Brief Equities Bottom-Up: Chunghwa Telecom’s 2019 Guidance Looks Optimistic After Missing 2018 Guidance. and more

In this briefing:

1. Chunghwa Telecom’s 2019 Guidance Looks Optimistic After Missing 2018 Guidance.
2. Sony: Mispriced, Misunderstood, or Both?
3. Carnarvon Petroleum (CVN AU) Equity Raise: Opportunity to Get Exposure to Cheap Pre-FID Oil Assets
4. Tokyo Kiraboshi Financial Group (7173 JP): Red Dwarf
5. EPG: Revenue from Auto Parts and EPP Buoyed Earnings to Grow YoY

1. Chunghwa Telecom’s 2019 Guidance Looks Optimistic After Missing 2018 Guidance.

Chunghwa Telecom (2412 TT) recently announced very ambitious FY19 guidance targets. While the market may view management’s optimism poistively, we expect this to be very short-lived for two reasons (i) Chunghwa’s 2018 guidance proved to be hopelessly optimistic, eventually missing revenue and EBITDA by a wide margin, and (ii) Chunghwa starts 2019 with a -6% revenue growth. It will be tough to get to the guided 2.4-3.5% growth in 2019.  Management seem to be assuming the competitive environment will ease, but the comparables will be very tough in 1H19, and we will not see a repeat of the one-off cancellation fees received in May 2018. The dividend looks to be at risk, and if that is a key concern, we would prefer to own Far Eastone (4904 TT) or Taiwan Mobile (3045 TT) which should keep  dividends stable. We to reiterate our Reduce recommendation and slightly lower the target price to NT$86.

2. Sony: Mispriced, Misunderstood, or Both?

• Forward earnings will focus heavily on the debut of PS5, the performance of the new Spider-Man movie and other core content revenue streams for the company this year.
• Some see Sony as coasting on historically successes of the past, others see recent Disney and ATT deals acquiring content competitors, as a prelude to a play on Sony this year.
• Investor pressure to sell or spin off non-content businesses growing due to continued poor performance in mobile and possible profitable departure from semiconductor sector.

3. Carnarvon Petroleum (CVN AU) Equity Raise: Opportunity to Get Exposure to Cheap Pre-FID Oil Assets

Carnarvon Petroleum (CVN AU) has announced a A$50mm equity raise to fund the appraisal of its key Dorado discovery this year and a further exploration well in the area. We discuss why we see Carnarvon’s assets as attractive.

4. Tokyo Kiraboshi Financial Group (7173 JP): Red Dwarf

Tokyo Kiraboshi Financial Group (7173 JP) (TKFG) progresses from bad to worse, and its stock price is behaving accordingly.  Amidst volatile trading, the share price is gradually sinking back towards the 52-week intra-day low of ¥1,454 that was reached on Christmas Day 2018 before closing that day at ¥1,504.  3Q FY3/2019 (9 months to 31 December 2018) consolidated results represented a decline of over 56% YoY at the recurring profit level, with net profits down 34% YoY after tax adjustments.  On a quarterly basis, Q3 (October-December 2018) net operating profits collapsed 96% to just ¥66 million, while recurring profits fell 68% YoY to just ¥565 million with a small net loss of ¥9 million as a result of lower fee income and sharply higher credit costs.  Hardly a ‘glittering’ performance.

Trading on a forward-looking price/earnings multiple of 11.7x (using the bank’s current FY3/2019 guidance) and a price/book ratio of 0.19x, TKFG is expensive compared to peer regional banks.  Indeed, adjusting the group’s earnings per share (EPS) for the ¥55 billion (US$507 million) in two still-outstanding preference share issues raises the annualised PER to over 19x: roughly twice that of peer banks.  TKFG’s RoA and RoE ratios are woefully low at 0.09% and 1.71% respectively, loan growth has shrunk to just +0.5% YoY, deposits have fallen alarmingly (down 4.5% YoY), and the overhead ratio has shot up to 95% in Q3.  Yet, despite all these ‘red flags’, TKFG still managed to attract an aggregate foreign ownership of 17.4% as of 31 March 2018 (the most recent data publicly available): a strange choice.  Caveat emptor (may the buyer beware) !

5. EPG: Revenue from Auto Parts and EPP Buoyed Earnings to Grow YoY

EPG reports FY3Q19 net profit of Bt225m (+24%YoY,-14%QoQ). The FY9M19 result was in line with and accounts for 69% of our full-year forecast.

• A YoY increase in earnings was mainly caused by sales contribution from automotive segment (+28%YoY). While a QoQ fall in earnings was due to a seasonal drop in sales of thermal insulators segment and narrow gross profit margins due to rising raw material costs.
• We maintain our positive outlook toward its FY19-20E earnings driven by growth in every business units: 1) sales recovery from EPP segment (22% of total sales in FY9M19) from changing its product mix toward more on food packaging; 2) revenue contribution from Flexiglass after acquired it during FY1Q19, and, 3) consistent sales growth for Aeroflex (28% of total sales)

We maintain our BUY rating  with the target price of *Bt10.40 derived from its 2-years average trading range of 25xPE’19E.

*We make no changes to forecast, recommendation, and target price at the time of result announcement.