Consumer

In this briefing:

1. Company Visits: The Best of March 2019
2. Summit Ascent’s Slippery Slope
3. Toyota: Hitting the Hybrid Accelerator and Towing Suzuki and Mazda in Its Wake
4. Dongzheng Auto Finance (东正汽车金融) Trading Update – Could Be Worth Setting up a Trade
5. TRADE IDEA – Melco (200 HK) Stub: Lose a Little Sleep in Macau

1. Company Visits: The Best of March 2019

We selectively visited a dozen companies in March and were most impressed with three of them (two of which we happily own):

• SISB, Thailand’s only listed education stock, whose market cap has increased more than 30% since its IPO. The future potential growth they are currently working on in Cambodia and China  will show up here and spruce the company’s already strong growth. Working in a favorable environment (Thailand’s affluent class is growing) also helps.
• MINT, the country’s hotel chain giant and 20th largest chain in the world, sees great growth potential in Europe, where things are slowly turning around after they made two big acquisitions (NH Hotels and Tivoli). Synergies are also materializing with co-marketing and re-branding efforts.
• After You, arguably the dessert chain with the highest margin in Thailand. No longer a newbie IPO stock, these guys boast collaboration with global giant Starbucks and branching out into new channels such as After You Durian. 

2. Summit Ascent’s Slippery Slope

Back in September 2017, Lawrence Ho, Summit Ascent Holdings (102 HK)‘s major shareholder, reduced his stake to 18.75% from 27.06% (at between $1.13-$1.60/share, but mainly at the low end of this range), according to Hong Kong Exchange disclosure of interest filings. The share price of this Russian integrated gaming play declined 34% to $1.06/share in the following five trading days. Who bought those shares was not disclosed – CCASS shows these shares moving out of VC Brokerage into at least 10 different brokerage accounts.

Shortly after, Howard Klein quoted one insider in his insight Melco Resorts: A Gem Hiding in Plain Sight Offers an Entry Point After a Recent Dip that the sell-down wasn’t likely a sign “Ho has lost confidence in the area.“

On the 15 December, Ho announced a complete exit from Summit, selling 17.37% of shares out. Concurrently Ho resigned from his NED and chairman positions. Those shares moved from VC Brokerage to Sun Hung Kai Investments on the 20 December 2017. Shares traded unchanged on the news. 

At the same time, First Steamship (2601 TT) disclosed it held 12.67% on the 18 December 2017. Concurrently, Kuo Jen Hao was appointed as NED and Chairman of the Board, with effect from 28 December 2017.  Kuo is also the chairman and the general manager of First Steamship. First Steamship gradually increased its stake to 19.11% as at 24 October 2018.

The New News

Yesterday, Summit Ascent announced it has been informed that First Steamship and Kuo are in talks to sell their entire shareholdings. No numbers were disclosed. This stake sale would not trigger an MGO and there was no reference to the release of an announcement pursuant to the Codes on Takeovers and Mergers and Share Buy-Backs in Hong Kong. Shares are up 24%.

With increased liquidity surrounding the news, this looks like a great opportunity to exit.

3. Toyota: Hitting the Hybrid Accelerator and Towing Suzuki and Mazda in Its Wake

The Nikkei announced this morning that Toyota Motor (7203 JP) was considering opening up its portfolio of hybrid patents for outside use, possibly for free.

We recently visited Toyota at its Toyota city headquarters and spent some time discussing this very topic. We believe this move is being made with an eye towards China in particular and to an extent the US. We would also highlight the continuing development of Toyota’s relationship with Suzuki. As the automakers move slowly towards what is likely to be an eventual union, the sharing of hybrid technology with Suzuki could have a significant impact on the medium-term prospects of both automakers.

4. Dongzheng Auto Finance (东正汽车金融) Trading Update – Could Be Worth Setting up a Trade

Dongzheng Automotive Finance (2718 HK) raised US$208m at a fixed price of HK$3.06 per share. We have covered the IPO extensively in:

• Dongzheng Auto Finance (东正汽车金融) Pre-IPO Review – Dependent on Dealership Network for Growth
• Dongzheng Auto Finance (东正汽车金融) IPO Review – Better off Buying the Parent
• Dongzheng Auto Finance (东正汽车金融) IPO Review – Relaunched at Lower Price

In this insight, we will update on the deal dynamics, implied valuation, and include a valuation sensitivity table.

5. TRADE IDEA – Melco (200 HK) Stub: Lose a Little Sleep in Macau

Visitors to Macao will notice the gaudy designs of new properties like Studio City and the City of Dreams owned by Melco. Few will know that the Melco of today traces its roots back almost 100 years when it was named The Macau Electric Lighting Company. Melco was listed in Hong Kong in 1927 when it was still managing the electricity supply service for the island of Macau, which it had done since 1906. After the CEM was established in 1972 to supply power in Macau, Melco changed its name to Melco International Development Limited and became a subsidiary of Stanley Ho’s real estate holding company, Shun Tak Holdings (242 HK). With the burden of supplying electricity off its shoulders, the company did what any logical Hong Kong firm would do when its business disappears, it bought real estate.

To this day, Melco International Development (200 HK) still maintains ownership of one of these classic Hong Kong destinations which I will take a closer look at in my note. In the rest of this insight I will:

• finish the historical overview of Melco
• present my trade idea and rationale
• give a detailed overview of the business units of Melco International
• recap ALL of my stub trades on Smartkarma and the performance of each 

In this briefing:

1. Rakuten: Lyft IPO Provides Timely Support for Mobile Deployment
2. LYFT Pre-IPO – Drivers and Shared Rides Hold the Key But the Numbers Are Missing
3. Orion Holdco/Sub Trade: Holdco’s Price Catching up Was Overworked, Time for Sub to Catch Up
4. Shanghai/Shenzhen Connect – $8.4 Bn Inflows in February (Kweichow Moutai, Aier Eye, Luxshare)

1. Rakuten: Lyft IPO Provides Timely Support for Mobile Deployment

The publication of Lyft’s IPO prospectus is a clear positive for Rakuten Inc (4755 JP) . As a pure investment, Rakuten’s return on its Lyft investments could be 273-366% or ¥101-136 per share based on the $20-25bn valuation range reported by the press. There has been a lot of focus on the investment gains Rakuten should accrue but the real upside is a timely boost to liquidity plus accounting cover as mobile investment accelerates.  Whether one believes Rakuten can succeed in mobile or not, it has the capital and paper profits to support a splashy introduction and spending is already accelerating.

2. LYFT Pre-IPO – Drivers and Shared Rides Hold the Key But the Numbers Are Missing

Lyft Inc (0812823D US) plans to list in the US at a valuation of US$20-25bn, as per media reports. 

Overall growth numbers have been great but some of the numbers are missing like the quarterly driver numbers, the number of shared riders versus single riders, organic growth in major cities, and progress of Canada operations, to name a few.

In my view, without the quarterly active driver numbers and the full picture of the extent of shared rides, one can’t develop an accurate picture of the business.

3. Orion Holdco/Sub Trade: Holdco’s Price Catching up Was Overworked, Time for Sub to Catch Up

• Orion Holdco/Sub duo is now above +2σ on a 20D MA. They made nearly 2σ jump in just two trading days. Price ratio is currently at a 120D high. Holdco discount to NAV dropped 4%p from 50% to 46% since last time we checked on Jan 24.
• China easing wind began to blow into Korea since late last year. This China expectation had pushed up both Holdco and Sub. Sub had reacted more sensitively to it. Sub has undergone a price correction lately. Holdco has done a lot of catching up during this period. Now, Holdco surpassed Sub in terms of price return. Holdco climbed 32% from its 52W low. Sub went up 30% from its 52W low.
• Holdco is preparing its own business operation, water purifier, in China. This may act as a divergence factor. But at this point, Holdco’s own business in China has no meaningful substance that can shake its NAV radically. They must be reverted back to mean. Their price return got reversed in favor of Holdco. Holdco’s price catching up should be done now. It is time to go long Sub and short Holdco.

4. Shanghai/Shenzhen Connect – $8.4 Bn Inflows in February (Kweichow Moutai, Aier Eye, Luxshare)

In our Discover SZ/SH Connect series, we aim to help our investors understand the flow of northbound trades via the Shanghai Connect and Shenzhen Connect, as analyzed by our proprietary data engine. We will discuss the stocks that experienced the most inflow and outflow by offshore investors in the past seven days.

We split the stocks eligible for the northbound trade into three groups: those with a market capitalization of above USD 5 billion, and those with a market capitalization between USD 1 billion and USD 5 billion.

We note that offshore investors were buying all GICS sectors, and had a strong preference for Industrials, Consumer Staples, Consumer Discretionary, and Financials names. We estimate that total inflow into the A-share market via northbound trade amounted to USD 8.4 bn in February.

In this briefing:

1. LYFT Pre-IPO – Drivers and Shared Rides Hold the Key But the Numbers Are Missing
2. Orion Holdco/Sub Trade: Holdco’s Price Catching up Was Overworked, Time for Sub to Catch Up
3. Shanghai/Shenzhen Connect – $8.4 Bn Inflows in February (Kweichow Moutai, Aier Eye, Luxshare)
4. Sea Ltd (SE US): Placement a Good Opportunity to Enter an Attractive Story

1. LYFT Pre-IPO – Drivers and Shared Rides Hold the Key But the Numbers Are Missing

Lyft Inc (0812823D US) plans to list in the US at a valuation of US$20-25bn, as per media reports. 

Overall growth numbers have been great but some of the numbers are missing like the quarterly driver numbers, the number of shared riders versus single riders, organic growth in major cities, and progress of Canada operations, to name a few.

In my view, without the quarterly active driver numbers and the full picture of the extent of shared rides, one can’t develop an accurate picture of the business.

2. Orion Holdco/Sub Trade: Holdco’s Price Catching up Was Overworked, Time for Sub to Catch Up

• Orion Holdco/Sub duo is now above +2σ on a 20D MA. They made nearly 2σ jump in just two trading days. Price ratio is currently at a 120D high. Holdco discount to NAV dropped 4%p from 50% to 46% since last time we checked on Jan 24.
• China easing wind began to blow into Korea since late last year. This China expectation had pushed up both Holdco and Sub. Sub had reacted more sensitively to it. Sub has undergone a price correction lately. Holdco has done a lot of catching up during this period. Now, Holdco surpassed Sub in terms of price return. Holdco climbed 32% from its 52W low. Sub went up 30% from its 52W low.
• Holdco is preparing its own business operation, water purifier, in China. This may act as a divergence factor. But at this point, Holdco’s own business in China has no meaningful substance that can shake its NAV radically. They must be reverted back to mean. Their price return got reversed in favor of Holdco. Holdco’s price catching up should be done now. It is time to go long Sub and short Holdco.

3. Shanghai/Shenzhen Connect – $8.4 Bn Inflows in February (Kweichow Moutai, Aier Eye, Luxshare)

In our Discover SZ/SH Connect series, we aim to help our investors understand the flow of northbound trades via the Shanghai Connect and Shenzhen Connect, as analyzed by our proprietary data engine. We will discuss the stocks that experienced the most inflow and outflow by offshore investors in the past seven days.

We split the stocks eligible for the northbound trade into three groups: those with a market capitalization of above USD 5 billion, and those with a market capitalization between USD 1 billion and USD 5 billion.

We note that offshore investors were buying all GICS sectors, and had a strong preference for Industrials, Consumer Staples, Consumer Discretionary, and Financials names. We estimate that total inflow into the A-share market via northbound trade amounted to USD 8.4 bn in February.

4. Sea Ltd (SE US): Placement a Good Opportunity to Enter an Attractive Story

Last Friday, Sea Ltd (SE US) unveiled plans to raise around $1 billion (based on the closing price on 28 February) through an underwritten public offering of 50 million ADS. The fundraising was inevitable due to the high cash burn and net cash position.

In this briefing:

1. Summit Ascent’s Slippery Slope
2. Toyota: Hitting the Hybrid Accelerator and Towing Suzuki and Mazda in Its Wake
3. Dongzheng Auto Finance (东正汽车金融) Trading Update – Could Be Worth Setting up a Trade
4. TRADE IDEA – Melco (200 HK) Stub: Lose a Little Sleep in Macau
5. BabyTree(1761.HK) FY18 Results: E-Com Further Hit by ‘integration’ with Alibaba; India Foray Timely

1. Summit Ascent’s Slippery Slope

Back in September 2017, Lawrence Ho, Summit Ascent Holdings (102 HK)‘s major shareholder, reduced his stake to 18.75% from 27.06% (at between $1.13-$1.60/share, but mainly at the low end of this range), according to Hong Kong Exchange disclosure of interest filings. The share price of this Russian integrated gaming play declined 34% to $1.06/share in the following five trading days. Who bought those shares was not disclosed – CCASS shows these shares moving out of VC Brokerage into at least 10 different brokerage accounts.

Shortly after, Howard Klein quoted one insider in his insight Melco Resorts: A Gem Hiding in Plain Sight Offers an Entry Point After a Recent Dip that the sell-down wasn’t likely a sign “Ho has lost confidence in the area.“

On the 15 December, Ho announced a complete exit from Summit, selling 17.37% of shares out. Concurrently Ho resigned from his NED and chairman positions. Those shares moved from VC Brokerage to Sun Hung Kai Investments on the 20 December 2017. Shares traded unchanged on the news. 

At the same time, First Steamship (2601 TT) disclosed it held 12.67% on the 18 December 2017. Concurrently, Kuo Jen Hao was appointed as NED and Chairman of the Board, with effect from 28 December 2017.  Kuo is also the chairman and the general manager of First Steamship. First Steamship gradually increased its stake to 19.11% as at 24 October 2018.

The New News

Yesterday, Summit Ascent announced it has been informed that First Steamship and Kuo are in talks to sell their entire shareholdings. No numbers were disclosed. This stake sale would not trigger an MGO and there was no reference to the release of an announcement pursuant to the Codes on Takeovers and Mergers and Share Buy-Backs in Hong Kong. Shares are up 24%.

With increased liquidity surrounding the news, this looks like a great opportunity to exit.

2. Toyota: Hitting the Hybrid Accelerator and Towing Suzuki and Mazda in Its Wake

The Nikkei announced this morning that Toyota Motor (7203 JP) was considering opening up its portfolio of hybrid patents for outside use, possibly for free.

We recently visited Toyota at its Toyota city headquarters and spent some time discussing this very topic. We believe this move is being made with an eye towards China in particular and to an extent the US. We would also highlight the continuing development of Toyota’s relationship with Suzuki. As the automakers move slowly towards what is likely to be an eventual union, the sharing of hybrid technology with Suzuki could have a significant impact on the medium-term prospects of both automakers.

3. Dongzheng Auto Finance (东正汽车金融) Trading Update – Could Be Worth Setting up a Trade

Dongzheng Automotive Finance (2718 HK) raised US$208m at a fixed price of HK$3.06 per share. We have covered the IPO extensively in:

• Dongzheng Auto Finance (东正汽车金融) Pre-IPO Review – Dependent on Dealership Network for Growth
• Dongzheng Auto Finance (东正汽车金融) IPO Review – Better off Buying the Parent
• Dongzheng Auto Finance (东正汽车金融) IPO Review – Relaunched at Lower Price

In this insight, we will update on the deal dynamics, implied valuation, and include a valuation sensitivity table.

4. TRADE IDEA – Melco (200 HK) Stub: Lose a Little Sleep in Macau

Visitors to Macao will notice the gaudy designs of new properties like Studio City and the City of Dreams owned by Melco. Few will know that the Melco of today traces its roots back almost 100 years when it was named The Macau Electric Lighting Company. Melco was listed in Hong Kong in 1927 when it was still managing the electricity supply service for the island of Macau, which it had done since 1906. After the CEM was established in 1972 to supply power in Macau, Melco changed its name to Melco International Development Limited and became a subsidiary of Stanley Ho’s real estate holding company, Shun Tak Holdings (242 HK). With the burden of supplying electricity off its shoulders, the company did what any logical Hong Kong firm would do when its business disappears, it bought real estate.

To this day, Melco International Development (200 HK) still maintains ownership of one of these classic Hong Kong destinations which I will take a closer look at in my note. In the rest of this insight I will:

• finish the historical overview of Melco
• present my trade idea and rationale
• give a detailed overview of the business units of Melco International
• recap ALL of my stub trades on Smartkarma and the performance of each 

5. BabyTree(1761.HK) FY18 Results: E-Com Further Hit by ‘integration’ with Alibaba; India Foray Timely

BabyTree (1761.HK)’s reported results for FY2018 continues to be impacted by the ‘shift in e-commerce strategy’ post collaboration with Alibaba Group Holding (BABA US) (also a key investor).  China’s leading parenting community platform that went public in November 2018 has announced a revenue decline of 4% during 2H2018; its e-commerce revenues were down 70% as its being ‘integrated’ with Alibaba. This is expected to be completed by 2Q2019. While the details of the collaboration (and revenue share, if any) are not given, Management has stated that Alibaba will manage the back-end e-commerce at a reduced cost and better efficiency while it will ‘manage’ users. Despite the fall in revenues, gross profits were up 18% helped by growth in advertisement revenues which now account for 85% of the total. Advertising as a revenue source has limited long term growth and valuation potential compared to e-commerce. The stock is up 25% since results announcement on March 27th, likely enthused by Net profit for FY2018 at Rmb526.2 mn and EPS of Rmb0.29 (implied current Year P/E of 23x). Key risk will be failure to revive e-commerce revenues post ‘integration’.

BabyTree also announced its first global foray – it has invested USD8mn in Healofy, amongst the top 3 leading parenting apps in India currently. India’s online Parenting app segment has numerous players and revenue generation/growth may not be easy in the near term for Healofy. However,  our analysis suggests that India’s overcrowded parenting app segment is now witnessing consolidation and this funding could probably help Healofy solidify its ranking amongst top 3 parenting platforms in India. In this context, BabyTree’s foray into India seems well timed. Healofy could potentially follow BabyTree’s operating model and fit into Alibaba Group Holding (BABA US) ‘s India e-commerce strategy (Refer our earlier report Alibaba’s India Game Plan – More than Meets the Eye; Investor Day Analysis (Part II) ).  

In the detailed report that follows, we briefly comment on BabyTree’s reported 2018 results and also present a quick overview of India Parenting App segment – key players, investors and why we think it may be on a consolidation mode. 

In this briefing:

1. Orion Holdco/Sub Trade: Holdco’s Price Catching up Was Overworked, Time for Sub to Catch Up
2. Shanghai/Shenzhen Connect – $8.4 Bn Inflows in February (Kweichow Moutai, Aier Eye, Luxshare)
3. Sea Ltd (SE US): Placement a Good Opportunity to Enter an Attractive Story

1. Orion Holdco/Sub Trade: Holdco’s Price Catching up Was Overworked, Time for Sub to Catch Up

• Orion Holdco/Sub duo is now above +2σ on a 20D MA. They made nearly 2σ jump in just two trading days. Price ratio is currently at a 120D high. Holdco discount to NAV dropped 4%p from 50% to 46% since last time we checked on Jan 24.
• China easing wind began to blow into Korea since late last year. This China expectation had pushed up both Holdco and Sub. Sub had reacted more sensitively to it. Sub has undergone a price correction lately. Holdco has done a lot of catching up during this period. Now, Holdco surpassed Sub in terms of price return. Holdco climbed 32% from its 52W low. Sub went up 30% from its 52W low.
• Holdco is preparing its own business operation, water purifier, in China. This may act as a divergence factor. But at this point, Holdco’s own business in China has no meaningful substance that can shake its NAV radically. They must be reverted back to mean. Their price return got reversed in favor of Holdco. Holdco’s price catching up should be done now. It is time to go long Sub and short Holdco.

2. Shanghai/Shenzhen Connect – $8.4 Bn Inflows in February (Kweichow Moutai, Aier Eye, Luxshare)

In our Discover SZ/SH Connect series, we aim to help our investors understand the flow of northbound trades via the Shanghai Connect and Shenzhen Connect, as analyzed by our proprietary data engine. We will discuss the stocks that experienced the most inflow and outflow by offshore investors in the past seven days.

We split the stocks eligible for the northbound trade into three groups: those with a market capitalization of above USD 5 billion, and those with a market capitalization between USD 1 billion and USD 5 billion.

We note that offshore investors were buying all GICS sectors, and had a strong preference for Industrials, Consumer Staples, Consumer Discretionary, and Financials names. We estimate that total inflow into the A-share market via northbound trade amounted to USD 8.4 bn in February.

3. Sea Ltd (SE US): Placement a Good Opportunity to Enter an Attractive Story

Last Friday, Sea Ltd (SE US) unveiled plans to raise around $1 billion (based on the closing price on 28 February) through an underwritten public offering of 50 million ADS. The fundraising was inevitable due to the high cash burn and net cash position.

In this briefing:

1. Orion Holdco/Sub Trade: Holdco’s Price Catching up Was Overworked, Time for Sub to Catch Up
2. Shanghai/Shenzhen Connect – $8.4 Bn Inflows in February (Kweichow Moutai, Aier Eye, Luxshare)
3. Sea Ltd (SE US): Placement a Good Opportunity to Enter an Attractive Story
4. GrainCorp (GNC AU): Better Late than Never Move to Get an LTAP Binding Proposal

1. Orion Holdco/Sub Trade: Holdco’s Price Catching up Was Overworked, Time for Sub to Catch Up

• Orion Holdco/Sub duo is now above +2σ on a 20D MA. They made nearly 2σ jump in just two trading days. Price ratio is currently at a 120D high. Holdco discount to NAV dropped 4%p from 50% to 46% since last time we checked on Jan 24.
• China easing wind began to blow into Korea since late last year. This China expectation had pushed up both Holdco and Sub. Sub had reacted more sensitively to it. Sub has undergone a price correction lately. Holdco has done a lot of catching up during this period. Now, Holdco surpassed Sub in terms of price return. Holdco climbed 32% from its 52W low. Sub went up 30% from its 52W low.
• Holdco is preparing its own business operation, water purifier, in China. This may act as a divergence factor. But at this point, Holdco’s own business in China has no meaningful substance that can shake its NAV radically. They must be reverted back to mean. Their price return got reversed in favor of Holdco. Holdco’s price catching up should be done now. It is time to go long Sub and short Holdco.

2. Shanghai/Shenzhen Connect – $8.4 Bn Inflows in February (Kweichow Moutai, Aier Eye, Luxshare)

In our Discover SZ/SH Connect series, we aim to help our investors understand the flow of northbound trades via the Shanghai Connect and Shenzhen Connect, as analyzed by our proprietary data engine. We will discuss the stocks that experienced the most inflow and outflow by offshore investors in the past seven days.

We split the stocks eligible for the northbound trade into three groups: those with a market capitalization of above USD 5 billion, and those with a market capitalization between USD 1 billion and USD 5 billion.

We note that offshore investors were buying all GICS sectors, and had a strong preference for Industrials, Consumer Staples, Consumer Discretionary, and Financials names. We estimate that total inflow into the A-share market via northbound trade amounted to USD 8.4 bn in February.

3. Sea Ltd (SE US): Placement a Good Opportunity to Enter an Attractive Story

Last Friday, Sea Ltd (SE US) unveiled plans to raise around $1 billion (based on the closing price on 28 February) through an underwritten public offering of 50 million ADS. The fundraising was inevitable due to the high cash burn and net cash position.

4. GrainCorp (GNC AU): Better Late than Never Move to Get an LTAP Binding Proposal

Graincorp Ltd A (GNC AU)‘s ability to generate shareholder value remains in doubt as LTAP enters its fourth month of due diligence. Yesterday, GrainCorp announced the first result (but overdue) of its portfolio review – the deal to sell its Australian bulk liquid terminals business to ANZ Terminals for A$350 million.

In this briefing:

1. Toyota: Hitting the Hybrid Accelerator and Towing Suzuki and Mazda in Its Wake
2. Dongzheng Auto Finance (东正汽车金融) Trading Update – Could Be Worth Setting up a Trade
3. TRADE IDEA – Melco (200 HK) Stub: Lose a Little Sleep in Macau
4. BabyTree(1761.HK) FY18 Results: E-Com Further Hit by ‘integration’ with Alibaba; India Foray Timely
5. European Apparel, Accessory & Luxury Goods Stocks Are Heating Up — Add Exposure

1. Toyota: Hitting the Hybrid Accelerator and Towing Suzuki and Mazda in Its Wake

The Nikkei announced this morning that Toyota Motor (7203 JP) was considering opening up its portfolio of hybrid patents for outside use, possibly for free.

We recently visited Toyota at its Toyota city headquarters and spent some time discussing this very topic. We believe this move is being made with an eye towards China in particular and to an extent the US. We would also highlight the continuing development of Toyota’s relationship with Suzuki. As the automakers move slowly towards what is likely to be an eventual union, the sharing of hybrid technology with Suzuki could have a significant impact on the medium-term prospects of both automakers.

2. Dongzheng Auto Finance (东正汽车金融) Trading Update – Could Be Worth Setting up a Trade

Dongzheng Automotive Finance (2718 HK) raised US$208m at a fixed price of HK$3.06 per share. We have covered the IPO extensively in:

• Dongzheng Auto Finance (东正汽车金融) Pre-IPO Review – Dependent on Dealership Network for Growth
• Dongzheng Auto Finance (东正汽车金融) IPO Review – Better off Buying the Parent
• Dongzheng Auto Finance (东正汽车金融) IPO Review – Relaunched at Lower Price

In this insight, we will update on the deal dynamics, implied valuation, and include a valuation sensitivity table.

3. TRADE IDEA – Melco (200 HK) Stub: Lose a Little Sleep in Macau

Visitors to Macao will notice the gaudy designs of new properties like Studio City and the City of Dreams owned by Melco. Few will know that the Melco of today traces its roots back almost 100 years when it was named The Macau Electric Lighting Company. Melco was listed in Hong Kong in 1927 when it was still managing the electricity supply service for the island of Macau, which it had done since 1906. After the CEM was established in 1972 to supply power in Macau, Melco changed its name to Melco International Development Limited and became a subsidiary of Stanley Ho’s real estate holding company, Shun Tak Holdings (242 HK). With the burden of supplying electricity off its shoulders, the company did what any logical Hong Kong firm would do when its business disappears, it bought real estate.

To this day, Melco International Development (200 HK) still maintains ownership of one of these classic Hong Kong destinations which I will take a closer look at in my note. In the rest of this insight I will:

• finish the historical overview of Melco
• present my trade idea and rationale
• give a detailed overview of the business units of Melco International
• recap ALL of my stub trades on Smartkarma and the performance of each 

4. BabyTree(1761.HK) FY18 Results: E-Com Further Hit by ‘integration’ with Alibaba; India Foray Timely

BabyTree (1761.HK)’s reported results for FY2018 continues to be impacted by the ‘shift in e-commerce strategy’ post collaboration with Alibaba Group Holding (BABA US) (also a key investor).  China’s leading parenting community platform that went public in November 2018 has announced a revenue decline of 4% during 2H2018; its e-commerce revenues were down 70% as its being ‘integrated’ with Alibaba. This is expected to be completed by 2Q2019. While the details of the collaboration (and revenue share, if any) are not given, Management has stated that Alibaba will manage the back-end e-commerce at a reduced cost and better efficiency while it will ‘manage’ users. Despite the fall in revenues, gross profits were up 18% helped by growth in advertisement revenues which now account for 85% of the total. Advertising as a revenue source has limited long term growth and valuation potential compared to e-commerce. The stock is up 25% since results announcement on March 27th, likely enthused by Net profit for FY2018 at Rmb526.2 mn and EPS of Rmb0.29 (implied current Year P/E of 23x). Key risk will be failure to revive e-commerce revenues post ‘integration’.

BabyTree also announced its first global foray – it has invested USD8mn in Healofy, amongst the top 3 leading parenting apps in India currently. India’s online Parenting app segment has numerous players and revenue generation/growth may not be easy in the near term for Healofy. However,  our analysis suggests that India’s overcrowded parenting app segment is now witnessing consolidation and this funding could probably help Healofy solidify its ranking amongst top 3 parenting platforms in India. In this context, BabyTree’s foray into India seems well timed. Healofy could potentially follow BabyTree’s operating model and fit into Alibaba Group Holding (BABA US) ‘s India e-commerce strategy (Refer our earlier report Alibaba’s India Game Plan – More than Meets the Eye; Investor Day Analysis (Part II) ).  

In the detailed report that follows, we briefly comment on BabyTree’s reported 2018 results and also present a quick overview of India Parenting App segment – key players, investors and why we think it may be on a consolidation mode. 

5. European Apparel, Accessory & Luxury Goods Stocks Are Heating Up — Add Exposure

We continue to believe that equities in Europe and the UK are bottoming with the STOXX Europe 600 index breaking topside its 14-month downtrend. Helping lead the turnaround is the Personal & Household Goods supersector. We believe outperformance is set to continue and several stocks are actionable at current levels within our int’l Group CD-28 Apparel, Accessory & Luxury Goods, Europe: LVMH Moet Hennessy Louis Vuitton SE (MC-FR), Christian Dior SE (CDI-FR), Kering SA (KER-FR), Hermes International SCA (RMS-FR), adidas AG (ADS-DE), Moncler SpA (MONC-IT), PUMA SE (PUM-DE), and Bjorn Borg AB (BORG-SE). Add exposure.

In this briefing:

1. Shanghai/Shenzhen Connect – $8.4 Bn Inflows in February (Kweichow Moutai, Aier Eye, Luxshare)
2. Sea Ltd (SE US): Placement a Good Opportunity to Enter an Attractive Story
3. GrainCorp (GNC AU): Better Late than Never Move to Get an LTAP Binding Proposal
4. Sea Ltd Placement – Capitalizing on Momentum

1. Shanghai/Shenzhen Connect – $8.4 Bn Inflows in February (Kweichow Moutai, Aier Eye, Luxshare)

In our Discover SZ/SH Connect series, we aim to help our investors understand the flow of northbound trades via the Shanghai Connect and Shenzhen Connect, as analyzed by our proprietary data engine. We will discuss the stocks that experienced the most inflow and outflow by offshore investors in the past seven days.

We split the stocks eligible for the northbound trade into three groups: those with a market capitalization of above USD 5 billion, and those with a market capitalization between USD 1 billion and USD 5 billion.

We note that offshore investors were buying all GICS sectors, and had a strong preference for Industrials, Consumer Staples, Consumer Discretionary, and Financials names. We estimate that total inflow into the A-share market via northbound trade amounted to USD 8.4 bn in February.

2. Sea Ltd (SE US): Placement a Good Opportunity to Enter an Attractive Story

Last Friday, Sea Ltd (SE US) unveiled plans to raise around $1 billion (based on the closing price on 28 February) through an underwritten public offering of 50 million ADS. The fundraising was inevitable due to the high cash burn and net cash position.

3. GrainCorp (GNC AU): Better Late than Never Move to Get an LTAP Binding Proposal

Graincorp Ltd A (GNC AU)‘s ability to generate shareholder value remains in doubt as LTAP enters its fourth month of due diligence. Yesterday, GrainCorp announced the first result (but overdue) of its portfolio review – the deal to sell its Australian bulk liquid terminals business to ANZ Terminals for A$350 million.

4. Sea Ltd Placement – Capitalizing on Momentum

Sea Ltd (SE US) is looking to raise about US$1.2bn in its upcoming placement. It will be larger than its IPO in 2017, which raised about US$880m.

The deal scores well on our framework owing to decent valuation, strong price and earnings momentum but had little track record for comparison. The company announced a strong set of FY2018/Q4 2018 results which had beaten estimates. 

Even though, the deal size is large, representing 23.2 days of three-month ADV, there is enough time between the announcement to the end of the bookbuild to price in the impact of the placement. 

In this briefing:

1. Dongzheng Auto Finance (东正汽车金融) Trading Update – Could Be Worth Setting up a Trade
2. TRADE IDEA – Melco (200 HK) Stub: Lose a Little Sleep in Macau
3. BabyTree(1761.HK) FY18 Results: E-Com Further Hit by ‘integration’ with Alibaba; India Foray Timely
4. European Apparel, Accessory & Luxury Goods Stocks Are Heating Up — Add Exposure
5. Tesla. Autopilot Safety Claims Roundly Debunked As Deafening Silence Follows Latest Fatality

1. Dongzheng Auto Finance (东正汽车金融) Trading Update – Could Be Worth Setting up a Trade

Dongzheng Automotive Finance (2718 HK) raised US$208m at a fixed price of HK$3.06 per share. We have covered the IPO extensively in:

• Dongzheng Auto Finance (东正汽车金融) Pre-IPO Review – Dependent on Dealership Network for Growth
• Dongzheng Auto Finance (东正汽车金融) IPO Review – Better off Buying the Parent
• Dongzheng Auto Finance (东正汽车金融) IPO Review – Relaunched at Lower Price

In this insight, we will update on the deal dynamics, implied valuation, and include a valuation sensitivity table.

2. TRADE IDEA – Melco (200 HK) Stub: Lose a Little Sleep in Macau

Visitors to Macao will notice the gaudy designs of new properties like Studio City and the City of Dreams owned by Melco. Few will know that the Melco of today traces its roots back almost 100 years when it was named The Macau Electric Lighting Company. Melco was listed in Hong Kong in 1927 when it was still managing the electricity supply service for the island of Macau, which it had done since 1906. After the CEM was established in 1972 to supply power in Macau, Melco changed its name to Melco International Development Limited and became a subsidiary of Stanley Ho’s real estate holding company, Shun Tak Holdings (242 HK). With the burden of supplying electricity off its shoulders, the company did what any logical Hong Kong firm would do when its business disappears, it bought real estate.

To this day, Melco International Development (200 HK) still maintains ownership of one of these classic Hong Kong destinations which I will take a closer look at in my note. In the rest of this insight I will:

• finish the historical overview of Melco
• present my trade idea and rationale
• give a detailed overview of the business units of Melco International
• recap ALL of my stub trades on Smartkarma and the performance of each 

3. BabyTree(1761.HK) FY18 Results: E-Com Further Hit by ‘integration’ with Alibaba; India Foray Timely

BabyTree (1761.HK)’s reported results for FY2018 continues to be impacted by the ‘shift in e-commerce strategy’ post collaboration with Alibaba Group Holding (BABA US) (also a key investor).  China’s leading parenting community platform that went public in November 2018 has announced a revenue decline of 4% during 2H2018; its e-commerce revenues were down 70% as its being ‘integrated’ with Alibaba. This is expected to be completed by 2Q2019. While the details of the collaboration (and revenue share, if any) are not given, Management has stated that Alibaba will manage the back-end e-commerce at a reduced cost and better efficiency while it will ‘manage’ users. Despite the fall in revenues, gross profits were up 18% helped by growth in advertisement revenues which now account for 85% of the total. Advertising as a revenue source has limited long term growth and valuation potential compared to e-commerce. The stock is up 25% since results announcement on March 27th, likely enthused by Net profit for FY2018 at Rmb526.2 mn and EPS of Rmb0.29 (implied current Year P/E of 23x). Key risk will be failure to revive e-commerce revenues post ‘integration’.

BabyTree also announced its first global foray – it has invested USD8mn in Healofy, amongst the top 3 leading parenting apps in India currently. India’s online Parenting app segment has numerous players and revenue generation/growth may not be easy in the near term for Healofy. However,  our analysis suggests that India’s overcrowded parenting app segment is now witnessing consolidation and this funding could probably help Healofy solidify its ranking amongst top 3 parenting platforms in India. In this context, BabyTree’s foray into India seems well timed. Healofy could potentially follow BabyTree’s operating model and fit into Alibaba Group Holding (BABA US) ‘s India e-commerce strategy (Refer our earlier report Alibaba’s India Game Plan – More than Meets the Eye; Investor Day Analysis (Part II) ).  

In the detailed report that follows, we briefly comment on BabyTree’s reported 2018 results and also present a quick overview of India Parenting App segment – key players, investors and why we think it may be on a consolidation mode. 

4. European Apparel, Accessory & Luxury Goods Stocks Are Heating Up — Add Exposure

We continue to believe that equities in Europe and the UK are bottoming with the STOXX Europe 600 index breaking topside its 14-month downtrend. Helping lead the turnaround is the Personal & Household Goods supersector. We believe outperformance is set to continue and several stocks are actionable at current levels within our int’l Group CD-28 Apparel, Accessory & Luxury Goods, Europe: LVMH Moet Hennessy Louis Vuitton SE (MC-FR), Christian Dior SE (CDI-FR), Kering SA (KER-FR), Hermes International SCA (RMS-FR), adidas AG (ADS-DE), Moncler SpA (MONC-IT), PUMA SE (PUM-DE), and Bjorn Borg AB (BORG-SE). Add exposure.

5. Tesla. Autopilot Safety Claims Roundly Debunked As Deafening Silence Follows Latest Fatality

In its final report into a fatal accident involving a Tesla Model S being driven in Autopilot Mode by one Joshua Brown, the NHTSA included the controversial finding that having Autopilot engaged reduced accident rates by 40%. Now, after battling both the NHTSA and Tesla for almost two years to get access to the underlying dataset, independent US-based consulting firm QCS has published a detailed report casting serious doubt on the methodology, statistics and science behind this 40% safer claim. 

Meanwhile on March 2’nd 2019, in a carbon copy of the circumstances which claimed the life of Joshua Brown almost three years ago, another Tesla driver lost his life when his Model 3 crashed into a semi-trailer as it legitimately crossed his line of travel to make a right-hand turn at an uncontrolled intersection. At the time of the accident, it was unknown whether Autopilot was engaged or not. If it transpires that it was engaged, it will represent a serious blow to Tesla’s credibility not least in part due to the company’s claims that its self-driving technology is continuously learning and improving based on the experiences and data collected on a daily basis from its ever-growing fleet of vehicles on the road.

Until now, on the one-month anniversary on this latest fatality, Tesla’s silence on the matter remains deafening.  

In this briefing:

1. Rakuten (4755) Lyft Lifts Shares Price but There Is Much Further to Go.

1. Rakuten (4755) Lyft Lifts Shares Price but There Is Much Further to Go.

Assuming a sum of the parts valuation the shares are cheap. We can assume the fintech business is worth perhaps Y800-900bn (based on 10x ebit, similar to Credit Saison), the domestic e-commerce operation (which makes an operating profit of about Y70bn on revenue of Y450bn) is worth perhaps Y1.2tr (assuming a valuation of 3x sales vs. 3.5x for Amazon). There are other parts of the business which detract and there are others, including a Y350bn plus investment portfolio which add but overall, all this compares with a market cap of a mere Y1.3tr. This suggests the market is thinking that Rakuten is more than throwing its MNO investment of Y600bn away. Given the Governments desire to reduce prices in the mobile market, and its desire for 4 operators, we would suggest this is overly negative. The recent announcement that Lyft will seek an IPO has lifted the share price given its 10% stake in this name (rumoured valuation of $23bn vs. $15bn currently), but we suspect the shares have much further to run. The market knows earnings will be depressed for the next 2 years or so but does not anticipate any recovery thereafter it would appear.