Category

Equity Bottom-Up

Brief Equities Bottom-Up: Japan Display: Deal to Raise JPY110bn from China-Taiwan Consortium and Japanese Investment Fund and more

By | Equity Bottom-Up

In this briefing:

  1. Japan Display: Deal to Raise JPY110bn from China-Taiwan Consortium and Japanese Investment Fund
  2. Tesla. Autopilot Safety Claims Roundly Debunked As Deafening Silence Follows Latest Fatality
  3. Haitian: Trade War Fears Fade, Full Stream Ahead
  4. Huishang Bank: Subpar Earnings and Asset Quality Indicate Caution
  5. China Construction Bank: Not Strategically Dear

1. Japan Display: Deal to Raise JPY110bn from China-Taiwan Consortium and Japanese Investment Fund

  • It was reported over the weekend that the troubled display supplier to iPhone maker Apple, Japan Display (JDI) has almost finalized a deal to raise more than JPY110bn (US$990m) from a China-Taiwan consortium and Japanese public-private fund INCJ Ltd.
  • The China-Taiwan consortium is expected to secure some 50% stake in Japan Display while the top shareholder INCJ’s current stake of 25.3% is expected to be halved.
  • The consortium is aiming to restructure JDI’s remaining debt payments of about JPY100bn from Apple for the construction of its plant while it also aims to procure parts for the latest iPhone. In addition, the consortium is also trying to modify a contract stipulating that Apple can seize plants if JDI’s cash and deposits fall below a certain amount.
  • The consortium along with JDI is planning to build an OLED panel plant in China with JDI providing the technological know-how while the consortium partners invest in capital expenditures and equity.
  • Japan Display has been struggling to navigate its display business due to the slowdown in iPhone sales, falling behind competition on OLED technology and facing stiff price competition from Chinese panel makers.
  • We expect the proposed OLED plant in China could help the company stabilize its panel business with Chinese smartphone makers Huawei and Xiaomi who prefer to source panels locally from domestic panel makers such as BOE Technology and Tianma.

2. Tesla. Autopilot Safety Claims Roundly Debunked As Deafening Silence Follows Latest Fatality

Screen%20shot%202019 04 02%20at%209.25.22%20am

In its final report into a fatal accident involving a Tesla Model S being driven in Autopilot Mode by one Joshua Brown, the NHTSA included the controversial finding that having Autopilot engaged reduced accident rates by 40%. Now, after battling both the NHTSA and Tesla for almost two years to get access to the underlying dataset, independent US-based consulting firm QCS has published a detailed report casting serious doubt on the methodology, statistics and science behind this 40% safer claim. 

Meanwhile on March 2’nd 2019, in a carbon copy of the circumstances which claimed the life of Joshua Brown almost three years ago, another Tesla driver lost his life when his Model 3 crashed into a semi-trailer as it legitimately crossed his line of travel to make a right-hand turn at an uncontrolled intersection. At the time of the accident, it was unknown whether Autopilot was engaged or not. If it transpires that it was engaged, it will represent a serious blow to Tesla’s credibility not least in part due to the company’s claims that its self-driving technology is continuously learning and improving based on the experiences and data collected on a daily basis from its ever-growing fleet of vehicles on the road.

Until now, on the one-month anniversary on this latest fatality, Tesla’s silence on the matter remains deafening.  

3. Haitian: Trade War Fears Fade, Full Stream Ahead

Screen%20shot%202019 04 02%20at%2015.16.40

We expect Haitian’s margins go up in 2019, because 1) steel price in China is expected to decrease by 10% yoy with the re-balance of sector demand-supply, 2) Haitian’s newly launched third generation PIMM, and increasing sales propotion of high margin products, would improve the company’s overall margin.

Market demand is warming up in March, according to the management. The third generation PIMM is expected to trigger clients’ demand on upgrading their existing machines. High margin products, all-electric PIMM and large two-plate PIMM, would further increasing their sales and profit contribution. Overseas revenue growth would continue going faster than domestic revenue growth, with its new plants in Germany and Turkey coming on stream. We estimate Haitian’s net profit growth to reach 15% yoy in 2019E, vs. a 4% yoy decline in 2018.

Market concern on potential risk from Trade War, which had triggered Haitian’s valuation de-rating, should fade. As we expected, Haitian’s business wasn’t hurt by the Trade War in 2018, as the company has only 3% of overall revenue from US market. And the negotiations between US and China are on the right way to terminate the Trade War. Valuation re-rating might come with earnings improvement.

4. Huishang Bank: Subpar Earnings and Asset Quality Indicate Caution

Huishang Bank Corp Ltd H (3698 HK) looks interesting at first. Some trends are moving in the right direction and the valuation is hardly stretched.

So it seems. Closer inspection reveals subpar earnings quality and pressure on the top line from an elevated growth in funding costs and a double-digit reduction in income from non-credit earning assets. Impairments weighed heavily on the bottom line. Underlying “jaws” were extremely negative, putting the decrease in the Cost-Income ratio into perspective.

An improving NPL ratio of 0.95% (or 1.04% depending on which one you use) does not tell the whole story at all. Asset quality issues, of course, come through in the income statement with writedowns and loan loss provisions consuming a huge (and increasing) chunk of pre-impairment profit. The Balance Sheet exhibits strains and stresses from an explosion of doubtful loans, rising substandard loans, and arguably an unhealthy expansion of special mention loans. At least “unimpaired past-due” loans have moderated though they stand at 45% of headline NPLs. Some key capitalisation metrics are deteriorating while liquidity erodes given the 23% growth in credit which flatters the problem loan picture.

5. China Construction Bank: Not Strategically Dear

China%20banks%20charting%20image%20export%20 %20apr%202nd%202019%209 45 49%20am

China Construction Bank (601939 CH) FY18 results reflected stability and some encouraging signs of positive fundamental momentum. The highlights were a positive “underlying jaws” of 220bps, fortified Capital Adequacy, enhanced Provisioning, and firmer net interest spread and margin. Liquidity remains prudent with credit and deposit growth both expanding by mid-single digits. In addition, the top-line exhibited solid growth with funding expense growth (an issue elsewhere) only mildly in excess of interest income growth. Sharply higher asset loan loss provisions reflected the ongoing battle with troubling systemic asset quality challenges.

CCB is committed to becoming a core comprehensive service provider for smart city development, in alignment with government strategic targets. In terms of technology, AI robots (in wealth management, for example), Intelligent Risk Management Platforms, Biometric verification plus a public and private “cloud ecosphere” are evolving. Big data is developing with data warehouse integrating internal and external data; with enterprise data management and application architecture; and via working platforms. CCB is wedded to IoT, blockchain as well as big data in industry chain finance, via internet-based “e Xin Tong”, “e Xin Tong” and “e Qi Tong”. The bank has a strategy of Mobile First, provision of internet-based smart financial services, booming WeChat banking, and integration of online banking services that combines transactions, sales, and customer service.

Automation and “intelligence” is the bedrock of risk management: the key area today of what is a highly leveraged system. Here, CCB is integrating corporate and retail early warning systems and unifying the monitoring of different exposures. Management launched a “new generation” retail customer scorecard model, elevating the level of automation and “intelligence” of risk metrics. In addition, the bank is attaining greater recognition and control of fraud. Regarding the remote monitoring system, CCB is adapting to the fast development of information, network and big data technology, by building a monitoring system with unified plans, standards, software and hardware.

While CCB trades at a P/Book of 0.8x (regional median, including Japan) and a franchise valuation of 9% (regional median, including Japan), the Earnings Yield of 17.4% is well in excess of regional median of 10%. The combination of a top decile PH Score™, capturing fundamental momentum, an underbought technical signal, and a reasonable franchise valuation position CCB in the top decile of opportunity globally. For a core strategic policy bank, this represents an opportunity.

Get Straight to the Source on Smartkarma

Smartkarma supports the world’s leading investors with high-quality, timely, and actionable Insights. Subscribe now for unlimited access, or request a demo below.



Brief Equities Bottom-Up: Pan Pacific/Don Quijote: Bringing Joy into Shopping and more

By | Equity Bottom-Up

In this briefing:

  1. Pan Pacific/Don Quijote: Bringing Joy into Shopping
  2. Mercari: Why Mercari Is Likely to Be a Winner in the Cashless Wars
  3. Notes from the Silk Road: Xtep Int’l Holdings (1368 HK): Time to Run (Away) For Now
  4. Angang Steel: PMI Recovery to Support Shares: Close Short
  5. Optex (6914 JP): Factory Automation Slowdown in the Price

1. Pan Pacific/Don Quijote: Bringing Joy into Shopping

Capture%206

  • Japanese Retail is in a secular decline: There are areas in retail that are worse affected than the rest
  • Falling foot traffic: The biggest problem for Japanese retail
  • Don Quijote’s recent history and growth potential
  • Attracting shoppers from multiple store formats helps Don Quijote to expand its target market
  • Don Quijote is least affected from slowdown in Chinese tourist spending
  • FamilyMart UNY store conversions to contribute to revenue and EBIT growth over the next five years
  • New store openings to cap at 25 per year because of UNY store conversions
  • Valuation: Market unjustly penalized Don Quijote for the UNY acquisition
  • Change in retail landscape to help make Don Quijote the “DON” in Japanese retail

2. Mercari: Why Mercari Is Likely to Be a Winner in the Cashless Wars

Mercari%20qoq%20growth

While we have been sceptical about Mercari Inc (4385 JP)‘s efforts in the US, we have always appreciated the domestic business and have only been put off by the rather demanding multiples. After speaking to the company, we continue to like the domestic business and feel that recent initiatives to broaden the user base are likely to be successful. In addition, while we still feel that there are numerous question marks about whether the business model can work in the US, we have come around to a more positive view on the company’s execution there. Lastly, we believe Merpay’s edge in the cashless wars is underappreciated and the fall in the share price is starting to make the stock attractive.

We discuss the details below.

3. Notes from the Silk Road: Xtep Int’l Holdings (1368 HK): Time to Run (Away) For Now

Xtep International (1368 HK) has announced a placing and top-up subscription of new shares event, creating a capital base which is 9% larger. 

XTEP states that they have considered various ways of raising funds and consider that it would be in their best interests to raise equity funding through the placing and the subscription. 

With the share price down 16% since the placement, we examine what this means for the company’s fundamentals and shareholders. We believe the results will prove to be mixed for management and shareholders alike. We highlight how we expect the stock ranking to react, given we the placement was only a few days back and this is yet to reflect. This special situation analysis may surprise you with the conclusions.

4. Angang Steel: PMI Recovery to Support Shares: Close Short

Pmi3

INVESTMENT VIEW:
The recovery in China’s March PMI index to 50.8 shows an unexpected expansion in economic activity.  Historically, there is a strong correlation between the PMI and Chinese steel prices as well as Angang’s share price. 

We close our short on Angang Steel Co Ltd (H) (347 HK) shares. 

5. Optex (6914 JP): Factory Automation Slowdown in the Price

Screen%20shot%202019 03 30%20at%2011.58.02

According to management, weak demand for factory automation sensors had a significant negative impact on sales and profits in 1Q of FY Dec-19. Also, in our estimation, it is likely to cause 1H results to fall short of guidance. But this should be in the share price, which has dropped by nearly 50% from its 52-week high. 

In the year to December 2018, operating profit was up only 2.1% on a 7.0% increase in sales, largely due to an increase in machine vision marketing expenses. In January and February 2019, factory automation orders and sales dropped abruptly as customers sought to reduce excess inventories. In March, some new orders were received for delivery in May, indicating that the situation may stabilize in 2H. Demand for security and automatic door sensors continues to grow at low single-digit rates.

For FY Dec-19 as a whole, management is guiding for a 6.2% increase in operating profit on a 7.2% increase in sales. Our forecast is for flat operating profit on a 2% increase in sales. Sales and profit growth should pick up over the following two years, in our estimation, but remain in single digits.

At ¥1,765 (Friday, March 29, closing price), Optex is selling at 18x our EPS estimate for FY Dec-19 and 17x our estimate for FY Dec-20. Over the past 5 years, the P/E has ranged from 13x to 36x. On a trailing 12-month basis, Japan Analytics calculates 5% upside to a no-growth valuation, which is in line with our forecast for this fiscal year. This suggests: buy either for the bounce or for the long term. 

Get Straight to the Source on Smartkarma

Smartkarma supports the world’s leading investors with high-quality, timely, and actionable Insights. Subscribe now for unlimited access, or request a demo below.



Brief Equities Bottom-Up: 58.com (WUBA): Weak Membership Growth Suggests More Volatile Performance, 17% Downside and more

By | Equity Bottom-Up

In this briefing:

  1. 58.com (WUBA): Weak Membership Growth Suggests More Volatile Performance, 17% Downside
  2. JKN: 4Q18 Earnings Grew Both YoY and QoQ
  3. 7-Eleven in India: Standard Franchise Model Would Require Minor Tweaks in India

1. 58.com (WUBA): Weak Membership Growth Suggests More Volatile Performance, 17% Downside

Pic%206

* We believe that the stagnancy in membership was due to the new competitor Ke.com and will make total revenues more volatile in the future.

* We assume total revenues will slow down, but the operating margin will be stable in 2019.

* We compare WUBA’s expected P/E for 2019 with other vertical platforms in China and conclude 17% downside.

2. JKN: 4Q18 Earnings Grew Both YoY and QoQ

Jkn%20update%203

The company’s 4Q18 net profit was at Bt46m (+298%YoY and +8%QoQ). The result was in line with our 2018 forecast and accounted for 97% of our full-year forecast.

  • A YoY surge in earnings was due to a 30% increase in revenue to Bt360m, mainly from export revenue (50% revenue contribution in 3Q18 from 0% in 4Q17). A QoQ gain was caused a reduction in extra expenses for holding an annual event ‘JKN mega showcase’ in early August.
  • 2019 earnings outlook is still decent on the back of 1.) higher revenue contribution from export market especially South East Asia (26% of revenue in 2018), 2.) CNBC studio commencement in 2Q19, and, 3.) revenue recognition from new channel subscribers (No.5, Thairath, Spring news, True4U, Nation and MONO)

We maintain our forecast and BUY rating for JKN with a target price of Bt8.80 based on 14.8xPE’19E mean of the Asia ex-Japan Consumer Discretionary Sector.

3. 7-Eleven in India: Standard Franchise Model Would Require Minor Tweaks in India

Capture%201

  • 7-Eleven partners up with Future Retail in an effort to enter the growing Indian Market
  • Indian E-Commerce giants pose a significant threat to 7-Eleven’s plans
  • 7-Eleven’s recent shift focuses more on developing markets.
  • Lack of profitability in India could require changes to the standard franchise agreement in order to attract franchisees

On 28th February 2019, Seven & I Holdings (3382 JP), the operator of the world’s largest convenience store chain 7-Eleven, announced that the company has signed a master franchise agreement with Kishore Biyani’s Future Retail, the operator of the Indian large format store chain Big Bazaar, to expand the 7-Eleven convenience stores into India. Future Retail and Seven & I Holdings expect the first 7-Eleven convenience store in India to be opened in Mumbai in 2019.

Get Straight to the Source on Smartkarma

Smartkarma supports the world’s leading investors with high-quality, timely, and actionable Insights. Subscribe now for unlimited access, or request a demo below.



Brief Equities Bottom-Up: Tesla. Autopilot Safety Claims Roundly Debunked As Deafening Silence Follows Latest Fatality and more

By | Equity Bottom-Up

In this briefing:

  1. Tesla. Autopilot Safety Claims Roundly Debunked As Deafening Silence Follows Latest Fatality
  2. Haitian: Trade War Fears Fade, Full Stream Ahead
  3. Huishang Bank: Subpar Earnings and Asset Quality Indicate Caution
  4. China Construction Bank: Not Strategically Dear
  5. Indonesia Property – In Search of the End of the Rainbow – Part 6 – Intiland Development (DILD IJ)

1. Tesla. Autopilot Safety Claims Roundly Debunked As Deafening Silence Follows Latest Fatality

Screen%20shot%202019 04 02%20at%209.25.22%20am

In its final report into a fatal accident involving a Tesla Model S being driven in Autopilot Mode by one Joshua Brown, the NHTSA included the controversial finding that having Autopilot engaged reduced accident rates by 40%. Now, after battling both the NHTSA and Tesla for almost two years to get access to the underlying dataset, independent US-based consulting firm QCS has published a detailed report casting serious doubt on the methodology, statistics and science behind this 40% safer claim. 

Meanwhile on March 2’nd 2019, in a carbon copy of the circumstances which claimed the life of Joshua Brown almost three years ago, another Tesla driver lost his life when his Model 3 crashed into a semi-trailer as it legitimately crossed his line of travel to make a right-hand turn at an uncontrolled intersection. At the time of the accident, it was unknown whether Autopilot was engaged or not. If it transpires that it was engaged, it will represent a serious blow to Tesla’s credibility not least in part due to the company’s claims that its self-driving technology is continuously learning and improving based on the experiences and data collected on a daily basis from its ever-growing fleet of vehicles on the road.

Until now, on the one-month anniversary on this latest fatality, Tesla’s silence on the matter remains deafening.  

2. Haitian: Trade War Fears Fade, Full Stream Ahead

Screen%20shot%202019 04 02%20at%2015.16.40

We expect Haitian’s margins go up in 2019, because 1) steel price in China is expected to decrease by 10% yoy with the re-balance of sector demand-supply, 2) Haitian’s newly launched third generation PIMM, and increasing sales propotion of high margin products, would improve the company’s overall margin.

Market demand is warming up in March, according to the management. The third generation PIMM is expected to trigger clients’ demand on upgrading their existing machines. High margin products, all-electric PIMM and large two-plate PIMM, would further increasing their sales and profit contribution. Overseas revenue growth would continue going faster than domestic revenue growth, with its new plants in Germany and Turkey coming on stream. We estimate Haitian’s net profit growth to reach 15% yoy in 2019E, vs. a 4% yoy decline in 2018.

Market concern on potential risk from Trade War, which had triggered Haitian’s valuation de-rating, should fade. As we expected, Haitian’s business wasn’t hurt by the Trade War in 2018, as the company has only 3% of overall revenue from US market. And the negotiations between US and China are on the right way to terminate the Trade War. Valuation re-rating might come with earnings improvement.

3. Huishang Bank: Subpar Earnings and Asset Quality Indicate Caution

Huishang Bank Corp Ltd H (3698 HK) looks interesting at first. Some trends are moving in the right direction and the valuation is hardly stretched.

So it seems. Closer inspection reveals subpar earnings quality and pressure on the top line from an elevated growth in funding costs and a double-digit reduction in income from non-credit earning assets. Impairments weighed heavily on the bottom line. Underlying “jaws” were extremely negative, putting the decrease in the Cost-Income ratio into perspective.

An improving NPL ratio of 0.95% (or 1.04% depending on which one you use) does not tell the whole story at all. Asset quality issues, of course, come through in the income statement with writedowns and loan loss provisions consuming a huge (and increasing) chunk of pre-impairment profit. The Balance Sheet exhibits strains and stresses from an explosion of doubtful loans, rising substandard loans, and arguably an unhealthy expansion of special mention loans. At least “unimpaired past-due” loans have moderated though they stand at 45% of headline NPLs. Some key capitalisation metrics are deteriorating while liquidity erodes given the 23% growth in credit which flatters the problem loan picture.

4. China Construction Bank: Not Strategically Dear

China%20banks%20charting%20image%20export%20 %20apr%202nd%202019%209 45 49%20am

China Construction Bank (601939 CH) FY18 results reflected stability and some encouraging signs of positive fundamental momentum. The highlights were a positive “underlying jaws” of 220bps, fortified Capital Adequacy, enhanced Provisioning, and firmer net interest spread and margin. Liquidity remains prudent with credit and deposit growth both expanding by mid-single digits. In addition, the top-line exhibited solid growth with funding expense growth (an issue elsewhere) only mildly in excess of interest income growth. Sharply higher asset loan loss provisions reflected the ongoing battle with troubling systemic asset quality challenges.

CCB is committed to becoming a core comprehensive service provider for smart city development, in alignment with government strategic targets. In terms of technology, AI robots (in wealth management, for example), Intelligent Risk Management Platforms, Biometric verification plus a public and private “cloud ecosphere” are evolving. Big data is developing with data warehouse integrating internal and external data; with enterprise data management and application architecture; and via working platforms. CCB is wedded to IoT, blockchain as well as big data in industry chain finance, via internet-based “e Xin Tong”, “e Xin Tong” and “e Qi Tong”. The bank has a strategy of Mobile First, provision of internet-based smart financial services, booming WeChat banking, and integration of online banking services that combines transactions, sales, and customer service.

Automation and “intelligence” is the bedrock of risk management: the key area today of what is a highly leveraged system. Here, CCB is integrating corporate and retail early warning systems and unifying the monitoring of different exposures. Management launched a “new generation” retail customer scorecard model, elevating the level of automation and “intelligence” of risk metrics. In addition, the bank is attaining greater recognition and control of fraud. Regarding the remote monitoring system, CCB is adapting to the fast development of information, network and big data technology, by building a monitoring system with unified plans, standards, software and hardware.

While CCB trades at a P/Book of 0.8x (regional median, including Japan) and a franchise valuation of 9% (regional median, including Japan), the Earnings Yield of 17.4% is well in excess of regional median of 10%. The combination of a top decile PH Score™, capturing fundamental momentum, an underbought technical signal, and a reasonable franchise valuation position CCB in the top decile of opportunity globally. For a core strategic policy bank, this represents an opportunity.

5. Indonesia Property – In Search of the End of the Rainbow – Part 6 – Intiland Development (DILD IJ)

Dild%20marketing%20sales%20by%20segment

In this series under Smartkarma Originals, CrossASEAN insight providers AngusMackintosh and Jessica Irene seek to determine whether or not we are close to the end of the rainbow and to a period of outperformance for the property sector. Our end conclusions will be based on a series of company visits to the major listed property companies in Indonesia, conversations with local banks, property agents, and other relevant channel checks. 

The sixth company that we explore is Intiland Development (DILD IJ), a property developer that focuses on landed residential, industrial estates, high-end condominiums, and offices in Jakarta and Surabaya. DILD has a good track record in building and operating high-end condominiums and offices. But the property market slowdown, tighter mortgage regulations, and rising construction costs took a massive toll on the company’s balance sheet and margin.

DILD shows the worst operating cashflow performance versus peers. The operating cashflow is running at a massive deficit after the property market peak in 2013, driven mostly by worsening working capital cycle. Both consolidated gross margin and EBIT margin are also trending down over the past five years, showing the company’s inability to pass on costs. The biggest margin decline is visible in the offices, landed residential, and condominiums. 

The total net asset value (NAV) for company’s landbank and investment properties is about IDR10.5tn, equivalent to IDR1,018 NAV per share. Despite an attractive Price-to-Book (PB) valuation and a chunky 65% discount to NAV, DILD still looks expensive on a Price-to-Earnings (PE) basis. Analysts have been downgrading earnings on lower margin expectation and weaker than expected cashflow generation that cause debt levels to remain high.

Consensus expects 16% EPS growth this year with revenues growing by 22%. We may see further downgrades post FY18 results as 9M18 EBIT only makes up 51% of consensus FY18 forecast. The government’s plan to reduce luxury taxes and allowing foreigners to hold strata title on Indonesian properties should bode well for DILD and serve as a potential catalyst in the short term. Our estimated fair value for DILD is at IDR 404 per share, suggesting 14% upside from the current levels.

Get Straight to the Source on Smartkarma

Smartkarma supports the world’s leading investors with high-quality, timely, and actionable Insights. Subscribe now for unlimited access, or request a demo below.



Brief Equities Bottom-Up: Haitian: Trade War Fears Fade, Full Stream Ahead and more

By | Equity Bottom-Up

In this briefing:

  1. Haitian: Trade War Fears Fade, Full Stream Ahead
  2. Huishang Bank: Subpar Earnings and Asset Quality Indicate Caution
  3. China Construction Bank: Not Strategically Dear
  4. Indonesia Property – In Search of the End of the Rainbow – Part 6 – Intiland Development (DILD IJ)
  5. Pan Pacific/Don Quijote: Bringing Joy into Shopping

1. Haitian: Trade War Fears Fade, Full Stream Ahead

Screen%20shot%202019 04 02%20at%2015.16.40

We expect Haitian’s margins go up in 2019, because 1) steel price in China is expected to decrease by 10% yoy with the re-balance of sector demand-supply, 2) Haitian’s newly launched third generation PIMM, and increasing sales propotion of high margin products, would improve the company’s overall margin.

Market demand is warming up in March, according to the management. The third generation PIMM is expected to trigger clients’ demand on upgrading their existing machines. High margin products, all-electric PIMM and large two-plate PIMM, would further increasing their sales and profit contribution. Overseas revenue growth would continue going faster than domestic revenue growth, with its new plants in Germany and Turkey coming on stream. We estimate Haitian’s net profit growth to reach 15% yoy in 2019E, vs. a 4% yoy decline in 2018.

Market concern on potential risk from Trade War, which had triggered Haitian’s valuation de-rating, should fade. As we expected, Haitian’s business wasn’t hurt by the Trade War in 2018, as the company has only 3% of overall revenue from US market. And the negotiations between US and China are on the right way to terminate the Trade War. Valuation re-rating might come with earnings improvement.

2. Huishang Bank: Subpar Earnings and Asset Quality Indicate Caution

Huishang Bank Corp Ltd H (3698 HK) looks interesting at first. Some trends are moving in the right direction and the valuation is hardly stretched.

So it seems. Closer inspection reveals subpar earnings quality and pressure on the top line from an elevated growth in funding costs and a double-digit reduction in income from non-credit earning assets. Impairments weighed heavily on the bottom line. Underlying “jaws” were extremely negative, putting the decrease in the Cost-Income ratio into perspective.

An improving NPL ratio of 0.95% (or 1.04% depending on which one you use) does not tell the whole story at all. Asset quality issues, of course, come through in the income statement with writedowns and loan loss provisions consuming a huge (and increasing) chunk of pre-impairment profit. The Balance Sheet exhibits strains and stresses from an explosion of doubtful loans, rising substandard loans, and arguably an unhealthy expansion of special mention loans. At least “unimpaired past-due” loans have moderated though they stand at 45% of headline NPLs. Some key capitalisation metrics are deteriorating while liquidity erodes given the 23% growth in credit which flatters the problem loan picture.

3. China Construction Bank: Not Strategically Dear

China%20banks%20charting%20image%20export%20 %20apr%202nd%202019%209 45 49%20am

China Construction Bank (601939 CH) FY18 results reflected stability and some encouraging signs of positive fundamental momentum. The highlights were a positive “underlying jaws” of 220bps, fortified Capital Adequacy, enhanced Provisioning, and firmer net interest spread and margin. Liquidity remains prudent with credit and deposit growth both expanding by mid-single digits. In addition, the top-line exhibited solid growth with funding expense growth (an issue elsewhere) only mildly in excess of interest income growth. Sharply higher asset loan loss provisions reflected the ongoing battle with troubling systemic asset quality challenges.

CCB is committed to becoming a core comprehensive service provider for smart city development, in alignment with government strategic targets. In terms of technology, AI robots (in wealth management, for example), Intelligent Risk Management Platforms, Biometric verification plus a public and private “cloud ecosphere” are evolving. Big data is developing with data warehouse integrating internal and external data; with enterprise data management and application architecture; and via working platforms. CCB is wedded to IoT, blockchain as well as big data in industry chain finance, via internet-based “e Xin Tong”, “e Xin Tong” and “e Qi Tong”. The bank has a strategy of Mobile First, provision of internet-based smart financial services, booming WeChat banking, and integration of online banking services that combines transactions, sales, and customer service.

Automation and “intelligence” is the bedrock of risk management: the key area today of what is a highly leveraged system. Here, CCB is integrating corporate and retail early warning systems and unifying the monitoring of different exposures. Management launched a “new generation” retail customer scorecard model, elevating the level of automation and “intelligence” of risk metrics. In addition, the bank is attaining greater recognition and control of fraud. Regarding the remote monitoring system, CCB is adapting to the fast development of information, network and big data technology, by building a monitoring system with unified plans, standards, software and hardware.

While CCB trades at a P/Book of 0.8x (regional median, including Japan) and a franchise valuation of 9% (regional median, including Japan), the Earnings Yield of 17.4% is well in excess of regional median of 10%. The combination of a top decile PH Score™, capturing fundamental momentum, an underbought technical signal, and a reasonable franchise valuation position CCB in the top decile of opportunity globally. For a core strategic policy bank, this represents an opportunity.

4. Indonesia Property – In Search of the End of the Rainbow – Part 6 – Intiland Development (DILD IJ)

Dild%20in%20a%20map

In this series under Smartkarma Originals, CrossASEAN insight providers AngusMackintosh and Jessica Irene seek to determine whether or not we are close to the end of the rainbow and to a period of outperformance for the property sector. Our end conclusions will be based on a series of company visits to the major listed property companies in Indonesia, conversations with local banks, property agents, and other relevant channel checks. 

The sixth company that we explore is Intiland Development (DILD IJ), a property developer that focuses on landed residential, industrial estates, high-end condominiums, and offices in Jakarta and Surabaya. DILD has a good track record in building and operating high-end condominiums and offices. But the property market slowdown, tighter mortgage regulations, and rising construction costs took a massive toll on the company’s balance sheet and margin.

DILD shows the worst operating cashflow performance versus peers. The operating cashflow is running at a massive deficit after the property market peak in 2013, driven mostly by worsening working capital cycle. Both consolidated gross margin and EBIT margin are also trending down over the past five years, showing the company’s inability to pass on costs. The biggest margin decline is visible in the offices, landed residential, and condominiums. 

The total net asset value (NAV) for company’s landbank and investment properties is about IDR10.5tn, equivalent to IDR1,018 NAV per share. Despite an attractive Price-to-Book (PB) valuation and a chunky 65% discount to NAV, DILD still looks expensive on a Price-to-Earnings (PE) basis. Analysts have been downgrading earnings on lower margin expectation and weaker than expected cashflow generation that cause debt levels to remain high.

Consensus expects 16% EPS growth this year with revenues growing by 22%. We may see further downgrades post FY18 results as 9M18 EBIT only makes up 51% of consensus FY18 forecast. The government’s plan to reduce luxury taxes and allowing foreigners to hold strata title on Indonesian properties should bode well for DILD and serve as a potential catalyst in the short term. Our estimated fair value for DILD is at IDR 404 per share, suggesting 14% upside from the current levels.

5. Pan Pacific/Don Quijote: Bringing Joy into Shopping

Capture%203

  • Japanese Retail is in a secular decline: There are areas in retail that are worse affected than the rest
  • Falling foot traffic: The biggest problem for Japanese retail
  • Don Quijote’s recent history and growth potential
  • Attracting shoppers from multiple store formats helps Don Quijote to expand its target market
  • Don Quijote is least affected from slowdown in Chinese tourist spending
  • FamilyMart UNY store conversions to contribute to revenue and EBIT growth over the next five years
  • New store openings to cap at 25 per year because of UNY store conversions
  • Valuation: Market unjustly penalized Don Quijote for the UNY acquisition
  • Change in retail landscape to help make Don Quijote the “DON” in Japanese retail

Get Straight to the Source on Smartkarma

Smartkarma supports the world’s leading investors with high-quality, timely, and actionable Insights. Subscribe now for unlimited access, or request a demo below.



Brief Equities Bottom-Up: Huishang Bank: Subpar Earnings and Asset Quality Indicate Caution and more

By | Equity Bottom-Up

In this briefing:

  1. Huishang Bank: Subpar Earnings and Asset Quality Indicate Caution
  2. China Construction Bank: Not Strategically Dear
  3. Indonesia Property – In Search of the End of the Rainbow – Part 6 – Intiland Development (DILD IJ)
  4. Pan Pacific/Don Quijote: Bringing Joy into Shopping
  5. Mercari: Why Mercari Is Likely to Be a Winner in the Cashless Wars

1. Huishang Bank: Subpar Earnings and Asset Quality Indicate Caution

Huishang Bank Corp Ltd H (3698 HK) looks interesting at first. Some trends are moving in the right direction and the valuation is hardly stretched.

So it seems. Closer inspection reveals subpar earnings quality and pressure on the top line from an elevated growth in funding costs and a double-digit reduction in income from non-credit earning assets. Impairments weighed heavily on the bottom line. Underlying “jaws” were extremely negative, putting the decrease in the Cost-Income ratio into perspective.

An improving NPL ratio of 0.95% (or 1.04% depending on which one you use) does not tell the whole story at all. Asset quality issues, of course, come through in the income statement with writedowns and loan loss provisions consuming a huge (and increasing) chunk of pre-impairment profit. The Balance Sheet exhibits strains and stresses from an explosion of doubtful loans, rising substandard loans, and arguably an unhealthy expansion of special mention loans. At least “unimpaired past-due” loans have moderated though they stand at 45% of headline NPLs. Some key capitalisation metrics are deteriorating while liquidity erodes given the 23% growth in credit which flatters the problem loan picture.

2. China Construction Bank: Not Strategically Dear

China%20banks%20charting%20image%20export%20 %20apr%202nd%202019%209 45 49%20am

China Construction Bank (601939 CH) FY18 results reflected stability and some encouraging signs of positive fundamental momentum. The highlights were a positive “underlying jaws” of 220bps, fortified Capital Adequacy, enhanced Provisioning, and firmer net interest spread and margin. Liquidity remains prudent with credit and deposit growth both expanding by mid-single digits. In addition, the top-line exhibited solid growth with funding expense growth (an issue elsewhere) only mildly in excess of interest income growth. Sharply higher asset loan loss provisions reflected the ongoing battle with troubling systemic asset quality challenges.

CCB is committed to becoming a core comprehensive service provider for smart city development, in alignment with government strategic targets. In terms of technology, AI robots (in wealth management, for example), Intelligent Risk Management Platforms, Biometric verification plus a public and private “cloud ecosphere” are evolving. Big data is developing with data warehouse integrating internal and external data; with enterprise data management and application architecture; and via working platforms. CCB is wedded to IoT, blockchain as well as big data in industry chain finance, via internet-based “e Xin Tong”, “e Xin Tong” and “e Qi Tong”. The bank has a strategy of Mobile First, provision of internet-based smart financial services, booming WeChat banking, and integration of online banking services that combines transactions, sales, and customer service.

Automation and “intelligence” is the bedrock of risk management: the key area today of what is a highly leveraged system. Here, CCB is integrating corporate and retail early warning systems and unifying the monitoring of different exposures. Management launched a “new generation” retail customer scorecard model, elevating the level of automation and “intelligence” of risk metrics. In addition, the bank is attaining greater recognition and control of fraud. Regarding the remote monitoring system, CCB is adapting to the fast development of information, network and big data technology, by building a monitoring system with unified plans, standards, software and hardware.

While CCB trades at a P/Book of 0.8x (regional median, including Japan) and a franchise valuation of 9% (regional median, including Japan), the Earnings Yield of 17.4% is well in excess of regional median of 10%. The combination of a top decile PH Score™, capturing fundamental momentum, an underbought technical signal, and a reasonable franchise valuation position CCB in the top decile of opportunity globally. For a core strategic policy bank, this represents an opportunity.

3. Indonesia Property – In Search of the End of the Rainbow – Part 6 – Intiland Development (DILD IJ)

Dild%20pe

In this series under Smartkarma Originals, CrossASEAN insight providers AngusMackintosh and Jessica Irene seek to determine whether or not we are close to the end of the rainbow and to a period of outperformance for the property sector. Our end conclusions will be based on a series of company visits to the major listed property companies in Indonesia, conversations with local banks, property agents, and other relevant channel checks. 

The sixth company that we explore is Intiland Development (DILD IJ), a property developer that focuses on landed residential, industrial estates, high-end condominiums, and offices in Jakarta and Surabaya. DILD has a good track record in building and operating high-end condominiums and offices. But the property market slowdown, tighter mortgage regulations, and rising construction costs took a massive toll on the company’s balance sheet and margin.

DILD shows the worst operating cashflow performance versus peers. The operating cashflow is running at a massive deficit after the property market peak in 2013, driven mostly by worsening working capital cycle. Both consolidated gross margin and EBIT margin are also trending down over the past five years, showing the company’s inability to pass on costs. The biggest margin decline is visible in the offices, landed residential, and condominiums. 

The total net asset value (NAV) for company’s landbank and investment properties is about IDR10.5tn, equivalent to IDR1,018 NAV per share. Despite an attractive Price-to-Book (PB) valuation and a chunky 65% discount to NAV, DILD still looks expensive on a Price-to-Earnings (PE) basis. Analysts have been downgrading earnings on lower margin expectation and weaker than expected cashflow generation that cause debt levels to remain high.

Consensus expects 16% EPS growth this year with revenues growing by 22%. We may see further downgrades post FY18 results as 9M18 EBIT only makes up 51% of consensus FY18 forecast. The government’s plan to reduce luxury taxes and allowing foreigners to hold strata title on Indonesian properties should bode well for DILD and serve as a potential catalyst in the short term. Our estimated fair value for DILD is at IDR 404 per share, suggesting 14% upside from the current levels.

4. Pan Pacific/Don Quijote: Bringing Joy into Shopping

Capture%201%20v2

  • Japanese Retail is in a secular decline: There are areas in retail that are worse affected than the rest
  • Falling foot traffic: The biggest problem for Japanese retail
  • Don Quijote’s recent history and growth potential
  • Attracting shoppers from multiple store formats helps Don Quijote to expand its target market
  • Don Quijote is least affected from slowdown in Chinese tourist spending
  • FamilyMart UNY store conversions to contribute to revenue and EBIT growth over the next five years
  • New store openings to cap at 25 per year because of UNY store conversions
  • Valuation: Market unjustly penalized Don Quijote for the UNY acquisition
  • Change in retail landscape to help make Don Quijote the “DON” in Japanese retail

5. Mercari: Why Mercari Is Likely to Be a Winner in the Cashless Wars

Mercari%20qoq%20growth

While we have been sceptical about Mercari Inc (4385 JP)‘s efforts in the US, we have always appreciated the domestic business and have only been put off by the rather demanding multiples. After speaking to the company, we continue to like the domestic business and feel that recent initiatives to broaden the user base are likely to be successful. In addition, while we still feel that there are numerous question marks about whether the business model can work in the US, we have come around to a more positive view on the company’s execution there. Lastly, we believe Merpay’s edge in the cashless wars is underappreciated and the fall in the share price is starting to make the stock attractive.

We discuss the details below.

Get Straight to the Source on Smartkarma

Smartkarma supports the world’s leading investors with high-quality, timely, and actionable Insights. Subscribe now for unlimited access, or request a demo below.



Brief Equities Bottom-Up: China Construction Bank: Not Strategically Dear and more

By | Equity Bottom-Up

In this briefing:

  1. China Construction Bank: Not Strategically Dear
  2. Indonesia Property – In Search of the End of the Rainbow – Part 6 – Intiland Development (DILD IJ)
  3. Pan Pacific/Don Quijote: Bringing Joy into Shopping
  4. Mercari: Why Mercari Is Likely to Be a Winner in the Cashless Wars
  5. Notes from the Silk Road: Xtep Int’l Holdings (1368 HK): Time to Run (Away) For Now

1. China Construction Bank: Not Strategically Dear

China%20banks%20charting%20image%20export%20 %20apr%202nd%202019%209 45 49%20am

China Construction Bank (601939 CH) FY18 results reflected stability and some encouraging signs of positive fundamental momentum. The highlights were a positive “underlying jaws” of 220bps, fortified Capital Adequacy, enhanced Provisioning, and firmer net interest spread and margin. Liquidity remains prudent with credit and deposit growth both expanding by mid-single digits. In addition, the top-line exhibited solid growth with funding expense growth (an issue elsewhere) only mildly in excess of interest income growth. Sharply higher asset loan loss provisions reflected the ongoing battle with troubling systemic asset quality challenges.

CCB is committed to becoming a core comprehensive service provider for smart city development, in alignment with government strategic targets. In terms of technology, AI robots (in wealth management, for example), Intelligent Risk Management Platforms, Biometric verification plus a public and private “cloud ecosphere” are evolving. Big data is developing with data warehouse integrating internal and external data; with enterprise data management and application architecture; and via working platforms. CCB is wedded to IoT, blockchain as well as big data in industry chain finance, via internet-based “e Xin Tong”, “e Xin Tong” and “e Qi Tong”. The bank has a strategy of Mobile First, provision of internet-based smart financial services, booming WeChat banking, and integration of online banking services that combines transactions, sales, and customer service.

Automation and “intelligence” is the bedrock of risk management: the key area today of what is a highly leveraged system. Here, CCB is integrating corporate and retail early warning systems and unifying the monitoring of different exposures. Management launched a “new generation” retail customer scorecard model, elevating the level of automation and “intelligence” of risk metrics. In addition, the bank is attaining greater recognition and control of fraud. Regarding the remote monitoring system, CCB is adapting to the fast development of information, network and big data technology, by building a monitoring system with unified plans, standards, software and hardware.

While CCB trades at a P/Book of 0.8x (regional median, including Japan) and a franchise valuation of 9% (regional median, including Japan), the Earnings Yield of 17.4% is well in excess of regional median of 10%. The combination of a top decile PH Score™, capturing fundamental momentum, an underbought technical signal, and a reasonable franchise valuation position CCB in the top decile of opportunity globally. For a core strategic policy bank, this represents an opportunity.

2. Indonesia Property – In Search of the End of the Rainbow – Part 6 – Intiland Development (DILD IJ)

Dild%20recurring%20revenue%20portion

In this series under Smartkarma Originals, CrossASEAN insight providers AngusMackintosh and Jessica Irene seek to determine whether or not we are close to the end of the rainbow and to a period of outperformance for the property sector. Our end conclusions will be based on a series of company visits to the major listed property companies in Indonesia, conversations with local banks, property agents, and other relevant channel checks. 

The sixth company that we explore is Intiland Development (DILD IJ), a property developer that focuses on landed residential, industrial estates, high-end condominiums, and offices in Jakarta and Surabaya. DILD has a good track record in building and operating high-end condominiums and offices. But the property market slowdown, tighter mortgage regulations, and rising construction costs took a massive toll on the company’s balance sheet and margin.

DILD shows the worst operating cashflow performance versus peers. The operating cashflow is running at a massive deficit after the property market peak in 2013, driven mostly by worsening working capital cycle. Both consolidated gross margin and EBIT margin are also trending down over the past five years, showing the company’s inability to pass on costs. The biggest margin decline is visible in the offices, landed residential, and condominiums. 

The total net asset value (NAV) for company’s landbank and investment properties is about IDR10.5tn, equivalent to IDR1,018 NAV per share. Despite an attractive Price-to-Book (PB) valuation and a chunky 65% discount to NAV, DILD still looks expensive on a Price-to-Earnings (PE) basis. Analysts have been downgrading earnings on lower margin expectation and weaker than expected cashflow generation that cause debt levels to remain high.

Consensus expects 16% EPS growth this year with revenues growing by 22%. We may see further downgrades post FY18 results as 9M18 EBIT only makes up 51% of consensus FY18 forecast. The government’s plan to reduce luxury taxes and allowing foreigners to hold strata title on Indonesian properties should bode well for DILD and serve as a potential catalyst in the short term. Our estimated fair value for DILD is at IDR 404 per share, suggesting 14% upside from the current levels.

3. Pan Pacific/Don Quijote: Bringing Joy into Shopping

Capture%204

  • Japanese Retail is in a secular decline: There are areas in retail that are worse affected than the rest
  • Falling foot traffic: The biggest problem for Japanese retail
  • Don Quijote’s recent history and growth potential
  • Attracting shoppers from multiple store formats helps Don Quijote to expand its target market
  • Don Quijote is least affected from slowdown in Chinese tourist spending
  • FamilyMart UNY store conversions to contribute to revenue and EBIT growth over the next five years
  • New store openings to cap at 25 per year because of UNY store conversions
  • Valuation: Market unjustly penalized Don Quijote for the UNY acquisition
  • Change in retail landscape to help make Don Quijote the “DON” in Japanese retail

4. Mercari: Why Mercari Is Likely to Be a Winner in the Cashless Wars

Mercari%20qoq%20growth

While we have been sceptical about Mercari Inc (4385 JP)‘s efforts in the US, we have always appreciated the domestic business and have only been put off by the rather demanding multiples. After speaking to the company, we continue to like the domestic business and feel that recent initiatives to broaden the user base are likely to be successful. In addition, while we still feel that there are numerous question marks about whether the business model can work in the US, we have come around to a more positive view on the company’s execution there. Lastly, we believe Merpay’s edge in the cashless wars is underappreciated and the fall in the share price is starting to make the stock attractive.

We discuss the details below.

5. Notes from the Silk Road: Xtep Int’l Holdings (1368 HK): Time to Run (Away) For Now

Xtep International (1368 HK) has announced a placing and top-up subscription of new shares event, creating a capital base which is 9% larger. 

XTEP states that they have considered various ways of raising funds and consider that it would be in their best interests to raise equity funding through the placing and the subscription. 

With the share price down 16% since the placement, we examine what this means for the company’s fundamentals and shareholders. We believe the results will prove to be mixed for management and shareholders alike. We highlight how we expect the stock ranking to react, given we the placement was only a few days back and this is yet to reflect. This special situation analysis may surprise you with the conclusions.

Get Straight to the Source on Smartkarma

Smartkarma supports the world’s leading investors with high-quality, timely, and actionable Insights. Subscribe now for unlimited access, or request a demo below.



Brief Equities Bottom-Up: Rakuten (4755) Lyft Lifts Shares Price but There Is Much Further to Go. and more

By | Equity Bottom-Up

In this briefing:

  1. Rakuten (4755) Lyft Lifts Shares Price but There Is Much Further to Go.
  2. 58.com (WUBA): Weak Membership Growth Suggests More Volatile Performance, 17% Downside
  3. JKN: 4Q18 Earnings Grew Both YoY and QoQ
  4. 7-Eleven in India: Standard Franchise Model Would Require Minor Tweaks in India

1. Rakuten (4755) Lyft Lifts Shares Price but There Is Much Further to Go.

4755

Assuming a sum of the parts valuation the shares are cheap. We can assume the fintech business is worth perhaps Y800-900bn (based on 10x ebit, similar to Credit Saison), the domestic e-commerce operation (which makes an operating profit of about Y70bn on revenue of Y450bn) is worth perhaps Y1.2tr (assuming a valuation of 3x sales vs. 3.5x for Amazon). There are other parts of the business which detract and there are others, including a Y350bn plus investment portfolio which add but overall, all this compares with a market cap of a mere Y1.3tr. This suggests the market is thinking that Rakuten is more than throwing its MNO investment of Y600bn away. Given the Governments desire to reduce prices in the mobile market, and its desire for 4 operators, we would suggest this is overly negative. The recent announcement that Lyft will seek an IPO has lifted the share price given its 10% stake in this name (rumoured valuation of $23bn vs. $15bn currently), but we suspect the shares have much further to run. The market knows earnings will be depressed for the next 2 years or so but does not anticipate any recovery thereafter it would appear.

2. 58.com (WUBA): Weak Membership Growth Suggests More Volatile Performance, 17% Downside

Pic%206

* We believe that the stagnancy in membership was due to the new competitor Ke.com and will make total revenues more volatile in the future.

* We assume total revenues will slow down, but the operating margin will be stable in 2019.

* We compare WUBA’s expected P/E for 2019 with other vertical platforms in China and conclude 17% downside.

3. JKN: 4Q18 Earnings Grew Both YoY and QoQ

Jkn%20update%203

The company’s 4Q18 net profit was at Bt46m (+298%YoY and +8%QoQ). The result was in line with our 2018 forecast and accounted for 97% of our full-year forecast.

  • A YoY surge in earnings was due to a 30% increase in revenue to Bt360m, mainly from export revenue (50% revenue contribution in 3Q18 from 0% in 4Q17). A QoQ gain was caused a reduction in extra expenses for holding an annual event ‘JKN mega showcase’ in early August.
  • 2019 earnings outlook is still decent on the back of 1.) higher revenue contribution from export market especially South East Asia (26% of revenue in 2018), 2.) CNBC studio commencement in 2Q19, and, 3.) revenue recognition from new channel subscribers (No.5, Thairath, Spring news, True4U, Nation and MONO)

We maintain our forecast and BUY rating for JKN with a target price of Bt8.80 based on 14.8xPE’19E mean of the Asia ex-Japan Consumer Discretionary Sector.

4. 7-Eleven in India: Standard Franchise Model Would Require Minor Tweaks in India

Capture%201

  • 7-Eleven partners up with Future Retail in an effort to enter the growing Indian Market
  • Indian E-Commerce giants pose a significant threat to 7-Eleven’s plans
  • 7-Eleven’s recent shift focuses more on developing markets.
  • Lack of profitability in India could require changes to the standard franchise agreement in order to attract franchisees

On 28th February 2019, Seven & I Holdings (3382 JP), the operator of the world’s largest convenience store chain 7-Eleven, announced that the company has signed a master franchise agreement with Kishore Biyani’s Future Retail, the operator of the Indian large format store chain Big Bazaar, to expand the 7-Eleven convenience stores into India. Future Retail and Seven & I Holdings expect the first 7-Eleven convenience store in India to be opened in Mumbai in 2019.

Get Straight to the Source on Smartkarma

Smartkarma supports the world’s leading investors with high-quality, timely, and actionable Insights. Subscribe now for unlimited access, or request a demo below.



Brief Equities Bottom-Up: Indonesia Property – In Search of the End of the Rainbow – Part 6 – Intiland Development (DILD IJ) and more

By | Equity Bottom-Up

In this briefing:

  1. Indonesia Property – In Search of the End of the Rainbow – Part 6 – Intiland Development (DILD IJ)
  2. Pan Pacific/Don Quijote: Bringing Joy into Shopping
  3. Mercari: Why Mercari Is Likely to Be a Winner in the Cashless Wars
  4. Notes from the Silk Road: Xtep Int’l Holdings (1368 HK): Time to Run (Away) For Now
  5. Angang Steel: PMI Recovery to Support Shares: Close Short

1. Indonesia Property – In Search of the End of the Rainbow – Part 6 – Intiland Development (DILD IJ)

Dild%20recurring%20revenue%20portion

In this series under Smartkarma Originals, CrossASEAN insight providers AngusMackintosh and Jessica Irene seek to determine whether or not we are close to the end of the rainbow and to a period of outperformance for the property sector. Our end conclusions will be based on a series of company visits to the major listed property companies in Indonesia, conversations with local banks, property agents, and other relevant channel checks. 

The sixth company that we explore is Intiland Development (DILD IJ), a property developer that focuses on landed residential, industrial estates, high-end condominiums, and offices in Jakarta and Surabaya. DILD has a good track record in building and operating high-end condominiums and offices. But the property market slowdown, tighter mortgage regulations, and rising construction costs took a massive toll on the company’s balance sheet and margin.

DILD shows the worst operating cashflow performance versus peers. The operating cashflow is running at a massive deficit after the property market peak in 2013, driven mostly by worsening working capital cycle. Both consolidated gross margin and EBIT margin are also trending down over the past five years, showing the company’s inability to pass on costs. The biggest margin decline is visible in the offices, landed residential, and condominiums. 

The total net asset value (NAV) for company’s landbank and investment properties is about IDR10.5tn, equivalent to IDR1,018 NAV per share. Despite an attractive Price-to-Book (PB) valuation and a chunky 65% discount to NAV, DILD still looks expensive on a Price-to-Earnings (PE) basis. Analysts have been downgrading earnings on lower margin expectation and weaker than expected cashflow generation that cause debt levels to remain high.

Consensus expects 16% EPS growth this year with revenues growing by 22%. We may see further downgrades post FY18 results as 9M18 EBIT only makes up 51% of consensus FY18 forecast. The government’s plan to reduce luxury taxes and allowing foreigners to hold strata title on Indonesian properties should bode well for DILD and serve as a potential catalyst in the short term. Our estimated fair value for DILD is at IDR 404 per share, suggesting 14% upside from the current levels.

2. Pan Pacific/Don Quijote: Bringing Joy into Shopping

Capture%2011

  • Japanese Retail is in a secular decline: There are areas in retail that are worse affected than the rest
  • Falling foot traffic: The biggest problem for Japanese retail
  • Don Quijote’s recent history and growth potential
  • Attracting shoppers from multiple store formats helps Don Quijote to expand its target market
  • Don Quijote is least affected from slowdown in Chinese tourist spending
  • FamilyMart UNY store conversions to contribute to revenue and EBIT growth over the next five years
  • New store openings to cap at 25 per year because of UNY store conversions
  • Valuation: Market unjustly penalized Don Quijote for the UNY acquisition
  • Change in retail landscape to help make Don Quijote the “DON” in Japanese retail

3. Mercari: Why Mercari Is Likely to Be a Winner in the Cashless Wars

Mercari%20qoq%20growth

While we have been sceptical about Mercari Inc (4385 JP)‘s efforts in the US, we have always appreciated the domestic business and have only been put off by the rather demanding multiples. After speaking to the company, we continue to like the domestic business and feel that recent initiatives to broaden the user base are likely to be successful. In addition, while we still feel that there are numerous question marks about whether the business model can work in the US, we have come around to a more positive view on the company’s execution there. Lastly, we believe Merpay’s edge in the cashless wars is underappreciated and the fall in the share price is starting to make the stock attractive.

We discuss the details below.

4. Notes from the Silk Road: Xtep Int’l Holdings (1368 HK): Time to Run (Away) For Now

Xtep International (1368 HK) has announced a placing and top-up subscription of new shares event, creating a capital base which is 9% larger. 

XTEP states that they have considered various ways of raising funds and consider that it would be in their best interests to raise equity funding through the placing and the subscription. 

With the share price down 16% since the placement, we examine what this means for the company’s fundamentals and shareholders. We believe the results will prove to be mixed for management and shareholders alike. We highlight how we expect the stock ranking to react, given we the placement was only a few days back and this is yet to reflect. This special situation analysis may surprise you with the conclusions.

5. Angang Steel: PMI Recovery to Support Shares: Close Short

Pmi3

INVESTMENT VIEW:
The recovery in China’s March PMI index to 50.8 shows an unexpected expansion in economic activity.  Historically, there is a strong correlation between the PMI and Chinese steel prices as well as Angang’s share price. 

We close our short on Angang Steel Co Ltd (H) (347 HK) shares. 

Get Straight to the Source on Smartkarma

Smartkarma supports the world’s leading investors with high-quality, timely, and actionable Insights. Subscribe now for unlimited access, or request a demo below.



Brief Equities Bottom-Up: JKN: 4Q18 Earnings Grew Both YoY and QoQ and more

By | Equity Bottom-Up

In this briefing:

  1. JKN: 4Q18 Earnings Grew Both YoY and QoQ
  2. 7-Eleven in India: Standard Franchise Model Would Require Minor Tweaks in India

1. JKN: 4Q18 Earnings Grew Both YoY and QoQ

Jkn%20update%203

The company’s 4Q18 net profit was at Bt46m (+298%YoY and +8%QoQ). The result was in line with our 2018 forecast and accounted for 97% of our full-year forecast.

  • A YoY surge in earnings was due to a 30% increase in revenue to Bt360m, mainly from export revenue (50% revenue contribution in 3Q18 from 0% in 4Q17). A QoQ gain was caused a reduction in extra expenses for holding an annual event ‘JKN mega showcase’ in early August.
  • 2019 earnings outlook is still decent on the back of 1.) higher revenue contribution from export market especially South East Asia (26% of revenue in 2018), 2.) CNBC studio commencement in 2Q19, and, 3.) revenue recognition from new channel subscribers (No.5, Thairath, Spring news, True4U, Nation and MONO)

We maintain our forecast and BUY rating for JKN with a target price of Bt8.80 based on 14.8xPE’19E mean of the Asia ex-Japan Consumer Discretionary Sector.

2. 7-Eleven in India: Standard Franchise Model Would Require Minor Tweaks in India

Capture%201

  • 7-Eleven partners up with Future Retail in an effort to enter the growing Indian Market
  • Indian E-Commerce giants pose a significant threat to 7-Eleven’s plans
  • 7-Eleven’s recent shift focuses more on developing markets.
  • Lack of profitability in India could require changes to the standard franchise agreement in order to attract franchisees

On 28th February 2019, Seven & I Holdings (3382 JP), the operator of the world’s largest convenience store chain 7-Eleven, announced that the company has signed a master franchise agreement with Kishore Biyani’s Future Retail, the operator of the Indian large format store chain Big Bazaar, to expand the 7-Eleven convenience stores into India. Future Retail and Seven & I Holdings expect the first 7-Eleven convenience store in India to be opened in Mumbai in 2019.

Get Straight to the Source on Smartkarma

Smartkarma supports the world’s leading investors with high-quality, timely, and actionable Insights. Subscribe now for unlimited access, or request a demo below.