CBM has expanded fast, from commanding a mere 0.7% share of system Assets in 2013 to 2.9% today.

The bank has a defined strategy underpinned by blue-chip, large, and medium-sized corporate services (fees, settlements, cash handling); high-margin consumer lending; and investment banking (SOVA Capital synergies, interbank, ECM, DCM, M&A). CBM commands a client-base of 15k corporates: companies represent 87% of loans. The bank has 1.5MM retail customers: accounting for a third of deposits.

In 2015 CBM acquired Inkakhran, swelling its nationwide cash handling market share to 17%. In this segment, CBM commands a client-base of 3k, of which 164 are banks, with 876 armoured vehicles covering 33k collection points.

Management is focused on above-system growth, based on a relatively robust liquid Balance Sheet, reducing funding costs, and enhancing operating efficiency and productivity. 2018 was marked by building up liquidity and strengthening capital adequacy as well as managing Balance Sheet risk -after 5 years of forceful growth- while maintaining profitability and cost efficiencies.

Technology highlights include the Your Bank Online system, MKB Business, and Foreign Exchange Control Dashboard.

Avdeev’s Rossium, a domestic group with interests in agriculture, timber, oil and a pharmacy chain, is the majority shareholder (56%) while the EBRD holds a position which reduces the float (18%). The supervisory board contains 5 out of 10 independent non executives while 2 more are nominees of minority shareholders. Related party lending is 3.5% of the loan book. Rosneft exposure though represents a caveat to CBM and to the system in general though some view this more of a strength.

3. Rides War Has Shifted To Share of Wallet

Grab is not just challenging the usual passengers-ride and taxi market; it has upped its game by selling monthly subscription plans, which can build recurring users. It is also looking to take bigger slices of business trips, traditionally the more lucrative pie for local taxi companies and niche car rental companies.

This report explains why Grab has gone into this promotional strategy, and is divided into five parts:

1. Monthly Subscription Plans 

2. Better Allocation of Resources 

3. The Juicy Corporate Pie

4. Fare comparison between Grab, Go-Jek, CD

5. Conclusions

4. Indonesian Telcos: Mobile Pricing Should Continue to Recover. Telkom Remains Our Top Pick

Over the past three years, an aggressive price war has pushed Indonesian data prices down 80% to unsustainable levels. With the exception of India, and Jio’s moves there, Indonesia now has the cheapest data in markets we track globally. However, there have been signs recently of tariff stability, with Telkomsel’s tariff rising 7%. Investors’ main concern, and the key risk to being bullish on the sector in Indonesia, is the risk a price war breaks out again. We think that is unlikely. The smaller telcos are not making sufficient returns to cover capex and finance costs and market share gains alone will not save them. Something needs to give: either prices rise and/or smaller players consolidate. Rumors swirling around Indosat (ISAT IJ) in recent days suggest consolidation may be under consideration again. 

Our view is that the price cycle has turned in Indonesia and consolidation is likely. That underpins our positive view on Indonesian telcos. We look for Telkom Indonesia (TLKM IJ) to deliver strong growth from its two major engines: mobile through Telkomsel and fixed line (broadband). The stock has done reasonably well since mid-2018, but we see upside and rate the shares a Buy with a raised target price of IDR5,250. We continue to like the re-rating story at XL Axiata (EXCL IJ), and remain Buyers with a price target of IDR5,200. Indosat’s share price has soared in recent days and we have now cut the stock to a Sell with the target price retained at IDR2,040.

5. Z IN

In spite of a stellar quarter (Q3 FY19), we remain cautious on Zee Entertainment Enterprises (Z IN) and the prospects of broadcasters in India. Hindi GEC is consolidating, and most of the growth is likely to happen in regional channels which remain competitive. Global data suggests ad spends as a % of revenue for many broadcasters and cable operators has been disrupted and couple of year’s down the line, India should be no exception. Contrary to consensus, driven by millennials and non-affordability of second television, cord cutting in India could accelerate sooner than excepted. With an hyper competitive OTT landscape, uncertainty post TRAI Tariff implementations, in an industry suspect to easy value migration, the long term outlook for Zee Entertainment Enterprises (Z IN) and the broadcast Industry warrants attention. The only near term positive for the stock is the potential stake sale to a strategic partner, which is likely to keep the stock price buoyant but only in the near term.