Brief Equities Bottom-Up: RHT Health Trust – 40.7% Net Returns Since Jan. Is There Any Upside Left? and more

In this briefing:

1. RHT Health Trust – 40.7% Net Returns Since Jan. Is There Any Upside Left?
2. BabyTree(1761.HK) FY18 Results: E-Com Further Hit by ‘integration’ with Alibaba; India Foray Timely
3. Japan Display: Deal to Raise JPY110bn from China-Taiwan Consortium and Japanese Investment Fund
4. Tesla. Autopilot Safety Claims Roundly Debunked As Deafening Silence Follows Latest Fatality
5. Haitian: Trade War Fears Fade, Full Stream Ahead

1. RHT Health Trust – 40.7% Net Returns Since Jan. Is There Any Upside Left?

Since my last insight on RHT Health Trust (RHT SP) on 29^th Jan 2019 – RHT Health Trust – Cash on Sale , investors who bought into RHT Health Trust at S$0.029 per unit would have netted a return on investment of 40.7% if they sell out today, including the cash distribution that they have received in 1^st March.

Since last insight in January, RHT reported major changes to its Board of Directors and Management. The strong background of the new BOD and CEO in investment banking and REIT management will be valuable to RHT as it progresses to transform itself and acquire new business/assets to inject into the Trust.

Key investment thesis remains unchanged. RHT Health Trust is an event-driven play and the catalyst will be the announcement of an RTO deal to inject new assets/business into the Trust. This will be the key driver to further upside in RHT. 

Proposed investment strategy at this stage is to hold on to the investment in RHT and look for opportunities to add if RHT trades lower. Target entry price is S$0.016 per unit, which translates to a NAV discount of 27.3%.

2. BabyTree(1761.HK) FY18 Results: E-Com Further Hit by ‘integration’ with Alibaba; India Foray Timely

BabyTree (1761.HK)’s reported results for FY2018 continues to be impacted by the ‘shift in e-commerce strategy’ post collaboration with Alibaba Group Holding (BABA US) (also a key investor).  China’s leading parenting community platform that went public in November 2018 has announced a revenue decline of 4% during 2H2018; its e-commerce revenues were down 70% as its being ‘integrated’ with Alibaba. This is expected to be completed by 2Q2019. While the details of the collaboration (and revenue share, if any) are not given, Management has stated that Alibaba will manage the back-end e-commerce at a reduced cost and better efficiency while it will ‘manage’ users. Despite the fall in revenues, gross profits were up 18% helped by growth in advertisement revenues which now account for 85% of the total. Advertising as a revenue source has limited long term growth and valuation potential compared to e-commerce. The stock is up 25% since results announcement on March 27th, likely enthused by Net profit for FY2018 at Rmb526.2 mn and EPS of Rmb0.29 (implied current Year P/E of 23x). Key risk will be failure to revive e-commerce revenues post ‘integration’.

BabyTree also announced its first global foray – it has invested USD8mn in Healofy, amongst the top 3 leading parenting apps in India currently. India’s online Parenting app segment has numerous players and revenue generation/growth may not be easy in the near term for Healofy. However,  our analysis suggests that India’s overcrowded parenting app segment is now witnessing consolidation and this funding could probably help Healofy solidify its ranking amongst top 3 parenting platforms in India. In this context, BabyTree’s foray into India seems well timed. Healofy could potentially follow BabyTree’s operating model and fit into Alibaba Group Holding (BABA US) ‘s India e-commerce strategy (Refer our earlier report Alibaba’s India Game Plan – More than Meets the Eye; Investor Day Analysis (Part II) ).  

In the detailed report that follows, we briefly comment on BabyTree’s reported 2018 results and also present a quick overview of India Parenting App segment – key players, investors and why we think it may be on a consolidation mode. 

3. Japan Display: Deal to Raise JPY110bn from China-Taiwan Consortium and Japanese Investment Fund

• It was reported over the weekend that the troubled display supplier to iPhone maker Apple, Japan Display (JDI) has almost finalized a deal to raise more than JPY110bn (US$990m) from a China-Taiwan consortium and Japanese public-private fund INCJ Ltd.
• The China-Taiwan consortium is expected to secure some 50% stake in Japan Display while the top shareholder INCJ’s current stake of 25.3% is expected to be halved.
• The consortium is aiming to restructure JDI’s remaining debt payments of about JPY100bn from Apple for the construction of its plant while it also aims to procure parts for the latest iPhone. In addition, the consortium is also trying to modify a contract stipulating that Apple can seize plants if JDI’s cash and deposits fall below a certain amount.
• The consortium along with JDI is planning to build an OLED panel plant in China with JDI providing the technological know-how while the consortium partners invest in capital expenditures and equity.
• Japan Display has been struggling to navigate its display business due to the slowdown in iPhone sales, falling behind competition on OLED technology and facing stiff price competition from Chinese panel makers.
• We expect the proposed OLED plant in China could help the company stabilize its panel business with Chinese smartphone makers Huawei and Xiaomi who prefer to source panels locally from domestic panel makers such as BOE Technology and Tianma.

4. Tesla. Autopilot Safety Claims Roundly Debunked As Deafening Silence Follows Latest Fatality

In its final report into a fatal accident involving a Tesla Model S being driven in Autopilot Mode by one Joshua Brown, the NHTSA included the controversial finding that having Autopilot engaged reduced accident rates by 40%. Now, after battling both the NHTSA and Tesla for almost two years to get access to the underlying dataset, independent US-based consulting firm QCS has published a detailed report casting serious doubt on the methodology, statistics and science behind this 40% safer claim. 

Meanwhile on March 2’nd 2019, in a carbon copy of the circumstances which claimed the life of Joshua Brown almost three years ago, another Tesla driver lost his life when his Model 3 crashed into a semi-trailer as it legitimately crossed his line of travel to make a right-hand turn at an uncontrolled intersection. At the time of the accident, it was unknown whether Autopilot was engaged or not. If it transpires that it was engaged, it will represent a serious blow to Tesla’s credibility not least in part due to the company’s claims that its self-driving technology is continuously learning and improving based on the experiences and data collected on a daily basis from its ever-growing fleet of vehicles on the road.

Until now, on the one-month anniversary on this latest fatality, Tesla’s silence on the matter remains deafening.  

5. Haitian: Trade War Fears Fade, Full Stream Ahead

We expect Haitian’s margins go up in 2019, because 1) steel price in China is expected to decrease by 10% yoy with the re-balance of sector demand-supply, 2) Haitian’s newly launched third generation PIMM, and increasing sales propotion of high margin products, would improve the company’s overall margin.

Market demand is warming up in March, according to the management. The third generation PIMM is expected to trigger clients’ demand on upgrading their existing machines. High margin products, all-electric PIMM and large two-plate PIMM, would further increasing their sales and profit contribution. Overseas revenue growth would continue going faster than domestic revenue growth, with its new plants in Germany and Turkey coming on stream. We estimate Haitian’s net profit growth to reach 15% yoy in 2019E, vs. a 4% yoy decline in 2018.

Market concern on potential risk from Trade War, which had triggered Haitian’s valuation de-rating, should fade. As we expected, Haitian’s business wasn’t hurt by the Trade War in 2018, as the company has only 3% of overall revenue from US market. And the negotiations between US and China are on the right way to terminate the Trade War. Valuation re-rating might come with earnings improvement.