![](https://wp-static.smartkarma.com/../assets/uploaded/2018/12/2018-12-28T2214320800-1.jpg)
In this briefing:
- Prabhat Dairy Ltd – Update: Revenues and Margins Continues to Increase in Line with Our Expectations
- Alkem Laboratories – En Route to Recovery, Valuations Attractive
- Swaraj Engines: Positive Outlook But Growth Is Slowing and Valuation Is Rich
- Changing Lanes
- India: 2018 Is Watershed Year for Renewables with Decline in New Capacity Additions, What Is Next?
1. Prabhat Dairy Ltd – Update: Revenues and Margins Continues to Increase in Line with Our Expectations
Prabhat Dairy Ltd’s quarterly result is in line with our expectation. In Q2 FY19, the company registered a growth of 8.53% YoY, EBITDA margin was 9.4% improving by 119 bps since the same period last year, EBITDA grew by 24.2% YOY; the profit margin was at 2.95% improving by 60 bps YoY, Net Income grew by 35.86% YOY. For more details about the company, please refer to our initiation report Prabhat Dairy Ltd – An Emerging Star in the Indian Milky Way. B2B business contributed to 70% of revenue and the remaining 30% was driven by B2C business. Value Added Products contributed to 25% of revenue in Q2FY19.
The stock is trading at 16.3x its TTM EPS, 13.8x its FY19F EPS. Margins have improved over the past quarters due to lower cost of raw materials, we expect raw materials to continue to be lower than their historic average in short term. Lower cost of raw material along with the improving contribution from B2C will lead to higher margins in medium to long term. The company also wants to increase its B2C contribution aggressively from the current 30% to 50% by 2020.
We will monitor the stock closely to firm up our views further, albeit we remain positive on the long-term prospects of the company.
2. Alkem Laboratories – En Route to Recovery, Valuations Attractive
Alkem Laboratories (ALKEM IN) produces branded generics, generic drugs, active pharmaceutical ingredients and neutraceuticals, which it markets in India and over 50 countries internationally. With a portfolio of over 700 brands covering all the major therapeutic segments and a pan-India sales and distribution network, Alkem has been ranked amongst the top ten pharmaceutical companies in India by sales for the past 13 years.
We are optimistic about Alkem because-
- Alkem continues to grow significantly ahead of the segment growth rate of ~16% in the chronic therapy areas of Cardiac, Antidiabetic, Neuro / Central nervous system (CNS) and Derma. Alkem continues grow in the acute therapy areas of Anti-infective, Gastro-intestinal, Pain/ Analgesic and Vitamins / Minerals /Nutrients.
- We expect India revenues to grow at CAGR 13% (FY18-21E) to Rs 64,687 mn in FY21E from Rs 44,900 mn in FY18. We expect US revenues to grow at CAGR 31% (FY18-21E) to Rs 30,438 mn from Rs 13,667 mn in FY18 and other international business revenues to grow at CAGR 11% (FY18-21E) to Rs 6,443 mn in FY21E from Rs 4,670 mn in FY18.
- We expect EBITDA to grow at CAGR 21% (FY18-21E) to Rs 18,638 mn in FY21E from Rs 10,566 mn in FY18 and EBITDA margins to expand by ~ 190 bps to 18.4% in FY21E from 16.5% in FY18. We expect PAT to grow at CAGR 27% (FY18-21E) to Rs. 12,979 mn in FY21E from Rs 6,289 mn in FY18 and we expect PAT margins to expand by ~ 300 bps to 12.8% in FY21E from 9.8% in FY18.
- We expect RoE to expand by ~530 bps to 19.0% in FY21E from 13.7% in FY18 and RoCE to expand by ~390 bps to 21.1% in FY21E from 17.2% in FY18
We initiate coverage on Alkem with fair value of Rs. 2,260/- representing a potential upside of 21% in the next 12 months. We arrived at the fair value by applying 22x multiple to September 20E EPS of Rs 102. Currently, the stock trades at 21x and 17x its earnings estimates for FY20E and FY21E respectively. After a very volatile 2018, we believe Alkem share price may have smooth upwards move in 2019 driven by strong PAT growth in the next 3 quarters.
Particulars (Rs mn, Y/E March) | Net sales | EBITDA | PAT | EPS | ROE | ROCE | PE(x) |
FY18 | 64,137 | 10,566 | 6,289 | 52.6 | 13.7% | 17.2% | 35 |
FY19E | 74,075 | 12,406 | 8,130 | 68.0 | 16.0% | 16.8% | 27 |
FY20E | 87,716 | 15,659 | 10,772 | 90.1 | 18.4% | 20.4% | 21 |
FY21E | 1,01,568 | 18,638 | 12,979 | 108.6 | 19.0% | 21.1% | 17 |
3. Swaraj Engines: Positive Outlook But Growth Is Slowing and Valuation Is Rich
Swaraj Engines (SWE IN) (SEL)is primarily manufacturing diesel engines for fitment into Swaraj tractors manufactured by Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd. (M&M). The Company is also supplying engine components to SML Isuzu Ltd used in the assembly of commercial vehicle engines. SEL was started as a joint venture between Punjab Tractor Ltd (now acquired by M&M Ltd) and Kirloskar Oil Engines Ltd. M&M holds 33.3% stake in SEL and is its key client.
We are positive about the business because:
- SEL’s growth is correlated with M&M’s tractor business growth. SEL supplies engines to the Swaraj division of M&M. M&M expects tractor growth to be around 12% YoY in FY19E. We forecast SEL’s tractor engine volumes will grow at a CAGR of 12% for FY18-21E.
- The growth of the company is dependent on the monsoon and rural sentiments. We expect the profitability to improve with normal rainfall and government initiatives towards the rural sector. We expect the revenue/ EBITDA/ PAT CAGR for FY18-21E to be 14%/ 15%/ 14% respectively.
- SEL is debt free and a cash generating company. It has a healthy and stable ROCE and ROE. SEL has increased its capacity from 75,000 engines in FY16 to 120,000 engines in FY18. We expect the capacity utilisation to reach 97% by FY20E from 90% in 1HFY19. SEL funds its capex through internal accruals. We forecast a capex of Rs 600 mn for FY19E to FY21E considering the requirement of the additional capacity, R&D and testing costs for new and higher HP engines & for upgradation of engines according to the TREM IV emission norms for >50 HP engines.
We initiate coverage on SEL with a fair value objective of Rs 1,655/- over the next 12 months. This represents a potential upside of 15% from the closing price of Rs 1,435/- (as on 26-12-2018). We arrive at the fair value by applying PE multiple of 18x to EPS of Rs 87/- to the year ending December-20E and add cash of Rs 82/- per share. While the business outlook is good, we think the upside in the share price is limited due to rich valuation.
Particulars (Rs mn) (Y/E March) | FY18 | FY19E | FY20E | FY21E |
Revenue | 7,712 | 9,210 | 10,478 | 11,525 |
PAT | 801 | 906 | 1,063 | 1,190 |
EPS (Rs) | 64.5 | 74.8 | 87.6 | 98.1 |
PE (x) | 22.3 | 19.2 | 16.4 | 14.6 |
Note: E= Estimates
4. Changing Lanes
The hyper-competitive Indian payments industry is changing. New regulations are increasing the cost operations, NPCI (National Payments Corporation of India) & Reserve Bank of India (RBI) are breaking all barriers to entry enabling a level playing field that ensures no competitive moats exist. Although there are volumes, profitability remains a distant dream and likely to remain so making Indian payments a bad business to be invested in.
5. India: 2018 Is Watershed Year for Renewables with Decline in New Capacity Additions, What Is Next?
2018 is a watershed year for renewable energy in India, a) the growth has turned negative in capacity additions after several years of huge capacity addition increase in Solar, b) the wind power generation capacity additions is depressed once again after a very poor 2017. The apparent reason is significant delays in commissioning of projects because of execution challenges but there are structural issues as well and this means that there is not much certainty on how things will evolve in future.
The current financial year has seen a big change in general sentiment towards renewables in India and there were instances of cancelled bids and project disputes. More importantly, we think there are important changes we will see in 2019, a) the tariffs may not be increasing in bids but the level on decline we had observed in 2017 is now firmly in the past and this trend will get stronger and tariff bids will be stabilizing, b) Financing will be a major challenge and banks are not interested in power sector with not many alternatives available.
After Indian renewable energy space generated massive interest among power companies as developers and also from investors, we in all likelihood will see a more rational approach in future. It is not certain but hopefully, Govt expectation of continuously declining tariffs will become more reasonable. After a serious decline of more than 80% in solar tariffs over ten years, Govt expectation on per unit prices is continuously getting lower which is an unrealistic assumption because of change in cost dynamics.